'Praying in your own words is better than using set prayers.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Christian teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some Christians would agree that praying in your own words is better. Informal prayer is personal: a Christian can tell God exactly how they feel, as a child talks to a loving parent, and Jesus taught his followers to call God 'Father'. Jesus also warned against 'vain repetitions' (Matthew 6:7), and set prayers can easily become words said on autopilot, especially when they are repeated every week. Praying in your own words means you can pray about real situations, such as a friend who is ill or a war in the news, which a set prayer might not mention. Many Evangelical and Pentecostal Christians believe that the Holy Spirit guides spontaneous prayer, as Paul says the Spirit helps believers when they do not know what to pray (Romans 8:26). Jesus himself often went off alone to pray (Mark 1:35), which suggests a personal conversation with God.
However, other Christians would disagree. Jesus himself gave his followers a set prayer, saying 'When ye pray, say, Our Father...' (Luke 11:2), so set prayer cannot be second best. Set prayers unite Christians: the Lord's Prayer is said by Catholics, Orthodox and Protestants all over the world, which shows that the Church is one body. They have been carefully written to express true Christian belief and to include every part of prayer, such as praise, confession and praying for others, whereas informal prayer can become self-centred or just a list of requests. Catholics and Orthodox Christians value set prayers such as the Rosary and the Jesus Prayer because repeating them helps the mind to rest on God, so repetition need not be 'vain'. Set prayers also help people who cannot find their own words, for example at a funeral; even Jesus used the words of Psalm 22 when he prayed on the cross.
Many Christians would say that both forms have value and that the attitude of the heart matters most. Jesus' warning in Matthew 6 was about praying to show off and saying words without meaning them, and that danger applies to informal prayer as much as to set prayer. Many Christians use both, joining in liturgical prayers on Sunday and praying in their own words at home.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Praying in your own words is valuable because it is personal, but it is not better in itself, because the prayer Jesus gave was a set prayer and set prayers can express what people feel when their own words fail. The best prayer is sincere prayer, whatever its form.
Explanation
Top-level answers weigh both sides with developed reasons and apply Christian teaching directly, for example Matthew 6:7 on empty repetition and Luke 11:2, where Jesus gives a set prayer. Showing different traditions - Pentecostal or Quaker informality and Catholic or Orthodox set prayer - strengthens the evaluation. Make sure the conclusion follows from your arguments rather than simply restating one side.