'Keeping people safe on a night out is the job of the police, not the Church.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Christian teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some people agree with this statement. The police are trained and paid to keep order and have legal powers that church volunteers do not have, such as the power to arrest. Keeping the public safe is the responsibility of the state, which is funded by taxes for this purpose, and if churches fill the gaps the government may feel less pressure to provide enough officers. Some Christians would also point to Paul's teaching in Romans 13 that rulers are given authority by God to keep order, and to Jesus' words 'Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar's'. They may also argue that the Church's main task is worship and preaching the gospel, so its limited time and volunteers should be used for that.
However, many Christians disagree. Street pastors, started by the Ascension Trust in London in 2003, do not try to replace the police: they work alongside them, offering care that officers may not have time to give, such as water, foil blankets or flip-flops, or simply staying with someone who is upset until friends arrive. Christians believe Jesus' command to love their neighbour applies to anyone in need. In the parable of the Good Samaritan, the priest and the Levite are criticised for passing by an injured man, which suggests that Christians cannot simply leave other people's safety to someone else. Jesus also spent time with outcasts and said he came 'to seek and to save that which was lost' (Luke 19:10), so the Church should be present in the places where people are most vulnerable, even at three in the morning.
It can also be argued that keeping a community safe is everyone's responsibility. Jeremiah told God's people to 'seek the peace of the city' where they lived, and street pastors are supported by prayer pastors who pray for the town while they patrol. Their presence shows that the Church cares about everyone, not just its members, which many Christians see as a powerful witness to God's love.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Enforcing the law is the job of the police, and Christians should support them in this. But keeping people safe involves more than enforcing the law: it also needs compassion, listening and practical care. Because Christian teaching makes love of neighbour a duty for every believer, the Church has a genuine part to play alongside the police rather than instead of them.
Explanation
A top-level answer weighs whether safety is only a matter of law or also a matter of Christian love, applying teachings such as the Good Samaritan or Romans 13 directly to the statement. Accurate detail about what street pastors actually do, and do not do, strengthens the evaluation. Avoid one-sided answers, and make sure the conclusion follows from the arguments you have weighed.