'Jesus' death was the only way for humans to be saved.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Christian teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many Christians would agree that Jesus' death was the only way for humans to be saved. Jesus said, 'no man cometh unto the Father, but by me' (John 14:6), and Peter preached that 'Neither is there salvation in any other' (Acts 4:12). Hebrews 9:22 teaches that 'without shedding of blood is no remission' of sins, so sin required a sacrifice, and Jesus, as the sinless Son of God, was the perfect sacrifice offered once for all. Anselm argued in Cur Deus Homo that human sin is a debt that humans owe but cannot pay, while only God could pay it, so only someone who was both God and human could make up for it. Many evangelical Christians believe in penal substitution: God's justice means that sin must be punished, and Jesus took that punishment in our place (Isaiah 53:5). In Gethsemane Jesus prayed that the cup of suffering might be taken away, but accepted the Father's will (Mark 14:36), which suggests there was no other way.
However, other Christians question this. God is omnipotent, so he could forgive sin without anyone dying. In the parable of the prodigal son (Luke 15), the father forgives his son freely, without demanding any payment, and Jesus forgave people's sins during his ministry, before his death (Mark 2:5). Many Christians also say salvation depends on Christ's whole work, not just his death: Paul says that 'if Christ be not raised ... ye are yet in your sins' (1 Corinthians 15:17), and Orthodox Christians stress that God became human so that humans could share in God's life, which makes the incarnation and resurrection just as important. Those who hold the moral influence view, following Abelard, believe the cross saves by showing God's love and changing people's hearts, so it was not a legal necessity. Some Christians are also uneasy with the idea that God needed a death before he could forgive, because it seems to conflict with his love.
In conclusion, I partly agree. For Christians, Jesus' death is central to salvation and cannot be removed from it, because the New Testament repeatedly links forgiveness to the cross. However, I do not think his death alone is the only way, because Christians believe that salvation comes from the whole of Christ's life, death and resurrection, received through God's grace, so the death is essential but not the whole story.
Explanation
Top-level answers use different understandings of the atonement, such as satisfaction, substitution and moral influence, to evaluate whether the cross was necessary, and consider the roles of the incarnation and resurrection. Apply sources such as Hebrews 9:22 and Luke 15 directly to the word 'only'. The conclusion should reach a clear judgement, not just list the theories.