'The bread and wine at Holy Communion are only symbols.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Christian teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some Christians would agree that the bread and wine are only symbols. Baptists and many other Evangelical Christians hold the memorial view, based on Jesus' words 'this do in remembrance of me' (Luke 22:19). For them the Lord's Supper is a meal of remembrance in which the bread reminds them of Jesus' body broken on the cross and the wine of his blood shed for their sins. They point out that Jesus often used metaphors, such as 'I am the door' (John 10:9) and 'I am the vine' (John 15:5), so when he said 'This is my body' he may have meant 'this represents my body'. The bread and wine clearly do not change in appearance or taste, and Article 28 of the Church of England's Thirty-Nine Articles rejects transubstantiation. For these Christians, what matters is the faith of the believer, not any change in the bread and wine.
However, Catholics would strongly disagree. They believe in transubstantiation: at the consecration the substance of the bread and wine becomes the body and blood of Christ, while the appearance remains (CCC 1376). This is why consecrated hosts are kept in the tabernacle and adored. Catholics take Jesus' words literally: he said 'This is my body' (Matthew 26:26) and 'my flesh is meat indeed' (John 6:55), and when many of his followers left him because they found this teaching hard, he did not call them back to explain it as a metaphor (John 6:66). Paul also warned that anyone who receives 'unworthily' is guilty of 'the body and blood of the Lord' (1 Corinthians 11:27), which would be strange if the bread were only a symbol. Orthodox Christians agree that Christ is truly present, though they call it a holy mystery rather than explaining how.
There are also views in between. Lutherans believe Christ is truly present 'in, with and under' the bread and wine, and many Anglicans and Methodists believe Christ is spiritually present to those who receive in faith. They would say the bread and wine are not 'only' symbols, because a sacrament is an outward sign through which God really gives grace.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. The memorial view is a serious Christian position with biblical support, but most Christians - Catholic, Orthodox, Lutheran and many Anglicans and Methodists - believe that Christ is present in some real way. The word 'only' is therefore too strong to describe what Holy Communion means for the majority of Christians.
Explanation
This statement needs accurate knowledge of the main interpretations: Catholic transubstantiation, Orthodox mystery, Lutheran presence, spiritual presence and the memorial view. Top answers analyse key texts such as Matthew 26:26, Luke 22:19 and John 6 rather than just naming views, and notice the force of the word 'only'. Avoid suggesting Catholics believe the bread looks or tastes like flesh.