'Christmas has lost its religious meaning in Great Britain today.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Christian teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
There is evidence that Christmas has lost much of its religious meaning in Great Britain. For many people Christmas is mainly about shopping, presents, food and time off work, and advertising begins weeks in advance, encouraging people to spend, sometimes more than they can afford. In the 2021 Census fewer than half of people in England and Wales described themselves as Christian, so many people celebrate Christmas with no religious belief at all. Popular symbols such as Father Christmas, reindeer and snowmen have nothing to do with the birth of Jesus, and most people do not go to church at Christmas. Some Christians campaign to 'keep Christ in Christmas', which suggests that they themselves believe its meaning is being lost.
However, there is also strong evidence that the religious meaning remains. Christmas is one of the busiest times of the year for churches, as people who rarely attend at other times go to Midnight Mass, carol services and Christingle services. Children in many schools still perform nativity plays, and carol services such as the Festival of Nine Lessons and Carols are broadcast across the country. Many carols, cards and decorations, such as the star and the crib, point to the story of Jesus' birth, and the monarch's Christmas message often refers to Christian faith. Even customs that seem non-religious can carry Christian meaning: giving presents can reflect God's gift of his Son (John 3:16), and many churches serve Christmas lunch for homeless or lonely people, following Jesus' concern for the poor.
Most importantly, for practising Christians the meaning of Christmas has not changed. They celebrate the incarnation, the belief that 'the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us' (John 1:14), and prepare for it through Advent with prayer and reflection. The fact that others celebrate in a different way does not remove the meaning for those who believe it.
In conclusion, I partly agree. For many people in Britain, Christmas has become a mainly secular holiday, so in society as a whole much of its religious meaning has been lost. However, it has not lost its religious meaning altogether, because churches are full at Christmas and Christians continue to celebrate the incarnation. It would be more accurate to say that Christmas now has two meanings in Britain, a religious one and a secular one, existing side by side.
Explanation
This statement is about Great Britain today, so top answers use evidence about British society, such as commercialisation and the 2021 Census on one side and full churches, nativity plays and carol services on the other. Apply Christian teaching, such as John 1:14 on the incarnation, to show what the religious meaning is. A justified conclusion might distinguish between society as a whole and practising Christians.