Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Practice
Course:
Topics:
Year 7 English Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
Grammar and punctuation
Unit 2
Spelling and vocabulary
Unit 3
Reading fiction
Unit 4
Poetry
Unit 5
Drama and Shakespeare
Unit 6
Reading non-fiction
Unit 7
Writing
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/47

Writing about a text: point, evidence, explain

Practise 20 questions on Writing about a text: point, evidence, explain for Year 7 English. Write your answer and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 20 questions
  • 1–8 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme.

Question 1

1 mark

Read this extract, then answer the question.

From Oliver Twist by Charles Dickens (1838; this version 1839)

(Oliver Twist, an orphan, has run away from the place where he was badly treated and has walked for seven days towards London. Tired and hungry, he is sitting on a doorstep in the town of Barnet when a boy he has never met comes up to him.)

"Hullo! my covey, what's the row?"

The boy who addressed this inquiry to the young wayfarer was about his own age, [...] He was a snub-nosed, flat-browed, common-faced boy enough, and as dirty a juvenile as one would wish to see; but he had about him all the airs and manners of a man. He was short of his age, with rather bow-legs, and little sharp ugly eyes. His hat was stuck on the top of his head so slightly that it threatened to fall off every moment, and would have done so very often if the wearer had not had a knack of every now and then giving his head a sudden twitch, which brought it back to its old place again. He wore a man's coat, which reached nearly to his heels. He had turned the cuffs back halfway up his arm to get his hands out of the sleeves, apparently with the ultimate view of thrusting them into the pockets of his corduroy trousers, for there he kept them. He was altogether as roystering and swaggering a young gentleman as ever stood four feet six, or something less, in his bluchers.

"Hullo, my covey, what's the row?" said this strange young gentleman to Oliver.

"I am very hungry and tired," replied Oliver, the tears standing in his eyes as he spoke. "I have walked a long way - I have been walking these seven days."

[...]

"[...] you want grub, and you shall have it. I'm at low-water-mark - only one bob and a magpie; but, as far as it goes, I'll fork out and stump. Up with you on your pins. [...]"

Assisting Oliver to rise, the young gentleman took him to an adjacent chandler's shop, where he purchased a sufficiency of ready-dressed ham and a half-quartern loaf [...]

Glossary: covey = mate (slang); what's the row? = what's the matter?; addressed this inquiry = asked this question; wayfarer = traveller; snub-nosed = with a short, turned-up nose; flat-browed = with a low, flat forehead; common-faced = with an ordinary face; juvenile = young person; airs and manners = way of behaving; short of his age = small for his age; bow-legs = legs that curve outwards; knack = clever habit; ultimate view = final aim; roystering = loud and lively; swaggering = behaving in a cocky, show-off way; four feet six = about 137 cm tall; bluchers = boots; grub = food; at low-water-mark = short of money; one bob and a magpie = a very small amount of money; fork out and stump = pay; pins = legs; adjacent = nearby; chandler's shop = a shop selling food and household goods; sufficiency = enough; ready-dressed = ready to eat; half-quartern loaf = a small loaf of bread

Look at this sentence from the second paragraph.

"He was a snub-nosed, flat-browed, common-faced boy enough, and as dirty a juvenile as one would wish to see; but he had about him all the airs and manners of a man."

A pupil wants to make the point that the boy behaves like a grown-up. Copy the shortest part of this sentence (no more than eight words) that supports this point.

Model answer

"all the airs and manners of a man"

Explanation

Good evidence is short and precise: only the last part of the sentence is about behaving like a grown-up, so there is no need to copy the rest. A short quotation is easier to embed in your own sentence and to explain word by word. A common mistake is to copy the whole sentence, which hides the important words.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    "all the airs and manners of a man" (or a shorter part of it, such as "airs and manners of a man" or "manners of a man")

    Accept any part of "all the airs and manners of a man" of up to eight words that includes "of a man". Do not accept the descriptions of his face or dirtiness ("snub-nosed", "common-faced", "as dirty a juvenile"), which do not show grown-up behaviour, or an answer of more than eight words.

Question 2

2 marks

Read this extract from a story, then answer the question.

Everyone on Albert Road was a little afraid of Mrs Kowalski at number 12. She shouted at footballs that bounced into her garden. She glared at the delivery drivers. When Sami's ball smashed one of her plant pots, she marched out with the pieces in her hands and said, "That pot was older than you, young man."

Sami did not go near number 12 for a month.

Then, on the coldest night of January, the power went off all along the street. Sami's family sat in the dark with blankets round their shoulders. Just after eight o'clock, there was a sharp knock at the door.

It was Mrs Kowalski. She was holding a huge flask of soup and a bag of candles, and her face was as stern as ever.

"You have a baby in this house," she said. "Babies should not be cold." She pushed the flask into Sami's mum's hands, turned and stomped back down the path before anyone could thank her.

Sami watched her go. For the first time, he noticed that she was limping.

A pupil is answering the question: How does the writer present Mrs Kowalski? Here is the start of their paragraph.

The writer shows that Mrs Kowalski is kinder than she first seems. She arrives on the coldest night of the year with "a huge flask of soup and a bag of candles". This suggests she has been thinking about her neighbours, even though she seemed so grumpy before.

Write one more sentence to finish the paragraph, linking back to the question.

Model answer

This shows that the writer presents Mrs Kowalski as someone whose stern, grumpy manner hides a kind and caring heart.

Explanation

The L in PEEL stands for Link: a final sentence that ties your paragraph back to the question. The best links sum up what you have shown in new words, here that her stern outside hides a kind heart. A common mistake is to copy the point again word for word, which adds nothing.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    a sentence that links back to the question: it says what the paragraph shows about how Mrs Kowalski is presented

    e.g. 'This shows that the writer presents her as someone whose strict manner hides a kind heart.' A sentence that adds a new quotation or retells another event without linking to the question does not earn this mark.

  2. 1 mark

    the link adds a final idea or sums up, rather than repeating the point word for word: e.g. her grumpy outside hides a caring nature / the reader's view of her changes / she is kind without wanting thanks or praise

    Award if the sentence develops or sums up the idea in new words. Do not award if it simply copies the first sentence ('The writer shows that Mrs Kowalski is kinder than she first seems').

Question 3

4 marks

Read this extract, then answer the question.

From Oliver Twist by Charles Dickens (1838; this version 1839)

(Oliver Twist, an orphan, has run away from the place where he was badly treated and has walked for seven days towards London. Tired and hungry, he is sitting on a doorstep in the town of Barnet when a boy he has never met comes up to him.)

"Hullo! my covey, what's the row?"

The boy who addressed this inquiry to the young wayfarer was about his own age, [...] He was a snub-nosed, flat-browed, common-faced boy enough, and as dirty a juvenile as one would wish to see; but he had about him all the airs and manners of a man. He was short of his age, with rather bow-legs, and little sharp ugly eyes. His hat was stuck on the top of his head so slightly that it threatened to fall off every moment, and would have done so very often if the wearer had not had a knack of every now and then giving his head a sudden twitch, which brought it back to its old place again. He wore a man's coat, which reached nearly to his heels. He had turned the cuffs back halfway up his arm to get his hands out of the sleeves, apparently with the ultimate view of thrusting them into the pockets of his corduroy trousers, for there he kept them. He was altogether as roystering and swaggering a young gentleman as ever stood four feet six, or something less, in his bluchers.

"Hullo, my covey, what's the row?" said this strange young gentleman to Oliver.

"I am very hungry and tired," replied Oliver, the tears standing in his eyes as he spoke. "I have walked a long way - I have been walking these seven days."

[...]

"[...] you want grub, and you shall have it. I'm at low-water-mark - only one bob and a magpie; but, as far as it goes, I'll fork out and stump. Up with you on your pins. [...]"

Assisting Oliver to rise, the young gentleman took him to an adjacent chandler's shop, where he purchased a sufficiency of ready-dressed ham and a half-quartern loaf [...]

Glossary: covey = mate (slang); what's the row? = what's the matter?; addressed this inquiry = asked this question; wayfarer = traveller; snub-nosed = with a short, turned-up nose; flat-browed = with a low, flat forehead; common-faced = with an ordinary face; juvenile = young person; airs and manners = way of behaving; short of his age = small for his age; bow-legs = legs that curve outwards; knack = clever habit; ultimate view = final aim; roystering = loud and lively; swaggering = behaving in a cocky, show-off way; four feet six = about 137 cm tall; bluchers = boots; grub = food; at low-water-mark = short of money; one bob and a magpie = a very small amount of money; fork out and stump = pay; pins = legs; adjacent = nearby; chandler's shop = a shop selling food and household goods; sufficiency = enough; ready-dressed = ready to eat; half-quartern loaf = a small loaf of bread

Here is a weak paragraph answering the question: How does Dickens present the boy?

The boy is weird. "He was a snub-nosed, flat-browed, common-faced boy enough, and as dirty a juvenile as one would wish to see; but he had about him all the airs and manners of a man. He was short of his age, with rather bow-legs, and little sharp ugly eyes." This shows that he is weird.

Rewrite the paragraph to improve it. Include a clear point, a short quotation, an explanation that zooms in on a word, and a link back to the question.

Model answer

Dickens presents the boy as a scruffy child who acts like a confident adult. Although he is "as dirty a juvenile as one would wish to see", he has "all the airs and manners of a man". The word "airs" suggests that he is putting on a grown-up act, behaving as if he is more important than he really is. This shows that Dickens presents him as a cocky, comical character who is pretending to be older than he is.

Explanation

The weak paragraph uses a vague word ('weird'), copies a long quotation and then repeats itself. To improve it, make a precise point, choose only the words you need, explain what one word suggests and finish by linking back to the question. A common mistake is to keep the long quotation and simply add more explanation after it.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Point: a clear, precise opening sentence about how the boy is presented, more exact than 'weird' (e.g. confident, cocky, scruffy, acts like a grown man, comical, streetwise)

    e.g. 'Dickens presents the boy as a scruffy child who acts like a confident adult.' Do not award this mark if the point is still only 'he is weird' or 'he is strange'.

  2. 1 mark

    Evidence: a short, relevant quotation (much shorter than the original), e.g. "all the airs and manners of a man" / "as dirty a juvenile as one would wish to see" / "swaggering" / "He wore a man's coat" / "thrusting them into the pockets" / "I'll fork out and stump"

    The quotation must be in quotation marks and support the point. Do not award this mark if the answer copies the whole long quotation again.

  3. 1 mark

    Explanation: zooms in on a word in the quotation and explains what it suggests about the boy, e.g. "airs" suggests he is putting on an act; "swaggering" suggests a cocky, show-off walk; the man's coat reaching "nearly to his heels" suggests a child dressing up as an adult

    The explanation must go beyond repeating the point (e.g. 'this shows he is confident' with no reason does not earn the mark).

  4. 1 mark

    Link: a final sentence that links back to the question (how Dickens presents the boy), e.g. 'This shows that Dickens presents him as a cocky boy pretending to be older than he is.'

    The link must refer back to the question; it should not just repeat the quotation.

Question 4

6 marks

Read this extract, then answer the question.

From Oliver Twist by Charles Dickens (1838; this version 1839)

(Oliver Twist, an orphan, has run away from the place where he was badly treated and has walked for seven days towards London. Tired and hungry, he is sitting on a doorstep in the town of Barnet when a boy he has never met comes up to him.)

"Hullo! my covey, what's the row?"

The boy who addressed this inquiry to the young wayfarer was about his own age, [...] He was a snub-nosed, flat-browed, common-faced boy enough, and as dirty a juvenile as one would wish to see; but he had about him all the airs and manners of a man. He was short of his age, with rather bow-legs, and little sharp ugly eyes. His hat was stuck on the top of his head so slightly that it threatened to fall off every moment, and would have done so very often if the wearer had not had a knack of every now and then giving his head a sudden twitch, which brought it back to its old place again. He wore a man's coat, which reached nearly to his heels. He had turned the cuffs back halfway up his arm to get his hands out of the sleeves, apparently with the ultimate view of thrusting them into the pockets of his corduroy trousers, for there he kept them. He was altogether as roystering and swaggering a young gentleman as ever stood four feet six, or something less, in his bluchers.

"Hullo, my covey, what's the row?" said this strange young gentleman to Oliver.

"I am very hungry and tired," replied Oliver, the tears standing in his eyes as he spoke. "I have walked a long way - I have been walking these seven days."

[...]

"[...] you want grub, and you shall have it. I'm at low-water-mark - only one bob and a magpie; but, as far as it goes, I'll fork out and stump. Up with you on your pins. [...]"

Assisting Oliver to rise, the young gentleman took him to an adjacent chandler's shop, where he purchased a sufficiency of ready-dressed ham and a half-quartern loaf [...]

Glossary: covey = mate (slang); what's the row? = what's the matter?; addressed this inquiry = asked this question; wayfarer = traveller; snub-nosed = with a short, turned-up nose; flat-browed = with a low, flat forehead; common-faced = with an ordinary face; juvenile = young person; airs and manners = way of behaving; short of his age = small for his age; bow-legs = legs that curve outwards; knack = clever habit; ultimate view = final aim; roystering = loud and lively; swaggering = behaving in a cocky, show-off way; four feet six = about 137 cm tall; bluchers = boots; grub = food; at low-water-mark = short of money; one bob and a magpie = a very small amount of money; fork out and stump = pay; pins = legs; adjacent = nearby; chandler's shop = a shop selling food and household goods; sufficiency = enough; ready-dressed = ready to eat; half-quartern loaf = a small loaf of bread

Write two PEE paragraphs answering this question: How does Dickens present the boy as both a grown-up and a child?

Model answer

Dickens presents the boy as someone who acts like a confident grown-up. He has "all the airs and manners of a man", and the word "airs" suggests he is putting on an act to seem important. He is described as "swaggering", which suggests a cocky, show-off walk, and he takes charge of Oliver at once, saying "you want grub, and you shall have it" and paying for the food himself. This shows that he behaves like an adult who knows how the world works.

However, Dickens also reminds us that he is really a child. He is "about his own age" and "short of his age", and Dickens jokes that he stands "four feet six, or something less". His "man's coat" reaches "nearly to his heels", which makes him seem like a little boy dressing up in his father's clothes, and his hat "threatened to fall off every moment". These comic details show that his grown-up manner is partly a performance, so Dickens presents him as both a streetwise young man and a small, scruffy boy.

Explanation

When a question asks about two sides of a character, give each side its own PEE paragraph. Dickens's humour comes from the contrast between the boy's confident "airs" and comic details such as the coat reaching "nearly to his heels". A common mistake is to write only about one side, or to quote long sentences without explaining particular words.

Mark scheme
  1. 6 marks

    Levels of response (6 marks).
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): Two clear PEE paragraphs (for example one on the grown-up side and one on the child side): each makes a clear point that answers the question, supports it with a short, well-chosen quotation (ideally embedded) and explains how specific words present the boy, with a link back to the question; subject terms help but are not essential.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Paragraphs with relevant points and quotations and some explanation, but the explanation may be general or partly retell the extract; quotations may be long or not embedded.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Simple points, mostly retelling, with little or only general evidence and little explanation.
    0 marks: Nothing relevant.

    Max 4 if the answer has only one PEE paragraph. Max 4 if the answer writes only about the grown-up side or only about the child side. Indicative content (not a checklist; credit any valid points about this extract):
    - Grown-up: "all the airs and manners of a man" ("airs" suggests an act); "He wore a man's coat"; "swaggering a young gentleman" (cocky, confident walk); "thrusting them into the pockets" (a confident, adult pose); he takes charge: "you want grub, and you shall have it", "Up with you on your pins"; he pays: "I'll fork out and stump" and "purchased" the food; his slang ("my covey", "what's the row?") makes him sound streetwise.
    - Child: "about his own age"; "short of his age"; "four feet six, or something less" (Dickens makes fun of his size); the coat "reached nearly to his heels" (too big, like a child dressing up); the hat "threatened to fall off every moment" and needs a "sudden twitch" (comic); "as dirty a juvenile as one would wish to see".
    - The effect: "young gentleman" is used humorously; the mix makes him comic and likeable, but also a little suspicious, because a child acting like a man may be up to something.
    Level guide for this question: Level 1, e.g. 'He is a boy but he acts like a man', with little or no quotation. Level 2: two points with quotations and some explanation, but general (e.g. 'he wears a man's coat, which shows he wants to be grown up'). Level 3: two well-organised paragraphs, each with a precise point, a short embedded quotation and explanation of specific words (e.g. 'airs', 'swaggering', 'nearly to his heels', 'something less'), linked back to the question. Spelling does not affect the mark.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Topic notes

Writing about a text: point, evidence, explain

The big idea

When you write about a story, you need to do more than say what happens. An analytical paragraph makes a point about the text, proves it with a quotation, then explains how that quotation shows it. PEE (Point, Evidence, Explain) and PEEL (with a Link at the end) help you remember the order.

The four parts

PartIts jobSentence starters
Pointanswers the question in one clear sentenceThe writer presents Ruby as... / The writer shows that...
Evidencea few words from the text that support the pointShe "..." / When he "..."
Explain (or Explanation)says how the quotation proves the point, often by zooming in on one wordThe verb "..." suggests... / This implies...
Linksums up and returns to the questionOverall, the writer makes the reader see Ruby as...

Choosing a quotation

  • Short: usually between one and eight words. Leave out any words that do not help your point.
  • Relevant: it must prove your point, not simply be from the correct section.
  • Exact: copy the words and spellings exactly, inside quotation marks.

Embedding a quotation

An embedded quotation is woven into a sentence you have written, so the evidence and your words read as one.

  • Not embedded: Ruby is jealous. Here is a quotation: "she snatched the trophy".
  • Embedded: Ruby's jealousy shows when she "snatched the trophy" from her sister.

Read your sentence aloud: it should make sense with the quotation inside it. Put quotation marks round the writer's words only.

Explain, don't retell

Retelling says what happens. Explaining says how the writer creates an idea or impression, and what the words suggest. If a sentence of yours could fit in a summary, it is probably retelling.

  • Retelling: Ruby takes the trophy from her sister.
  • Explaining: The verb "snatched" suggests a sudden, greedy grab, which shows how badly Ruby wants what her sister has.

Make your explanations precise with subject terms: the correct names for features, such as verb, adjective, adverb, simile, repetition and contrast. Use them accurately: mixing up an adverb and an adjective weakens your point.

More than one paragraph

For a longer answer, give each new point its own paragraph, and join the paragraphs with connectives such as Also, However and Finally.

A model PEEL paragraph

Marcus hovered outside the head teacher's office, clutching the envelope. Twice he raised his hand to knock, and twice it dropped back to his side. At last he knocked, so softly that he could barely hear it himself.

Question: How is Marcus shown to be nervous?

Model answer: The writer shows that Marcus is nervous about seeing the head teacher. He "hovered" outside the office, and the verb "hovered" suggests that he hangs in the air without landing, as if he cannot decide whether to go in or run away. The repetition of "twice" shows that he loses his courage again and again. When he finally knocks, he does it "so softly" that he "could barely hear it", which hints that part of him hopes nobody will answer. Overall, Marcus is presented as so anxious that he can hardly make himself go in.

  • Point: the first sentence.
  • Evidence: "hovered", "twice", "so softly" and "could barely hear it", all embedded.
  • Explain: what each quotation suggests, zooming in on "hovered".
  • Link: the last sentence.

Improve a weak paragraph

Weak: Marcus is "very nervous" about seeing the head teacher. His hand "dropped back to his side". The adjective "dropped" shows that he is nervous.

What is wrong: "very nervous" are the pupil's own words, so they should not be in quotation marks; "dropped" is a verb, not an adjective; and the explanation only repeats the point.

Better: Marcus's fear shows when his hand "dropped back to his side" twice. The verb "dropped" suggests that his courage drains away, as if his arm suddenly feels too heavy to lift.

Remember

  • Point, Evidence, Explain, Link.
  • Keep quotations short and embed them in your own sentences.
  • Explain what the words suggest: zoom in on one word.
  • Use subject terms, and use them correctly.

Common mistakes

  • Retelling events instead of explaining the writer's methods.
  • Copying a long quotation, so the key words get lost.
  • Writing an explanation that just repeats the point, such as This shows he is scared.
  • Putting quotation marks round your own words instead of the writer's.
  • Choosing a quotation that proves a different point.

Top tip

Count the words in your quotation. If there are more than eight, cut it down to the few words that really prove your point.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.