Read the two texts, then answer the question.
Text A
From Records of a Girlhood by Fanny Kemble (1878)
(Fanny Kemble, a famous young actress, wrote this letter to a friend in August 1830, the day after George Stephenson, the engineer who built the new railway between Liverpool and Manchester, took her for a ride on one of the first steam trains. The railway had not yet opened to the public. She published her letters many years later.)
We were introduced to the little engine which was to drag us along the rails. She (for they make these curious little fire-horses all mares) consisted of a boiler, a stove, a small platform, a bench, and behind the bench a barrel containing enough water to prevent her being thirsty for fifteen miles, - the whole machine not bigger than a common fire-engine. [...] This snorting little animal, which I felt rather inclined to pat, was then harnessed to our carriage, and, Mr. Stephenson having taken me on the bench of the engine with him, we started at about ten miles an hour. [...] You can't imagine how strange it seemed to be journeying on thus, without any visible cause of progress other than the magical machine, with its flying white breath and rhythmical, unvarying pace [...].
[...] the carriage was placed behind it, for it cannot turn, and was set off at its utmost speed, thirty-five miles an hour, swifter than a bird flies (for they tried the experiment with a snipe). You cannot conceive what that sensation of cutting the air was; the motion is as smooth as possible, too. I could either have read or written; and as it was, I stood up, and with my bonnet off "drank the air before me." [...] When I closed my eyes this sensation of flying was quite delightful, and strange beyond description; yet, strange as it was, I had a perfect sense of security, and not the slightest fear.
Glossary: drag = pull; mares = female horses; boiler = the tank where water is heated to make steam; common fire-engine = an ordinary horse-drawn fire pump; harnessed = attached, as a horse is to a cart; without any visible cause of progress = with nothing you could see making you move; flying white breath = the steam; rhythmical, unvarying pace = steady speed; utmost = greatest; snipe = a fast-flying bird; conceive = imagine; bonnet = a hat tied under the chin; drank the air before me = a line from Shakespeare: she breathed in the rushing air; security = safety
Text B
The 7.42 to nowhere - a blog post by Dev, a train commuter, written today
Another Monday, another "delay due to signalling problems". I have now spent so long on Platform 3 that the pigeons know me by name.
When the 7.42 finally crawled in, twenty-three minutes late, it had four carriages instead of eight. Four. So two hundred of us squeezed on like toothpaste being pushed back into the tube. I spent the journey with my nose pressed into a stranger's rucksack, while the train lurched and squealed every time it braked.
Don't get me wrong: I loved trains when I was little. My grandad used to take me to the station just to watch them thunder past. But there is nothing magical about paying more than a hundred pounds a week to stand in a metal box that smells of damp coats and someone else's breakfast.
The railway companies keep promising faster, more reliable trains. I'll believe it when I see it. Until then, if anyone needs me, I'll be on Platform 3, making friends with the pigeons.
Glossary: commuter = someone who travels to work every day
Both writers use the word "magical": Fanny Kemble calls the engine "the magical machine", but Dev says "there is nothing magical" about his train journeys. Explain what this difference shows about their views of train travel.