Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Practice
Course:
Topics:
Year 7 English Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
Grammar and punctuation
Unit 2
Spelling and vocabulary
Unit 3
Reading fiction
Unit 4
Poetry
Unit 5
Drama and Shakespeare
Unit 6
Reading non-fiction
Unit 7
Writing
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/47

Comparing viewpoints

Practise 15 questions on Comparing viewpoints for Year 7 English. Write your answer and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 15 questions
  • 1–8 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
15 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme.

Question 1

1 mark

When you compare two texts, connectives help you to show similarities and differences.

Which of these connectives shows a similarity?

Choose your answer.

  • however
  • in contrast
  • on the other hand
  • similarly

Model answer

similarly

Explanation

"Similarly" shows that two writers share an idea, for example: 'Writer A is worried about plastic. Similarly, Writer B wants to recycle more.' The other connectives introduce a contrast. A common mistake is to choose 'on the other hand' because it sounds like a link: it actually introduces the opposite view.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    similarly

    Do not accept more than one of the four options. Do not accept however, in contrast or on the other hand, which all show a difference.

Question 2

2 marks

Read the two texts, then answer the question.

Text A

From Records of a Girlhood by Fanny Kemble (1878)

(Fanny Kemble, a famous young actress, wrote this letter to a friend in August 1830, the day after George Stephenson, the engineer who built the new railway between Liverpool and Manchester, took her for a ride on one of the first steam trains. The railway had not yet opened to the public. She published her letters many years later.)

We were introduced to the little engine which was to drag us along the rails. She (for they make these curious little fire-horses all mares) consisted of a boiler, a stove, a small platform, a bench, and behind the bench a barrel containing enough water to prevent her being thirsty for fifteen miles, - the whole machine not bigger than a common fire-engine. [...] This snorting little animal, which I felt rather inclined to pat, was then harnessed to our carriage, and, Mr. Stephenson having taken me on the bench of the engine with him, we started at about ten miles an hour. [...] You can't imagine how strange it seemed to be journeying on thus, without any visible cause of progress other than the magical machine, with its flying white breath and rhythmical, unvarying pace [...].

[...] the carriage was placed behind it, for it cannot turn, and was set off at its utmost speed, thirty-five miles an hour, swifter than a bird flies (for they tried the experiment with a snipe). You cannot conceive what that sensation of cutting the air was; the motion is as smooth as possible, too. I could either have read or written; and as it was, I stood up, and with my bonnet off "drank the air before me." [...] When I closed my eyes this sensation of flying was quite delightful, and strange beyond description; yet, strange as it was, I had a perfect sense of security, and not the slightest fear.

Glossary: drag = pull; mares = female horses; boiler = the tank where water is heated to make steam; common fire-engine = an ordinary horse-drawn fire pump; harnessed = attached, as a horse is to a cart; without any visible cause of progress = with nothing you could see making you move; flying white breath = the steam; rhythmical, unvarying pace = steady speed; utmost = greatest; snipe = a fast-flying bird; conceive = imagine; bonnet = a hat tied under the chin; drank the air before me = a line from Shakespeare: she breathed in the rushing air; security = safety

Text B

The 7.42 to nowhere - a blog post by Dev, a train commuter, written today

Another Monday, another "delay due to signalling problems". I have now spent so long on Platform 3 that the pigeons know me by name.

When the 7.42 finally crawled in, twenty-three minutes late, it had four carriages instead of eight. Four. So two hundred of us squeezed on like toothpaste being pushed back into the tube. I spent the journey with my nose pressed into a stranger's rucksack, while the train lurched and squealed every time it braked.

Don't get me wrong: I loved trains when I was little. My grandad used to take me to the station just to watch them thunder past. But there is nothing magical about paying more than a hundred pounds a week to stand in a metal box that smells of damp coats and someone else's breakfast.

The railway companies keep promising faster, more reliable trains. I'll believe it when I see it. Until then, if anyone needs me, I'll be on Platform 3, making friends with the pigeons.

Glossary: commuter = someone who travels to work every day

Both writers use the word "magical": Fanny Kemble calls the engine "the magical machine", but Dev says "there is nothing magical" about his train journeys. Explain what this difference shows about their views of train travel.

Model answer

For Fanny Kemble, the train seems like a "magical machine" because it is brand new and nothing like it has existed before, so she is full of wonder. For Dev, "there is nothing magical" about trains because they are now an ordinary, crowded and expensive part of his daily life. The difference shows how something that once seemed amazing has become a frustrating everyday routine.

Explanation

Looking at how two writers use the same word is a sharp way to compare their viewpoints. Kemble's "magical" shows wonder at a new invention, while Dev's "nothing magical" shows that the wonder has been replaced by frustration. For full marks, explain both writers' views. A common mistake is to explain only one text.

Mark scheme
  1. 2 marks

    explains the difference: for Kemble, the train is new, amazing and full of wonder, like magic, because nothing like it had existed before / for Dev, train travel is ordinary, expensive and unpleasant, so all the magic has gone / this shows how something that once seemed a miracle has become an everyday, frustrating part of life

    Award 2 marks for explaining both views: what "magical" shows about Kemble's wonder or amazement AND what "nothing magical" shows about Dev's frustration or disappointment, e.g. 'Kemble is amazed by the train because it is new and seems like magic, whereas Dev finds trains crowded and expensive, so to him they are not special at all'. Award 1 mark for explaining only one writer's view, or for a simple contrast with no explanation (e.g. 'she likes trains and he doesn't'). Reference to the time difference (1830 and today) is creditworthy but not required.

Question 3

4 marks

Read the two texts, then answer the question.

Text A

A letter to parents from the head teacher of Kingsway School

Dear Parents and Carers,

From September, pupils at Kingsway School will not be allowed to use mobile phones during the school day. Phones must be switched off and kept in pupils' bags from 8.30am until 3.15pm.

We have not made this decision lightly. Over the past year, teachers have told us that phones are distracting pupils in lessons, and arguments that start online are often spilling over into the classroom. At lunchtime, too many pupils sit side by side staring at screens instead of talking or playing.

We believe that school should be a place where young people can concentrate, make real friendships and have a break from the pressure of social media. Many schools with similar rules report calmer corridors and livelier playgrounds.

If you need to contact your child urgently, please phone the school office, which is open all day.

Thank you for your support.

Yours faithfully,

Mrs A. Hughes
Head Teacher

Text B

An article from the Kingsway School magazine

Banning phones won't solve anything - by Kian, Year 8

Next term, our phones are going to be locked away in our bags all day. The school says this will make us calmer and friendlier. I'm not so sure.

For a start, my mum works shifts, and sometimes she needs to message me during the day to tell me whether I'm going to my nan's after school. If my phone is switched off, how will I know where to go?

Phones aren't just for games, either. I use mine to check my homework planner, to look up words I don't know and to listen to revision podcasts. Taking them away treats us all like toddlers who can't be trusted.

I agree that some people spend far too long on their screens at lunch. But surely the answer is to teach us how to use phones sensibly, not to pretend they don't exist. We will need to manage them for the rest of our lives.

So here's my suggestion: let's have phone-free lessons, but let us use our phones at break and lunch. That way, everyone wins.

Write a short paragraph comparing the two writers' views about phones in school. Use at least one comparative connective and evidence from both texts.

Model answer

The head teacher thinks pupils should not use phones at all during the school day, because "phones are distracting pupils in lessons" and pupils spend lunchtime "staring at screens". In contrast, Kian thinks a complete ban is unfair, because phones are useful for homework and contacting his mum, and he says it "treats us all like toddlers who can't be trusted". However, they do agree on one thing: both think pupils spend too long on screens at lunch. The difference is that the head teacher's answer is a ban, whereas Kian wants pupils to be taught "how to use phones sensibly", with phone-free lessons as a compromise.

Explanation

A good short comparison states each writer's view, backs each one up with evidence and links them with comparative connectives such as 'In contrast' and 'whereas'. The best answers also notice where the writers agree, here on lunchtime screen use, and explain exactly where they differ. A common mistake is to write about one text and then the other without ever linking them.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    states the head teacher's view with evidence from Text A: she thinks phones should not be used during the school day, because they distract pupils / cause arguments / stop pupils talking or playing (e.g. "phones are distracting pupils in lessons", "too many pupils sit side by side staring at screens")

    The view must be accurate and supported by a quotation or close reference from Text A.

  2. 1 mark

    states Kian's view with evidence from Text B: he thinks a full ban is unfair or will not work, because phones are useful and pupils should be trusted or taught to use them sensibly (e.g. "Banning phones won't solve anything", "treats us all like toddlers who can't be trusted", "teach us how to use phones sensibly")

    The view must be accurate and supported by a quotation or close reference from Text B.

  3. 1 mark

    uses at least one suitable comparative connective to link the two views: whereas / while / however / in contrast / on the other hand / unlike / similarly / both

    The connective must be used correctly to show a difference or similarity between the two writers (e.g. 'whereas Kian thinks ...'). A connective used only within one text does not score.

  4. 1 mark

    makes a developed comparison: explains the difference clearly, or notes a similarity as well as the difference (e.g. both agree there is a problem with screens at lunch, but they disagree about the answer; or Kian wants phone-free lessons, which is a compromise with the head teacher's rule)

    Award this mark for a comparison that goes beyond two separate statements, e.g. by noting where they agree or how Kian's suggestion is a compromise, or by clearly explaining why their views differ. Two views placed side by side with a connective but no further comment do not score this mark.

Question 4

6 marks

Read the two texts, then answer the question.

Text A

Why our zoo matters - by Sam Okoro, head keeper at Ridgeway Zoo

People sometimes ask me whether zoos should exist at all. My answer is always the same: a good zoo is one of the best friends wild animals have.

Take our red pandas. In the wild, their forests are being cut down and their numbers are falling. Here, they are part of a breeding programme shared by zoos across Europe. Last spring, we celebrated the birth of twin cubs, Bao and Mei. Every cub born in a zoo is a safety net for the species.

Zoos also teach. Every year, around 40,000 schoolchildren visit Ridgeway. Most of them will never see a red panda in the Himalayas, but here they can watch one climb, eat and sleep just metres away. You cannot care about an animal you have never seen.

Of course, zoos must be good zoos. Our animals have large, natural enclosures, and our vets check every one of them regularly. A cramped cage is never acceptable.

So next time you visit, remember: your ticket helps to protect animals in the wild.

Text B

A letter to the Ridgeway Gazette

Dear Editor,

I read with sadness your article praising Ridgeway Zoo. I visited last month, and I came away feeling sick at heart.

The keepers were friendly, and the enclosures were clean. But no enclosure, however large, can replace the wild. I watched a tiger pace up and down the same strip of grass, again and again, for twenty minutes. In the wild, a tiger may roam across many miles of forest. At Ridgeway, it has a field and a fence.

Supporters say zoos protect endangered animals. Some do. But many of the animals I saw, such as the meerkats, are not endangered at all: they are there because they are popular and sell tickets. Surely the money would do more good protecting forests and wild animals in their real homes?

And what are children really learning? That it is acceptable to keep animals behind glass for our entertainment.

I urge your readers to think twice before buying a ticket. Instead, give that money to a charity that protects animals where they belong: in the wild.

Yours faithfully,

Rosa Delgado

Glossary: species = a type of animal; enclosures = the areas where zoo animals live; endangered = in danger of dying out

Compare how the two writers get their views about zoos across to the reader.

Model answer

Sam Okoro believes that "a good zoo is one of the best friends wild animals have", whereas Rosa Delgado thinks that "no enclosure, however large, can replace the wild".

Both writers use a single animal to make their point, but they choose very different examples. Sam describes the red panda cubs "Bao and Mei"; naming them makes them appealing and shows that zoos help endangered species to breed. In contrast, Rosa describes a tiger that paced "up and down the same strip of grass, again and again", which makes the zoo seem cruel and boring for the animal. She sharpens this with a contrast between "many miles of forest" and "a field and a fence".

The writers also disagree about what children learn. Sam says "You cannot care about an animal you have never seen", suggesting that zoos make children care about wildlife. Rosa, on the other hand, asks the rhetorical question "what are children really learning?" and answers that they learn "it is acceptable to keep animals behind glass for our entertainment".

Interestingly, both writers admit a point to the other side, which makes them seem fair. Sam accepts that "A cramped cage is never acceptable", and similarly Rosa admits that "The keepers were friendly, and the enclosures were clean" before arguing back. Finally, both end by telling the reader what to do with their money: Sam says "your ticket helps to protect animals in the wild", while Rosa urges readers to "think twice before buying a ticket" and give to a charity instead. Sam's tone is confident and proud, whereas Rosa's is sad and disapproving.

Explanation

To compare how writers get their views across, look at the examples they choose, their evidence, how they deal with the other side, their tone and how they end. The best answers move between the two texts point by point, using connectives such as 'whereas', 'in contrast' and 'similarly'. A common mistake is to explain each text separately without comparing, or to compare only what they think and not how they persuade.

Mark scheme
  1. 6 marks

    Levels of response (6 marks).
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): Clearly compares the writers' views and how they get them across, with well-chosen short quotations from both texts; comments on specific choices (such as examples, anecdotes, statistics, rhetorical questions, tone and endings) and links the texts throughout with comparative connectives.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Some comparison of the writers' views and methods, with relevant quotations from both texts; some comment on how the views are conveyed.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Simple comments on one or both texts, mostly retelling their views, with little or only general evidence and little comparison.
    0 marks: Nothing relevant.

    Max 3 if the answer writes about only one text.
    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit any valid comparisons):
    - Views: Sam is for (good) zoos: "a good zoo is one of the best friends wild animals have"; Rosa is against them: "no enclosure, however large, can replace the wild".
    - Who they are: Sam writes as an expert insider ("head keeper"), which gives authority; Rosa writes as a visitor who saw it for herself ("I visited last month").
    - Examples: Sam chooses a positive example, the red panda cubs "Bao and Mei" (naming them makes them appealing); Rosa chooses a distressing one, the tiger pacing "again and again".
    - Facts and statistics: Sam uses "around 40,000 schoolchildren" and the European breeding programme; Rosa contrasts "many miles of forest" with "a field and a fence".
    - Answering the other side: Sam admits "zoos must be good zoos" and "A cramped cage is never acceptable"; Rosa admits "The keepers were friendly" and "Some do" before arguing back with "But": both concede a point, which makes them seem fair.
    - Rhetorical questions: Rosa uses "Surely the money would do more good ...?" and "what are children really learning?"; Sam uses statements of certainty ("My answer is always the same").
    - Education: they disagree about what children learn: Sam says "You cannot care about an animal you have never seen"; Rosa says children learn "it is acceptable to keep animals behind glass for our entertainment".
    - Tone: Sam is confident and proud; Rosa is sad and disapproving ("sick at heart").
    - Endings: both end by telling the reader what to do with their money: Sam says "your ticket helps"; Rosa says "think twice before buying a ticket" and give to a charity instead.
    Level guide for this question: Level 1, e.g. 'Sam likes zoos and Rosa doesn't', with little evidence or comment on methods. Level 2: compares the views with relevant quotations from both texts and some comment on methods (e.g. 'Sam uses the red pandas as an example, whereas Rosa uses the tiger'). Level 3: compares how the views are conveyed through several specific choices (e.g. the contrasting examples; both conceding a point; the opposite views of what children learn; the matching endings about tickets), with short quotations from both texts and comparative connectives throughout. Close references can count as evidence, but Level 3 needs short, precise quotations. Spelling does not affect the mark.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Topic notes

Comparing viewpoints

The big idea

Two writers can look at the same subject and see it very differently. A writer's viewpoint is what they think about the subject. Comparing two texts means saying what each writer thinks, how you can tell, and how their ways of getting their views across are alike or different.

Step 1: Sum up each viewpoint

Sum up each writer's overall view in one sentence: Writer A is for the new road, but Writer B is against it. Base it on the whole text, not on one detail.

Writers sometimes admit that the other side has a point before arguing against it: It is true that the road would cut journey times, but... This is called a concession. Do not mistake it for the writer's main view.

Step 2: How can you tell?

Look for:

  • word choice: positive words (exciting, safe) or negative ones (noisy, dangerous)
  • the details and examples the writer picks out
  • evidence: facts, statistics, an expert, or a personal story
  • tone: the attitude the words show, such as proud, angry, worried or humorous
  • the ending: what the writer wants the reader to think or do

Step 3: Compare how they get their views across

Ask the same questions about both texts and put the answers side by side. Both writers might use facts, but one might add a personal story. One might sound cheerful, the other worried. It also helps to ask who each writer is: a parent and a shop owner may see the same change very differently.

Comparative connectives

Comparative connectives are linking words that show how two things are alike or different.

To show a similarityTo show a difference
similarly, likewise, both, also, in the same waywhereas, while, however, in contrast, on the other hand, unlike

Example: Unlike Writer A, who wants a new road, Writer B would rather have a better bus service.

Writing a short comparison

Write about the texts together, point by point, rather than all of one text and then all of the other:

  1. Writer A's view or method, with a quotation.
  2. A comparative connective.
  3. Writer B's view or method, with a quotation.
  4. A short explanation of the difference or similarity.

Compare two views of a new skate park

Here are two made-up texts.

Text A, from a blog by Jess, aged 13: At last! Fernhill is getting a skate park. Right now we skate in the supermarket car park and get shouted at. A proper park would give us somewhere safe to go and something to be proud of.

Text B, from a letter to a local newspaper: I am worried about the plan to build a skate park on Fernhill Green. The green is the only quiet space in our village, where older people sit and toddlers play. And what about the noise and litter late at night?

Model answer: Jess is excited about the skate park, whereas the letter writer is worried about it. Jess opens with the exclamation At last! and says a park would give young people somewhere safe to go, so she sees it as a solution. In contrast, the letter writer thinks about the people who already use the green, older people and toddlers, and ends with a worried question about the noise and litter. Both writers care about having a good place to spend time, but they disagree about who the green should be for.

Improve a weak comparison

Weak: Jess likes the skate park. The letter writer does not like it.

Better: Jess thinks the skate park would give young people "somewhere safe to go", while the letter writer fears it will bring "noise and litter" to a quiet green.

The better version joins the two views with a comparative connective (while), uses a short quotation from each text, and uses more precise words for each view (thinks, fears).

Remember

  • Sum up each writer's overall view in one sentence first.
  • Compare the same things in both texts: view, evidence, tone and ending.
  • Use comparative connectives such as whereas, in contrast and similarly.
  • Give evidence from both texts.

Common mistakes

  • Writing about one text and then the other without ever linking them.
  • Giving evidence from only one text.
  • Mistaking a concession for the writer's main view.
  • Joining two different views with and, which does not show a difference. Use whereas or but.
  • Comparing different things, such as one writer's tone and the other writer's facts.

Top tip

Before you write, make a quick two-column plan: Text A on the left, Text B on the right, and one row for each thing you will compare. Then write across the rows, not down the columns.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.