The big idea
Proofreading means checking writing for mistakes in spelling, punctuation and grammar, and correcting them. Editing means making the writing better: choosing more precise words, varying the sentences and putting ideas in the best order. Every good writer does both.
How to proofread
- Read slowly, one sentence at a time, saying each word in your head.
- Look for one kind of mistake at a time: spelling, then punctuation, then grammar.
- Check that every sentence starts with a capital letter and ends with a full stop, question mark or exclamation mark.
- When you correct a passage, copy everything else exactly, so you do not add new mistakes.
Mistakes to look for
| Kind of mistake | Wrong | Right |
|---|
| Spelling | We need to seperate the pens. | separate |
| Homophones (words that sound the same but are spelt differently) | Your going to love this. | You're (you are) |
| Capital letters for names, places, days, months and I | we flew to spain in june. | We, Spain, June |
| Apostrophes | I dont know. | don't |
| Comma splice (two sentences joined with only a comma) | The shop was shut, we went home. | The shop was shut. We went home. |
| Question marks | Have you seen my coat. | coat? |
| Standard English (the grammar used in formal writing) | I done my homework. | I did or I have done |
| Agreement (the verb matching who is doing it) | The dogs barks. | The dogs bark. |
| Tense (past or present) | We arrived, and the guide shows us round. | showed |
Editing: making it better
- Precise words: swap vague words such as nice, good, got, went and thing for exact ones: went could become crept, raced or wandered.
- Varied sentences: do not start every sentence the same way. Join short sentences with words such as when, because, although and which, and split sentences that run on too long.
- Order: put sentences in a logical order, such as the order in which things happened.
- Paragraphs: start a new paragraph when the time, place, topic or person speaking changes. Some pupils remember this as TiPToP: Time, Place, Topic, Person.
When you explain an improvement, say what you changed and what it does for the reader. It sounds better explains nothing.
This passage has five deliberate mistakes. Find and correct them.
Last weekend my family visited a castle in wales. We climbed the tower, it was very windy at the top. From there we could see are town and the sea beyond it. I was hopeing to see the dungeon, but it was shut. We could of stayed all day.
- wales becomes Wales: places need a capital letter.
- tower, it was becomes tower. It was: a comma cannot join two sentences.
- are becomes our: two words that are easily mixed up.
- hopeing becomes hoping: drop the e before adding -ing.
- could of becomes could have: Standard English.
Corrected: Last weekend my family visited a castle in Wales. We climbed the tower. It was very windy at the top. From there we could see our town and the sea beyond it. I was hoping to see the dungeon, but it was shut. We could have stayed all day.
Improve this sentence and explain your change: We went to the waterfall and it was really big and it was really loud.
When we reached the waterfall, it was thundering down the cliff so loudly that we had to shout.
Explanation: thundering is a precise verb that shows the waterfall's size and noise at once, and we had to shout proves how loud it was instead of just saying really loud. Cutting the repeated and it was also makes the sentence flow.
Why it matters
In the longer writing tasks, spelling, punctuation and grammar count towards the vocabulary, sentences and accuracy marks, and editing your ideas into a clear order helps the content and organisation marks. So always leave a few minutes to check your work.
Common mistakes
- Reading too fast, so you see what you meant to write instead of what is really there.
- Checking only spelling and missing capital letters, full stops and grammar.
- "Correcting" a word that was already right.
- Fixing a comma splice by deleting the comma: The shop was shut we went home is still wrong.
- Explaining an improvement with it sounds better. Say what the change shows the reader.
Top tip
Proofread backwards, from the last sentence to the first. Reading sentences out of order stops you getting carried along by the meaning, so mistakes stand out.