Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Practice
Course:
Topics:
Year 7 English Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
Grammar and punctuation
Unit 2
Spelling and vocabulary
Unit 3
Reading fiction
Unit 4
Poetry
Unit 5
Drama and Shakespeare
Unit 6
Reading non-fiction
Unit 7
Writing
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/47

Comparing two poems

Practise 16 questions on Comparing two poems for Year 7 English. Write your answer and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 16 questions
  • 1–8 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
16 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme.

Question 1

2 marks

Read these two poems, then answer the question.

Poem A

Where Go the Boats? by Robert Louis Stevenson (1885)

1 Dark brown is the river,
2 Golden is the sand.
3 It flows along for ever,
4 With trees on either hand.

5 Green leaves a-floating,
6 Castles of the foam,
7 Boats of mine a-boating -
8 Where will all come home?

9 On goes the river
10 And out past the mill,
11 Away down the valley,
12 Away down the hill.

13 Away down the river,
14 A hundred miles or more,
15 Other little children
16 Shall bring my boats ashore.

Glossary: on either hand = on both sides; a-floating = floating; castles of the foam = heaps of foam that look like castles; ashore = onto the land

Poem B

Paper Boat

1 I folded it from last week's spelling test,
2 a neat white boat with a pointed sail,
3 and launched it in the gutter after the storm.

4 It spun, it wobbled, then it sailed away,
5 past the bus stop, past the chip shop,
6 racing a crisp packet down Station Road,

7 until the drain gulped it down, sail and all.

8 Somewhere under the city it is still sailing,
9 I tell myself,
10 all the way to the sea.

Give one similarity and one difference between Poem A and Poem B.

Model answer

Similarity: in both poems a child watches their boat float away and imagines where it will end up. Difference: Poem A is set by a river in the countryside, whereas Poem B is set in a city street, where the boat goes down a drain.

Explanation

When comparing, look at subject, setting, feelings and form. Both poems share the same subject - a child's boat floating away - but their settings and what happens to the boats are very different. A common mistake is to give a 'difference' that only describes one poem without saying how the other poem is different.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    a similarity: e.g. both speakers are children sailing their own boats; both boats float away on moving water; both speakers imagine where their boats will go after they are out of sight; both end hopefully, imagining the boat's journey going on; both use repetition ("Away down the valley, / Away down the hill" / "past the bus stop, past the chip shop")

    Accept any valid similarity that is true of both poems.

  2. 1 mark

    a difference: e.g. Poem A is set by a river in the countryside, whereas Poem B is set in a city street and gutter; in Poem A the boats sail on safely, whereas in Poem B the boat is lost down a drain; Poem A's speaker is sure the boats will be found ("Shall bring my boats ashore"), whereas Poem B's speaker is less sure ("I tell myself"); Poem A has regular rhyming stanzas, whereas Poem B is free verse with no rhyme

    The difference must refer to both poems (it may be implied, e.g. 'Poem B's boat goes down a drain but Poem A's boats keep sailing'). Award even if the similarity is wrong. Spelling does not matter.

Question 2

3 marks

Read these two poems, then answer the question.

Poem A

The Lamb by William Blake (1789)

(A child speaks to a lamb. Christians sometimes call Jesus "the Lamb of God".)

1 Little Lamb, who made thee
2 Dost thou know who made thee,
3 Gave thee life, and bid thee feed
4 By the stream and o'er the mead;
5 Gave thee clothing of delight,
6 Softest clothing, woolly, bright;
7 Gave thee such a tender voice,
8 Making all the vales rejoice?
9 Little Lamb, who made thee?
10 Dost thou know who made thee?

11 Little Lamb, I'll tell thee;
12 Little Lamb, I'll tell thee:
13 He is called by thy name,
14 For He calls Himself a Lamb
15 He is meek, and He is mild,
16 He became a little child.
17 I a child, and thou a lamb,
18 We are called by His name.
19 Little Lamb, God bless thee!
20 Little Lamb, God bless thee!

Glossary: thee, thou = you; dost thou = do you; bid = told; o'er = over; mead = meadow; vales = valleys; meek = gentle and humble; mild = calm and kind

Poem B

The Tyger by William Blake (1794)

1 Tyger, tyger, burning bright
2 In the forests of the night,
3 What immortal hand or eye
4 Could frame thy fearful symmetry?

5 In what distant deeps or skies
6 Burnt the fire of thine eyes?
7 On what wings dare he aspire?
8 What the hand dare seize the fire?

9 And what shoulder and what art
10 Could twist the sinews of thy heart?
11 And, when thy heart began to beat,
12 What dread hand and what dread feet?

13 What the hammer? what the chain?
14 In what furnace was thy brain?
15 What the anvil? what dread grasp
16 Dare its deadly terrors clasp?

17 When the stars threw down their spears,
18 And watered heaven with their tears,
19 Did he smile his work to see?
20 Did he who made the lamb make thee?

21 Tyger, tyger, burning bright
22 In the forests of the night,
23 What immortal hand or eye
24 Dare frame thy fearful symmetry?

Glossary: Tyger = tiger (an old spelling); immortal = living for ever, like a god; frame = make, build; fearful = frightening; symmetry = perfect balance of shape and pattern; deeps = depths of the sea; aspire = rise up; sinews = strong muscles; dread = terrifying; anvil = an iron block on which a blacksmith hammers hot metal; grasp = grip

Both speakers ask questions about who made the animal. Compare the questions in the two poems. How are they similar, and how are they different?

Model answer

Both speakers ask who made the animal: Poem A asks "Little Lamb, who made thee?" and Poem B asks "What immortal hand or eye / Could frame thy fearful symmetry?" Poem B even links back to Poem A with "Did he who made the lamb make thee?" However, the questions are very different. In Poem A they are gentle and simple, and the speaker answers them himself: "Little Lamb, I'll tell thee", which shows he feels calm and certain. In Poem B the questions pile up, such as "What the hammer? what the chain?", and are never answered, which shows the speaker's awe and fear of the tiger.

Explanation

Blake wrote these poems as a pair, so they ask the same question - who made you? - in very different ways. The lamb's question is answered with calm certainty; the tiger's questions are left hanging in amazement. For full marks, give a similarity and a difference and support both with evidence from each poem. A common mistake is to write about only one poem.

Mark scheme
  1. 3 marks

    Award 3 marks: identifies a similarity AND explains a difference, with reference to both poems, e.g. similarity - both speakers ask who created the animal ("who made thee?" / "What immortal hand or eye / Could frame thy fearful symmetry?"), and Poem B even links back to the lamb ("Did he who made the lamb make thee?"); difference - the questions in Poem A are gentle and simple, and the speaker answers them himself ("Little Lamb, I'll tell thee"), which shows calm certainty, whereas the questions in Poem B are many, intense and never answered ("What the hammer? what the chain?"), which shows awe, fear or wonder.
    Award 2 marks: a similarity and a difference with only simple support, or a well-explained difference with no similarity.
    Award 1 mark: a simple point about one or both poems (e.g. 'both ask questions', 'the Tyger asks more questions').

    Accept other valid points: Poem A's questions are tender, like talking to a pet; Poem B's are like a list of demands that build up speed; Poem B's questions focus on the danger of making the tiger ("dare seize the fire"); Poem A's questions are about kindness ("Gave thee life", "tender voice"). Quotations or close references are both accepted; spelling does not matter.

Question 3

4 marks

Read these two poems, then answer the question.

Poem A

Composed upon Westminster Bridge by William Wordsworth (1807)

(Wordsworth wrote this sonnet about London early one morning, as he crossed a bridge over the River Thames.)

1 Earth has not any thing to shew more fair:
2 Dull would he be of soul who could pass by
3 A sight so touching in its majesty:
4 This City now doth like a garment wear
5 The beauty of the morning; silent, bare,
6 Ships, towers, domes, theatres, and temples lie
7 Open unto the fields, and to the sky;
8 All bright and glittering in the smokeless air.
9 Never did sun more beautifully steep
10 In his first splendor valley, rock, or hill;
11 Ne'er saw I, never felt, a calm so deep!
12 The river glideth at his own sweet will:
13 Dear God! the very houses seem asleep;
14 And all that mighty heart is lying still!

Glossary: shew = show; fair = beautiful; dull of soul = with no feeling for beauty; majesty = grandeur, magnificence; doth = does; garment = a piece of clothing; temples = churches; unto = to; smokeless = without smoke (the chimneys are not yet lit); steep = soak; splendor = splendour, brightness; ne'er = never; glideth = glides; at his own sweet will = just as it pleases

Poem B

Rush Hour

1 Eight o'clock, and the city is wide awake,
2 shouting its head off.
3 Buses grind and hiss at every stop,
4 horns blare, a drill hammers at the road,
5 and the crowd pours out of the station
6 like water from a burst pipe.

7 Everyone is late. Everyone is rushing,
8 coffee in one hand, phone in the other,
9 eyes fixed on the grey pavement.
10 Nobody looks up. Nobody stops.

11 I am squashed against a window on the 38,
12 counting the stops to school,
13 when the bus crosses the bridge
14 and the river, for one second, flashes gold.

Both poets use personification to describe the city. Compare how the city is personified in the two poems. Use one example from each poem and explain it.

Model answer

In Poem A, Wordsworth personifies London as a sleeping person: "the very houses seem asleep; / And all that mighty heart is lying still!" The city is "mighty", but at this early hour its heart is resting, so it seems peaceful, calm and almost gentle.

In contrast, in Poem B the city is "wide awake, / shouting its head off". It is personified as a loud, rude person yelling at the top of their voice, which shows that the city is noisy and chaotic. Wordsworth's city is a giant asleep, whereas this city is a giant who has woken up and will not stop shouting.

Explanation

Both poets make the city seem alive, but in opposite states: asleep and still in Poem A, awake and shouting in Poem B. For full marks, give one example from each poem, explain what each suggests, and make the contrast clear with a connective. A common mistake is to choose a simile, such as "like water from a burst pipe", which is a comparison but not personification.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    an example of personification of the city from Poem A: "This City now doth like a garment wear / The beauty of the morning" / "the very houses seem asleep" / "all that mighty heart is lying still" / "The river glideth at his own sweet will"

    Accept a quotation or a close reference. Accept the river example as part of the city.

  2. 1 mark

    explains what this personification suggests about the city in Poem A: e.g. it is like a person wearing beautiful clothes, so the morning makes it elegant and lovely; it is like a sleeping person, so it is peaceful, calm and still; "mighty heart" suggests the city is a powerful living thing that is resting quietly; the river moves freely and calmly, as it likes

    Award only if the example from Poem A (the point before) was awarded.

  3. 1 mark

    an example of personification of the city from Poem B: "the city is wide awake, / shouting its head off"

    Accept "wide awake" or "shouting its head off" on their own. Accept "Buses grind and hiss" or "a drill hammers" only if explained as the city's noisy voice; the simile "like water from a burst pipe" is not personification.

  4. 1 mark

    explains what this personification suggests about the city in Poem B, ideally in contrast with Poem A: e.g. it is like a loud, rude or excited person who will not stop yelling, so the city is noisy, energetic and chaotic, the opposite of Wordsworth's sleeping, silent city

    Award only if the example from Poem B (the point before) was awarded. Max 3 if the answer makes no comparison between the two cities. Spelling does not matter.

Question 4

8 marks

Read these two poems, then answer the question.

Poem A

The Lamb by William Blake (1789)

(A child speaks to a lamb. Christians sometimes call Jesus "the Lamb of God".)

1 Little Lamb, who made thee
2 Dost thou know who made thee,
3 Gave thee life, and bid thee feed
4 By the stream and o'er the mead;
5 Gave thee clothing of delight,
6 Softest clothing, woolly, bright;
7 Gave thee such a tender voice,
8 Making all the vales rejoice?
9 Little Lamb, who made thee?
10 Dost thou know who made thee?

11 Little Lamb, I'll tell thee;
12 Little Lamb, I'll tell thee:
13 He is called by thy name,
14 For He calls Himself a Lamb
15 He is meek, and He is mild,
16 He became a little child.
17 I a child, and thou a lamb,
18 We are called by His name.
19 Little Lamb, God bless thee!
20 Little Lamb, God bless thee!

Glossary: thee, thou = you; dost thou = do you; bid = told; o'er = over; mead = meadow; vales = valleys; meek = gentle and humble; mild = calm and kind

Poem B

The Tyger by William Blake (1794)

1 Tyger, tyger, burning bright
2 In the forests of the night,
3 What immortal hand or eye
4 Could frame thy fearful symmetry?

5 In what distant deeps or skies
6 Burnt the fire of thine eyes?
7 On what wings dare he aspire?
8 What the hand dare seize the fire?

9 And what shoulder and what art
10 Could twist the sinews of thy heart?
11 And, when thy heart began to beat,
12 What dread hand and what dread feet?

13 What the hammer? what the chain?
14 In what furnace was thy brain?
15 What the anvil? what dread grasp
16 Dare its deadly terrors clasp?

17 When the stars threw down their spears,
18 And watered heaven with their tears,
19 Did he smile his work to see?
20 Did he who made the lamb make thee?

21 Tyger, tyger, burning bright
22 In the forests of the night,
23 What immortal hand or eye
24 Dare frame thy fearful symmetry?

Glossary: Tyger = tiger (an old spelling); immortal = living for ever, like a god; frame = make, build; fearful = frightening; symmetry = perfect balance of shape and pattern; deeps = depths of the sea; aspire = rise up; sinews = strong muscles; dread = terrifying; anvil = an iron block on which a blacksmith hammers hot metal; grasp = grip

Compare how Blake presents the lamb and the tiger in these two poems.

You could write about:
- the language and imagery used to describe each animal
- the questions the speakers ask, and whether they are answered
- the sound, form and structure of each poem

Use evidence from both poems and comparative connectives.

Model answer

Blake wrote these two poems as a pair, and both speakers ask the same question about an animal: who made you? In "The Lamb" the child asks, "Little Lamb, who made thee?", and similarly the speaker of "The Tyger" asks, "What immortal hand or eye / Could frame thy fearful symmetry?" Both poems use short rhyming couplets and a strong, simple beat, like a song, and both begin and end with the same lines.

However, the animals are presented in opposite ways. The lamb is gentle and innocent. Blake describes its wool as "clothing of delight, / Softest clothing, woolly, bright", and it has "such a tender voice" that "all the vales rejoice". These soft images, set "By the stream and o'er the mead", make the lamb seem harmless and loved. In contrast, the tiger is "burning bright / In the forests of the night". The image of fire glowing in the darkness makes the tiger seem beautiful but dangerous, and "fearful" and "deadly terrors" show how frightening it is.

The creators are different too. The lamb's maker gently "Gave thee life, and bid thee feed", whereas the tiger's maker is like a blacksmith: "What the hammer? what the chain? / In what furnace was thy brain?" This suggests that making the tiger was violent, hot and dangerous work.

The questions also work differently. In "The Lamb" the child answers his own questions confidently - "Little Lamb, I'll tell thee" - so the tone is calm and certain, ending with a blessing: "God bless thee!" On the other hand, the questions in "The Tyger" pile up faster and faster and are never answered, which creates a tone of awe and fear. The speaker even asks, "Did he who made the lamb make thee?", amazed that the same maker could create both. Finally, when the first stanza returns at the end, "Could" has changed to "Dare", suggesting that making the tiger was a daring, almost frightening act. So while the lamb brings comfort, the tiger leaves the speaker, and the reader, full of wonder.

Explanation

For the top level, compare throughout: link the poems with connectives such as 'similarly', 'in contrast' and 'whereas', and compare the same features in both - the imagery of the animals, their makers, the questions and the endings. Explain single words such as "Softest", "burning" and "Dare". A common mistake is to write about "The Lamb" and then "The Tyger" with no links between them.

Mark scheme
  1. 8 marks

    Levels of response (8 marks).
    Level 3 (6-8 marks): Clearly compares how Blake presents the lamb and the tiger, explaining similarities and differences with well-chosen short quotations from both poems; comments on specific words, imagery, sound and structure; uses comparative connectives to link the poems throughout (subject terms help but are not essential).
    Level 2 (3-5 marks): Some comparison of the two poems, with relevant quotations from both; some comment on language or structure; the poems may be dealt with mostly one after the other.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Simple comments, mostly about one poem or retelling, with little comparison or evidence.
    0 marks: Nothing relevant.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit any valid comparisons):
    - Similarities: both speakers address the animal directly ("Little Lamb" / "Tyger, tyger"); both ask who made it ("who made thee?" / "What immortal hand or eye / Could frame thy fearful symmetry?"); Poem B refers to Poem A ("Did he who made the lamb make thee?"); both use rhyming couplets with short lines and a strong, simple beat like a song or hymn; both use repetition and a circular structure (opening lines repeated at the end).
    - The lamb: gentle, soft and innocent - "clothing of delight, / Softest clothing, woolly, bright", "such a tender voice", "He is meek, and He is mild"; a peaceful daytime setting "By the stream and o'er the mead"; its voice makes "all the vales rejoice".
    - The tiger: fierce, powerful, beautiful and frightening - "burning bright / In the forests of the night" (fire against darkness); "fearful symmetry"; "deadly terrors"; "twist the sinews of thy heart".
    - The creator: in Poem A the maker is gentle, giving life and food ("Gave thee life, and bid thee feed"); in Poem B the maker is like a blacksmith at a forge - "What the hammer? what the chain? / In what furnace was thy brain? / What the anvil?" - violent, dangerous work ("dare seize the fire").
    - Questions: in Poem A the questions are simple and the child answers them confidently ("Little Lamb, I'll tell thee"), giving a calm, certain tone; in Poem B the questions pile up, faster and more intense, and are never answered, giving a tone of awe, amazement and fear.
    - Sound: soft 'l' and 'm' sounds in Poem A ("Little Lamb", "meek ... mild") against hard, harsh sounds in Poem B ("burning bright", "dread hand", "deadly terrors").
    - Endings: Poem A ends with a blessing ("God bless thee!") - comfort; Poem B repeats its first stanza but changes "Could" to "Dare" - even greater awe, as if making the tiger was a daring act.
    Level guide for this question: Level 1, e.g. 'The lamb is nice and the tiger is scary', or writing about only one poem. Level 2: makes several valid comparisons with quotations from both poems, explained in general terms; the poems may be treated separately. Level 3: explains clear similarities and differences with precise comments on words and images (e.g. "Softest", "tender", "burning", "furnace", "Dare"), and compares the questions or the structure, linking the poems with connectives; 7-8 marks for detailed, well-linked comparison across both whole poems. Max 5 if the answer writes about only one of the two poems. Close references can count as evidence, but Level 3 needs short, precise quotations. Spelling does not affect the mark.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Topic notes

Comparing two poems

The big idea

To compare two poems is to look at them side by side and find what is the same (the similarities) and what is different (the differences). A good comparison links the poems all the way through, instead of dealing with one poem and then the other.

What to compare

Compare theAsk yourself
SubjectWhat is each poem about? Is it the same subject?
FeelingsHow does each speaker feel? Do the feelings change?
ImageryWhat pictures does each poet create, and what do they suggest?
FormDoes each poem rhyme? Is the rhythm regular? How long are the lines and stanzas?

Two poems on the same subject often make the most interesting comparison, because the differences really stand out.

Comparative connectives

Comparative connectives are linking words that show how two ideas relate.

To show a similarityTo show a difference
bothwhereas
similarlyhowever
likewisein contrast
in the same wayon the other hand
likeunlike
  • Both poems describe the sea.
  • The first speaker is calm, whereas the second is furious.
  • The first poem rhymes. However, the second is written in free verse.

Whereas joins two ideas inside one sentence; However usually starts a new sentence.

Writing a comparative paragraph

  1. Point: make a comparison that covers both poems.
  2. Poem A: give a short quotation and explain it.
  3. Connective: turn to poem B with a linking word.
  4. Poem B: give a short quotation and explain it, showing how it is similar or different.
  5. Sum up the comparison in a final sentence.

Plan the comparison

Task: plan a comparison of these two poems about the sea.

Poem A is the first verse of Break, break, break by Alfred, Lord Tennyson (1842). He wrote it after the sudden death of his closest friend (thy = your; I would that = I wish; utter = say).

  1. Break, break, break,
  2. On thy cold gray stones, O Sea!
  3. And I would that my tongue could utter
  4. The thoughts that arise in me.

Poem B, Tag, was written for these notes.

  1. The sea comes running up the beach
  2. to tag us, quick and bright;
  3. it fizzes round our ankles
  4. and we squeal with cold delight.
Poem APoem B
Subjectthe seathe sea
Feelingsgrief: he cannot find words for his thoughtsjoy: we squeal with cold delight
Imagerycold gray stones: bleak and lifelesspersonification: the sea plays tag, quick and bright
Formlines 2 and 4 rhyme; line 1 is three heavy beatslines 2 and 4 rhyme; a light, bouncing beat

A comparative paragraph

Model answer (connectives in bold):

Both poems are about the sea, but the speakers feel very differently about it. Tennyson's speaker is full of grief: the waves "Break, break, break, / On thy cold gray stones", and the words "cold gray" make the sea seem bleak and lifeless, like his sadness. The three repeated words are slow and heavy, like waves crashing again and again. In contrast, the sea in "Tag" is a playful friend that comes "running up the beach / to tag us". Whereas Tennyson's stones are "cold gray", this sea is "quick and bright", and even its coldness brings "delight". Both poems rhyme lines 2 and 4, but their rhythms are very different: Tennyson's first line is just three heavy beats, while the light, bouncing beat of "Tag" sounds as cheerful as the game. Tennyson's speaker cannot find the words for what he feels, whereas in "Tag" the joy simply bursts out in a "squeal".

Why it works: it moves between the poems all the way through, and it uses evidence from both.

Common mistakes

  • Writing about one poem, then the other, with no links between them.
  • Giving a "difference" that describes only one poem. Poem A is sad is not a comparison; Poem A is sad, whereas Poem B is joyful is.
  • Using a connective that does not fit: similarly must introduce a similarity.
  • Quoting from only one of the poems.
  • Comparing only what happens, and forgetting the feelings, imagery and form.

Top tip

Start with a similarity, then turn to a difference with However or In contrast. It gives your paragraph a clear shape.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.