Question 1
2 marksRead these two poems, then answer the question.
Poem A
Where Go the Boats? by Robert Louis Stevenson (1885)
1 Dark brown is the river,
2 Golden is the sand.
3 It flows along for ever,
4 With trees on either hand.
5 Green leaves a-floating,
6 Castles of the foam,
7 Boats of mine a-boating -
8 Where will all come home?
9 On goes the river
10 And out past the mill,
11 Away down the valley,
12 Away down the hill.
13 Away down the river,
14 A hundred miles or more,
15 Other little children
16 Shall bring my boats ashore.
Glossary: on either hand = on both sides; a-floating = floating; castles of the foam = heaps of foam that look like castles; ashore = onto the land
Poem B
Paper Boat
1 I folded it from last week's spelling test,
2 a neat white boat with a pointed sail,
3 and launched it in the gutter after the storm.
4 It spun, it wobbled, then it sailed away,
5 past the bus stop, past the chip shop,
6 racing a crisp packet down Station Road,
7 until the drain gulped it down, sail and all.
8 Somewhere under the city it is still sailing,
9 I tell myself,
10 all the way to the sea.
Give one similarity and one difference between Poem A and Poem B.
Model answer
Similarity: in both poems a child watches their boat float away and imagines where it will end up. Difference: Poem A is set by a river in the countryside, whereas Poem B is set in a city street, where the boat goes down a drain.
Explanation
When comparing, look at subject, setting, feelings and form. Both poems share the same subject - a child's boat floating away - but their settings and what happens to the boats are very different. A common mistake is to give a 'difference' that only describes one poem without saying how the other poem is different.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
a similarity: e.g. both speakers are children sailing their own boats; both boats float away on moving water; both speakers imagine where their boats will go after they are out of sight; both end hopefully, imagining the boat's journey going on; both use repetition ("Away down the valley, / Away down the hill" / "past the bus stop, past the chip shop")
Accept any valid similarity that is true of both poems.
-
1 mark
a difference: e.g. Poem A is set by a river in the countryside, whereas Poem B is set in a city street and gutter; in Poem A the boats sail on safely, whereas in Poem B the boat is lost down a drain; Poem A's speaker is sure the boats will be found ("Shall bring my boats ashore"), whereas Poem B's speaker is less sure ("I tell myself"); Poem A has regular rhyming stanzas, whereas Poem B is free verse with no rhyme
The difference must refer to both poems (it may be implied, e.g. 'Poem B's boat goes down a drain but Poem A's boats keep sailing'). Award even if the similarity is wrong. Spelling does not matter.