Question 1
45 marks'Spending money on exploring space is wrong when there are so many problems on Earth.'
You have been asked to give a speech at a debating competition in which you express your views on this statement.
Your speech may include:
- the problems on Earth that need money and attention
- what space exploration has achieved and might achieve in the future
- any other points you wish to make.
Your response will be marked for the accurate and appropriate use of vocabulary, spelling, punctuation and grammar.
Model answer
Madam Chair, members of the judging panel, fellow debaters:
Tonight, somewhere in the world, a child will go to bed hungry. A family will drink water that makes them sick. A hospital will run short of medicine. These are not abstract statistics; they are real people, and they deserve our attention. So when someone asks how we can justify spending billions on rockets while people suffer here on Earth, it sounds unanswerable. I understand that feeling completely. But I am here to argue that the statement is wrong - and that space exploration is not a distraction from Earth's problems, but one of our best tools for solving them.
Let us first be clear about the scale of the spending. It is often imagined that space agencies swallow vast proportions of national budgets. In fact, the United States, which spends more on space than any other nation, devotes less than half of one per cent of its federal budget to NASA. Far greater sums are spent on weapons and on advertising. If we are looking for money to end hunger, space exploration is hardly the first place to start.
Second, consider what that money has already given us. Look at the phone in your pocket: its camera relies on image-sensor technology developed for spacecraft. The weather forecast that warns farmers of drought and coastal towns of approaching hurricanes depends on satellites. Satellite navigation guides ambulances to emergencies and ships across oceans. Water purification systems, scratch-resistant lenses, memory foam - all owe something to research funded by NASA. Space exploration is not money fired into the void. It comes back to Earth in ways that touch every one of our lives.
Third, and most importantly, space helps us understand and protect our own planet. Satellites measure the melting of polar ice, track the destruction of rainforests and monitor the gases that are warming our atmosphere. Without them, we would be fighting climate change blindfolded. When floods strike or earthquakes devastate cities, images from space help rescue teams to find survivors and deliver aid. Far from ignoring Earth's problems, space science shines a light on them.
My opponents will say: surely we should fix our own home before exploring the universe? But this is a false choice. Humanity has never solved one problem at a time. We developed vaccines while building railways; we fought disease while writing symphonies. A civilisation that refuses to look beyond its immediate troubles is a civilisation that stops discovering - and discovery is how problems get solved.
And let us not forget the power of inspiration. Countless scientists, engineers and doctors working today were first drawn to science by watching a rocket launch or seeing a photograph of Earth from space - that fragile blue marble suspended in darkness. That image did more to make people care about our planet than any lecture ever could.
Yes, we must do more to tackle poverty, hunger and disease. Governments must spend wisely and generously on those causes. But abandoning space would not feed a single extra child. It would only make us poorer - in knowledge, in technology and in hope.
So I urge you to reject this statement. Keep looking up, because that is how we learn to look after what lies below.
Thank you.
Explanation
This is a top-band debating speech: it addresses the chair and judges, concedes the emotional force of the statement before turning it, and builds a signposted case (scale of spending, practical benefits, protecting Earth) with a direct rebuttal ('this is a false choice') and a rousing conclusion. Evidence is accurate and well chosen, and AO5 is secured by controlled rhetoric - the opening triple, antithesis, the tricolon 'in knowledge, in technology and in hope'. Weaker responses simply list points for and against without reaching a view, use no features of spoken address, or rely on inaccurate or implausible figures.
Mark scheme
-
27 marks
Levels of response (27 marks). AO4 (communication and organisation).
Level 1 (1-5 marks): Communication is at a basic level and limited in clarity; little awareness of the purpose or of the audience and judges at a debating competition; little awareness of the form, tone and register of a speech.
Level 2 (6-11 marks): Communicates in a broadly appropriate way; some grasp of the purpose and of the expectations of the audience and judges at a debating competition; straightforward use of form, tone and register.
Level 3 (12-17 marks): Communicates clearly; a clear sense of purpose (arguing a view on spending money on space exploration) and understanding of the expectations of the audience and judges at a debating competition; appropriate use of form, tone and register.
Level 4 (18-22 marks): Communicates successfully; a secure realisation of the task (arguing a view on spending money on space exploration) that meets the expectations of the audience and judges at a debating competition; effective use of form, tone and register.
Level 5 (23-27 marks): Communication is perceptive and subtle; the task is sharply focused on its purpose (arguing a view on spending money on space exploration) and on the expectations of the audience and judges at a debating competition; sophisticated use of form, tone and register.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points).
Purpose: to argue and persuade: to present a clear, reasoned case for or against the statement. Either side, or a qualified view, can reach the top level.
Audience: judges and an audience at a debating competition - expecting a formal, well-structured argument with evidence, rebuttal and rhetorical skill.
Form: a speech, set out effectively with a clear introduction that addresses the audience, development of points and a conclusion. Expect features of spoken address such as direct address, rhetorical questions, signposting, repetition and a memorable ending; stage directions are not needed.
Responses may:
- problems on Earth: poverty, hunger, disease, lack of clean water, climate change, natural disasters - money could be spent directly on these
- scale of spending: space budgets are a small share of government spending compared with defence and other areas
- achievements and spin-offs: satellites for weather forecasting, communications and navigation; camera sensors, water purification, materials; scientific knowledge
- space helps Earth: monitoring climate change, deforestation and ice; disaster response
- future: resources, protecting Earth from asteroids, inspiration for scientists and engineers; or, against: private companies and tourism, risk, money better spent now
- debating conventions: addressing the chair and judges, rebutting the other side, a strong conclusion urging the audience to vote
The bullet points in the task are suggestions: a response does not have to cover both to reach the top levels, but it must stay focused on the task, its purpose and its audience. Use a best-fit approach. Little awareness of purpose, reader or form points to Levels 1-2; a clear, appropriate and organised response to Level 3; a secure, sustained and well-developed response with effective choices of tone and structure to Level 4; Level 5 needs perceptive, subtle communication with sophisticated, well-judged control of tone, register and structure throughout. -
18 marks
Levels of response (18 marks). AO5 (technical accuracy).
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Expresses information and ideas with limited use of structural and grammatical features; basic vocabulary, often misspelt; punctuation with basic control, creating undeveloped, often repetitive sentence structures.
Level 2 (4-7 marks): Expresses and orders information and ideas, using paragraphs and a range of structural and grammatical features; some correctly spelt vocabulary (e.g. regular patterns such as prefixes, suffixes, double consonants); punctuation with some control; a range of sentence structures including coordination and subordination.
Level 3 (8-11 marks): Develops and connects appropriate information and ideas; structural and grammatical features and paragraphing make the meaning clear; varied vocabulary, with words containing irregular patterns spelt correctly; accurate and varied punctuation, adapting sentence structure as appropriate.
Level 4 (12-15 marks): Manages information and ideas, with structural and grammatical features used cohesively and deliberately across the text; a wide, selective vocabulary with only occasional spelling errors; a range of punctuation positioned for clarity; sentence structures managed for deliberate effect.
Level 5 (16-18 marks): Manipulates complex ideas, using a range of structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion; extensive vocabulary used strategically; rare spelling errors do not detract from meaning; accurate punctuation that aids emphasis and precision; a range of sentence structures used accurately and selectively to achieve particular effects.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Mark the whole response for technical accuracy only: range and precision of vocabulary; variety and control of sentence structures; paragraphing and cohesion; accuracy of spelling, punctuation and grammar. Do not reward or penalise the content, ideas or viewpoint here (that is AO4). Level 5: extensive vocabulary used precisely and strategically; a full range of punctuation (e.g. colons, semicolons, dashes, brackets, question marks) used accurately for emphasis and precision; sentence forms chosen deliberately for effect; spelling errors rare. Level 4: wide, selective vocabulary; sentences managed for deliberate effect; only occasional errors. Level 3: varied vocabulary, irregular words mostly spelt correctly, accurate and varied punctuation with some lapses. Level 2: some control; regular words spelt correctly but errors in more complex words; punctuation errors such as comma splices or missing sentence boundaries. Level 1: basic vocabulary, frequent errors, undeveloped or repetitive sentences. Length is not specified, but a very brief response gives limited evidence of range and control. Rhetorical questions, exclamations, repetition and occasional deliberate fragments are conventions of a speech and are not errors when they are controlled.