Remind yourself of the extract from 'Chinese Cinderella' by Adeline Yen Mah in the Pearson Edexcel International GCSE English Anthology.
How does the writer use language and structure to show the importance of success and status in Adeline's family?
You should support your answer with close reference to the passage, including brief quotations.
Model answer
The extract presents a world in which status matters greatly. The family's wealth is signalled through setting: their 'elegant villa at mid-level', halfway up the hill 'between the peak and the harbour', the 'swimming-pool', the chauffeur and Ah Gum, who opens the door. The precise location suggests prestige, and the leisure activities - 'playing bridge', 'sunbathing' - show a comfortable, privileged life.
Success is presented as public honour. The newspaper uses formal, celebratory language: Adeline has won 'first prize' in the 'International Play-writing Competition held in London', and it is 'the first time that any local Chinese student' has won 'such a prestigious event'. The capitals in 'ADELINE JUN-LING YEN' and 'FIFTY ENGLISH POUNDS' make the achievement seem grand, and the phrase 'bringing honour to Hong Kong' shows that her success reflects on the whole community.
Her father values the prize mainly for what it does for his reputation. His story about 'my friend C.Y. Tung' centres on a 'prominent fellow businessman', and the detail that Tung's children have not won 'an international literary prize' turns her success into a point of competition between fathers. Adeline understands this: 'I had given him face'. The concept of face, meaning reputation and respect, shows that in her family a child's worth is measured by the honour she brings. 'For once, he was proud of me' suggests that affection must be earned through achievement.
Success also brings opportunity. Adeline uses the moment to ask to go to university in England 'just like my brothers', which shows that education abroad is a privilege she must earn while her brothers receive it as a matter of course. England is presented as 'heaven', revealing its prestige in her eyes.
Her father's view of careers is shaped by practicality and security. He dismisses writing with 'You are going to starve!' and chooses medicine because 'Women will always be having babies', calling it 'a foolproof profession'. The word 'foolproof' shows that he values a safe, respectable career over personal passion.
Structurally, the newspaper announcement sits near the centre of the extract and transforms Adeline's position. Before it, she is ignored and fearful; after it, she is praised and granted her wish. This turning point shows how completely her standing in the family depends on success.
Explanation
Top answers connect several kinds of evidence - the wealthy setting, the newspaper's language, the father's comparison with C.Y. Tung, the concept of 'face' and his choice of a 'foolproof' career - and analyse how each shows the importance of status. They also see the announcement as the structural turning point. Weaker answers focus only on the prize without exploring what it means to the family.