Question 1
45 marksA newspaper has published an article arguing that art, music and drama are a waste of school time and should be replaced by more lessons in maths and science.
Write a letter to the editor of the newspaper in which you give your views on this argument.
Your letter may include:
- why creative subjects do or do not matter to young people
- what would be gained or lost if these subjects were cut
- any other points you wish to make.
Your response will be marked for the accurate and appropriate use of vocabulary, spelling, punctuation and grammar.
Model answer
Dear Editor,
I am writing in response to the article 'Back to Basics', published in last Thursday's edition, in which your columnist argued that art, music and drama are 'a waste of precious school time' and should be replaced by extra maths and science. As a sixteen-year-old student who studies both chemistry and music, I could not disagree more strongly, and I hope you will allow me to explain why.
Let me begin by agreeing with your columnist on one point: maths and science are vitally important. Nobody is suggesting otherwise. But the article presents a false choice, as though a young person must choose between solving equations and playing the piano. The truth is that creative subjects do not take away from academic success; they support it.
Consider what these subjects actually teach. In drama, students learn to speak confidently in front of others, to work closely as a team and to understand people whose lives are very different from their own. In art, they learn to observe carefully, to experiment and to accept that a first attempt is rarely the best. In music, they develop discipline, concentration and the patience to persevere through hours of difficult practice. These are not soft skills. They are exactly the qualities that employers, universities and, indeed, scientists say they need. Many great scientific breakthroughs have come from people who could think creatively, imagine what did not yet exist and see connections that others had missed.
Creative subjects also matter enormously to young people's wellbeing. For many students, the art room or the music practice room is the one place in school where they feel truly successful. Not everyone shines in written exams. A student who struggles with algebra may be a gifted painter, a talented actor or a natural songwriter, and creative subjects give them the chance to discover that talent and feel proud of it. At a time when so many young people are suffering from stress and anxiety, removing the very lessons that help them express themselves seems not just unwise but harmful.
Then there is the economic argument, which your columnist ignored entirely. The creative industries - film, television, music, design, fashion, gaming and advertising - employ huge numbers of people and contribute vast sums to the economy. Where will the next generation of designers, animators and composers come from if schools stop teaching these subjects? It would be a strange economic policy that cut off the supply of talent to one of our most successful industries.
What would be lost if these subjects were cut? School concerts and plays that bring whole communities together. The quiet confidence of a shy student taking a bow on stage. The joy of making something beautiful with your own hands. These experiences cannot be measured in a league table, but they shape who young people become.
I would urge your columnist, and your readers, to attend a school production or exhibition this term. I think they would quickly see that creative subjects are not a waste of time. They are where many young people find their voice.
Yours faithfully,
Priya Sharma
Explanation
The letter is sharply focused on its purpose and readership: it identifies the article it is answering, concedes the columnist's valid point before exposing the 'false choice', and builds a cumulative case (skills, wellbeing, economy) that ends with an evocative list of what would be lost and a courteous challenge to the columnist. The register is consistently formal and measured, which makes the disagreement more persuasive, and the sentence variety (including fragments in the penultimate paragraph) is clearly deliberate. Common pitfalls are attacking the writer personally, writing an essay with no reference to the original article or letter conventions, and failing to explain why the skills learned in creative subjects matter.
Mark scheme
-
27 marks
Levels of response (27 marks). AO4 (communication and organisation).
Level 1 (1-5 marks): Communication is at a basic level and limited in clarity; little awareness of the purpose or of the editor and readers of a newspaper; little awareness of the form, tone and register of a formal letter.
Level 2 (6-11 marks): Communicates in a broadly appropriate way; some grasp of the purpose and of the expectations of the editor and readers of a newspaper; straightforward use of form, tone and register.
Level 3 (12-17 marks): Communicates clearly; a clear sense of purpose (arguing a view on whether creative subjects should be cut from schools) and understanding of the expectations of the editor and readers of a newspaper; appropriate use of form, tone and register.
Level 4 (18-22 marks): Communicates successfully; a secure realisation of the task (arguing a view on whether creative subjects should be cut from schools) that meets the expectations of the editor and readers of a newspaper; effective use of form, tone and register.
Level 5 (23-27 marks): Communication is perceptive and subtle; the task is sharply focused on its purpose (arguing a view on whether creative subjects should be cut from schools) and on the expectations of the editor and readers of a newspaper; sophisticated use of form, tone and register.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points).
Purpose: to argue and persuade: to respond to the article with a clear, reasoned view. Most candidates will defend creative subjects, but agreeing with the article is acceptable if well argued.
Audience: the newspaper's editor and readers - a broad adult readership, so a formal, articulate, measured register is required; the letter may refer to the original article.
Form: a formal letter with an appropriate salutation (e.g. 'Dear Mr ...', 'Dear Sir or Madam') and sign-off ('Yours sincerely' or 'Yours faithfully' - accept either); addresses and a date are not required. Expect a clear opening that states the reason for writing, developed paragraphs and a courteous close.
Responses may:
- value of creative subjects: confidence, teamwork, empathy, observation, discipline, creative thinking; qualities employers and scientists value
- wellbeing: self-expression, success for students who struggle in written exams, reduced stress
- economy: creative industries (film, music, design, gaming, advertising) employ many people
- what would be lost: concerts, plays, exhibitions, community events, the chance to discover talents
- answering the article: maths and science are important, but it is a false choice; creative subjects can support academic success
- possible counter-view: limited timetable time and pressure for exam results; extracurricular alternatives
The bullet points in the task are suggestions: a response does not have to cover both to reach the top levels, but it must stay focused on the task, its purpose and its audience. Use a best-fit approach. Little awareness of purpose, reader or form points to Levels 1-2; a clear, appropriate and organised response to Level 3; a secure, sustained and well-developed response with effective choices of tone and structure to Level 4; Level 5 needs perceptive, subtle communication with sophisticated, well-judged control of tone, register and structure throughout. -
18 marks
Levels of response (18 marks). AO5 (technical accuracy).
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Expresses information and ideas with limited use of structural and grammatical features; basic vocabulary, often misspelt; punctuation with basic control, creating undeveloped, often repetitive sentence structures.
Level 2 (4-7 marks): Expresses and orders information and ideas, using paragraphs and a range of structural and grammatical features; some correctly spelt vocabulary (e.g. regular patterns such as prefixes, suffixes, double consonants); punctuation with some control; a range of sentence structures including coordination and subordination.
Level 3 (8-11 marks): Develops and connects appropriate information and ideas; structural and grammatical features and paragraphing make the meaning clear; varied vocabulary, with words containing irregular patterns spelt correctly; accurate and varied punctuation, adapting sentence structure as appropriate.
Level 4 (12-15 marks): Manages information and ideas, with structural and grammatical features used cohesively and deliberately across the text; a wide, selective vocabulary with only occasional spelling errors; a range of punctuation positioned for clarity; sentence structures managed for deliberate effect.
Level 5 (16-18 marks): Manipulates complex ideas, using a range of structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion; extensive vocabulary used strategically; rare spelling errors do not detract from meaning; accurate punctuation that aids emphasis and precision; a range of sentence structures used accurately and selectively to achieve particular effects.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Mark the whole response for technical accuracy only: range and precision of vocabulary; variety and control of sentence structures; paragraphing and cohesion; accuracy of spelling, punctuation and grammar. Do not reward or penalise the content, ideas or viewpoint here (that is AO4). Level 5: extensive vocabulary used precisely and strategically; a full range of punctuation (e.g. colons, semicolons, dashes, brackets, question marks) used accurately for emphasis and precision; sentence forms chosen deliberately for effect; spelling errors rare. Level 4: wide, selective vocabulary; sentences managed for deliberate effect; only occasional errors. Level 3: varied vocabulary, irregular words mostly spelt correctly, accurate and varied punctuation with some lapses. Level 2: some control; regular words spelt correctly but errors in more complex words; punctuation errors such as comma splices or missing sentence boundaries. Level 1: basic vocabulary, frequent errors, undeveloped or repetitive sentences. Length is not specified, but a very brief response gives limited evidence of range and control. Check the punctuation of the salutation and sign-off. Contractions and slang are a matter of register, judged under AO4, not errors here.