Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/21

Writing a review

Practise 12 exam-style questions on Writing a review for Edexcel International GCSE English Language A (Paper 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 12 questions
  • 45 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
12 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

45 marks

Your school's student magazine is starting a regular page called 'Screen Time', on which students review films for other students.

Write a review of a film you have watched recently, either at the cinema or at home, for the magazine.

Your review may include:
- what the film is about and how well it is made
- who would enjoy the film and whether it is worth watching
- any other points you wish to make.

Your response will be marked for the accurate and appropriate use of vocabulary, spelling, punctuation and grammar.

Model answer

Ninety Miles of Snow
Four stars out of five

There is a moment, about halfway through Ninety Miles of Snow, when the cinema fell completely silent. Nobody rustled a sweet wrapper; nobody checked a phone. On screen, two teenagers stood at the edge of a frozen lake, deciding whether the ice would hold. I realised I was holding my breath, and I suspect I was not the only one. It is that kind of film: quiet, patient and, when it matters, absolutely gripping.

What is it about?
The premise is simple. When their father's truck breaks down on a remote mountain road in the middle of winter, sixteen-year-old Mara and her younger brother Teo set off on foot to find help, armed with little more than a torch, a flask of soup and a long-running argument about whose fault it all is. What follows is part survival thriller and part family drama, as the journey forces the siblings to confront the resentments that have been building since their mother left. I will say no more, because the film's twists deserve to be discovered, not spoiled in a school magazine.

How well is it made?
Exceptionally well, for the most part. The two young leads are the film's greatest strength. Mara is prickly, sarcastic and fiercely protective, and the actress playing her reveals the fear behind the attitude with nothing more than a glance. Teo could easily have been an irritating little brother, but he is played with such warmth and comic timing that he steals almost every scene. Their bickering feels real - anyone with a sibling will recognise it - which makes the moments of tenderness all the more powerful.

Visually, the film is stunning. The director uses vast, wide shots of white mountains to make the pair look tiny and helpless, then switches to tight, shaky close-ups when danger strikes, so that you feel trapped alongside them. The soundtrack is sparse: long stretches have no music at all, only the crunch of boots and the howl of the wind, and that silence is far more frightening than any orchestra.

Any weaknesses?
A few. The middle section drags; there is only so much trudging through snow that an audience can take, and twenty minutes could have been cut without losing anything important. The flashbacks to the family's life before the breakdown are clumsy, too, spelling out emotions that the actors had already shown us perfectly well. Some viewers may find the ending too neat - I won't say why - although I found it satisfying.

Who should watch it?
Ninety Miles of Snow is rated suitable for viewers aged twelve and over, and that feels right: there are tense moments and one scene involving an injury that might upset younger children, but nothing gratuitous. It is ideal for anyone who enjoys survival stories or character-driven drama, and it would make an excellent choice for a family film night, provided everyone is willing to put their phones away. If you need an explosion every ten minutes, though, this is not the film for you.

The verdict
This is a film that trusts its audience: it lets silences speak and allows its characters to be flawed. Despite a sluggish middle and some heavy-handed flashbacks, it delivers genuine tension and an emotional punch that stayed with me long after the credits rolled. Wrap up warm and go and see it.

Explanation

The best film reviews give just enough of the premise to hook the reader, then spend most of their length evaluating how the film is made - acting, camera work, sound, pacing - with specific moments as evidence. A spoiler-free approach, a clear sense of the viewer the film suits and a balanced verdict show secure awareness of audience and form. The commonest pitfall is retelling the whole storyline, including the ending, which leaves no room for judgement; others are vague praise ('the acting was really good') and a register too casual for a magazine. The film in the model answer is invented: any real or invented film is acceptable.

Mark scheme
  1. 27 marks

    Levels of response (27 marks). AO4 (communication and organisation).
    Level 1 (1-5 marks): Communication is basic and limited in clarity; little awareness of the purpose of the writing or of the intended reader; little awareness of form, tone and register.
    Level 2 (6-11 marks): Communicates in a broadly appropriate way; some grasp of the purpose and of what the intended reader expects; straightforward use of form, tone and register for a review.
    Level 3 (12-17 marks): Communicates clearly; a clear sense of purpose and understanding of what the intended reader expects; appropriate use of form, tone and register for a review.
    Level 4 (18-22 marks): Communicates successfully; a secure realisation of the task according to its purpose and the intended reader's expectations; effective use of form, tone and register for a review.
    Level 5 (23-27 marks): Communication is perceptive and subtle; the task is sharply focused on its purpose and on the intended reader's expectations; sophisticated use of form, tone and register for a review.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to inform students about a film and evaluate it, helping them decide whether to watch it; to entertain. Audience: students at the writer's school reading a student magazine: peers, so a lively, engaging register with some informality is appropriate, provided it remains controlled. Form: a review. It may use conventions such as a title or headline, the name and key details of what is reviewed, a star or numerical rating, subheadings, a balance of description and evaluation, and a clear verdict or recommendation. Candidates do not need layout features such as columns or pictures. There should be clear organisation, with an engaging introduction, development of points and a conclusion. Responses may: introduce the film's premise and genre without giving away the ending; evaluate the acting, characters, direction, camera work, music, special effects, dialogue and pacing, using specific moments as evidence; identify strengths and weaknesses; consider age suitability, the kind of viewer who would enjoy it and whether it is best seen at the cinema or at home; compare it with similar films where helpful; end with a verdict or rating. Reviews of real or invented places, events and works are equally acceptable; do not reward or penalise the accuracy of details about real ones. Higher-level responses: evaluate rather than simply describe, supporting each judgement with precise, vivid detail; balance strengths with fair criticism; sustain a confident, engaging reviewing voice suited to the named readers; and reach a clear, justified verdict that tells readers who the subject would suit. Lower-level responses: mainly narrate the visit or retell the story in time order, offer vague praise or criticism ('it was good'), deal with only part of the task, or lose sight of the named readers. The bullets in the question are suggestions ('may include'): a response need not cover every one, but it should address the whole task. Mark by best fit: a response need not meet every descriptor of a level to be placed in it. Length is not assessed directly, but a very brief or unfinished response is unlikely to develop ideas enough for the higher levels.

  2. 18 marks

    Levels of response (18 marks). AO5 (technical accuracy).
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Expresses information and ideas with limited use of structural and grammatical features; basic vocabulary, often misspelt; punctuation with basic control; undeveloped, often repetitive sentence structures.
    Level 2 (4-7 marks): Expresses and orders information and ideas, using paragraphs and a range of structural and grammatical features; some correctly spelt vocabulary (e.g. words with regular patterns such as prefixes, suffixes and double consonants); punctuation with some control; a range of sentence structures including coordination and subordination.
    Level 3 (8-11 marks): Develops and connects appropriate information and ideas, with structural and grammatical features and paragraphing that make the meaning clear; varied vocabulary, with words containing irregular patterns spelt correctly; accurate and varied punctuation; sentence structures adapted as appropriate.
    Level 4 (12-15 marks): Manages information and ideas, with structural and grammatical features used cohesively and deliberately across the text; wide, selective vocabulary with only occasional spelling errors; a range of punctuation positioned for clarity; sentence structures managed for deliberate effect.
    Level 5 (16-18 marks): Manipulates complex ideas, using a range of structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion; extensive vocabulary used strategically, with rare spelling errors that do not detract from overall meaning; accurate punctuation used to aid emphasis and precision; a range of sentence structures used accurately and selectively to achieve particular effects.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Mark this point for technical accuracy only, by best fit, across the whole response (ideas, content and adaptation to purpose and audience are credited under AO4): the range, precision and spelling of vocabulary (including ambitious and irregular words); the variety and control of sentence structures (simple, compound and complex; questions, commands and short sentences used deliberately for effect); paragraphing and cohesion (topic sentences, clear links between and within paragraphs); and the accuracy and range of punctuation (secure sentence boundaries, commas in complex sentences, apostrophes, and colons, semicolons, dashes, brackets, question and exclamation marks used correctly and for effect), with consistent tense, agreement and Standard English. Informal touches suited to the audience are acceptable if clearly deliberate and controlled. Titles, ratings and subheadings are acceptable conventions of a review: do not treat them as errors, and do not count them as evidence of sentence control. Frequent comma splices, run-on sentences, missing paragraphs or errors in common spellings keep a response in Level 2 or Level 3 however ambitious its vocabulary; Level 5 needs accuracy and deliberate, selective control throughout, though rare slips do not prevent it. A very brief response offers limited evidence of range.

Question 2

45 marks

A website for teenage gamers and their parents publishes reviews of new video games. Each review should help readers decide whether a game is worth buying.

Write a review of a video game you have played recently for the website.

Your review may include:
- the gameplay, the graphics and the story
- whether the game is suitable for young players and offers good value for money
- any other points you wish to make.

Your response will be marked for the accurate and appropriate use of vocabulary, spelling, punctuation and grammar.

Model answer

Lanterns of Kestrel Bay
Verdict: 4 out of 5

Every few years, a game comes along that makes you forget you are holding a controller. Lanterns of Kestrel Bay, a puzzle adventure set on a fog-wrapped fishing island, is not quite that game - but for long, enchanting stretches, it comes remarkably close.

The story
You play as Wren, a lighthouse keeper's teenage apprentice, who wakes to find that every lantern on the island has gone dark and the islanders have vanished. Your task is to relight the lanterns, one by one, and uncover what happened. It is a simple premise, but the story unfolds with real care, through letters, overheard conversations and memories that flicker into view whenever a lantern is lit. Without giving anything away, the final hour delivers a twist that is both surprising and, on reflection, entirely earned.

Gameplay
Most of your time is spent exploring and solving puzzles: redirecting beams of light with mirrors, repairing old machinery and timing your crossings of the tidal causeways before the sea swallows them. The puzzles are cleverly designed, starting gently and growing steadily more devious, and the satisfaction of finally cracking one is enormous. Importantly, the game never punishes failure harshly; if you get stuck, an optional hint system nudges you in the right direction without simply handing you the answer.

There is no combat at all, which some players will find refreshing and others dull. The middle section, in particular, involves a great deal of walking back and forth across the island, and a faster way of travelling would have helped. I occasionally found my attention drifting before the next puzzle pulled me back in.

Graphics and sound
Visually, Kestrel Bay is gorgeous. The hand-painted style makes every rock pool and crooked cottage look like an illustration from a storybook, and the lighting effects - golden lamplight spilling across wet cobbles, or a storm rolling in from the horizon - are breathtaking. The soundtrack, mostly gentle piano and the cries of seabirds, is the perfect companion, though it becomes rather repetitive after several hours.

A note for parents
The game is rated suitable for players aged seven and over, and that seems fair. There is no violence or bad language, and the occasional spooky moment is more atmospheric than terrifying. There is no online chat, so younger players cannot be contacted by strangers. Best of all, there are no in-game purchases or loot boxes: once you have bought the game, you own all of it, which is increasingly rare and deserves praise.

Value for money
The full price is a little lower than most new releases, and you can expect around twelve to fifteen hours of play, with extra time if you want to find every hidden collectable. Little changes on a second play-through, however, so it may be worth waiting for a sale if your budget is tight.

The final word
Lanterns of Kestrel Bay will not satisfy players who crave fast action or competitive online battles. But for anyone who enjoys a thoughtful puzzle, a beautiful world and a story that rewards patience, it is a treasure. It is also one of those rare games that parents and children could happily play together, taking turns at the puzzles and arguing gently over the answers. Light the lanterns. You won't regret it.

Explanation

The strongest answers recognise the dual audience: they give gamers precise judgements about gameplay, graphics and story, and give parents clear information about age suitability, online contact and in-game purchases. Evaluation is balanced (the slow middle section, the repetitive soundtrack) and supported by specific detail, leading to a verdict that tells readers exactly who the game suits. Weaker answers simply describe what happens in the game, assume the reader already knows it, or ignore value for money. The game in the model answer is invented: any real or invented game is acceptable.

Mark scheme
  1. 27 marks

    Levels of response (27 marks). AO4 (communication and organisation).
    Level 1 (1-5 marks): Communication is basic and limited in clarity; little awareness of the purpose of the writing or of the intended reader; little awareness of form, tone and register.
    Level 2 (6-11 marks): Communicates in a broadly appropriate way; some grasp of the purpose and of what the intended reader expects; straightforward use of form, tone and register for a review.
    Level 3 (12-17 marks): Communicates clearly; a clear sense of purpose and understanding of what the intended reader expects; appropriate use of form, tone and register for a review.
    Level 4 (18-22 marks): Communicates successfully; a secure realisation of the task according to its purpose and the intended reader's expectations; effective use of form, tone and register for a review.
    Level 5 (23-27 marks): Communication is perceptive and subtle; the task is sharply focused on its purpose and on the intended reader's expectations; sophisticated use of form, tone and register for a review.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to inform and advise readers by evaluating a video game, helping them decide whether to buy it. Audience: a dual audience of teenage gamers and their parents; the best responses address both, for example giving gamers judgements about gameplay and giving parents information about age suitability, online safety and costs. Form: a review. It may use conventions such as a title or headline, the name and key details of what is reviewed, a star or numerical rating, subheadings, a balance of description and evaluation, and a clear verdict or recommendation. Candidates do not need layout features such as columns or pictures. There should be clear organisation, with an engaging introduction, development of points and a conclusion. Responses may: outline the game's premise and genre without spoilers; evaluate the gameplay (controls, challenge, variety, difficulty, length, replay value), graphics, sound and story, with specific examples; comment on the age rating and content (violence, language, frightening scenes), online interaction and chat, and screen time; discuss value for money: price, hours of play, in-game purchases, loot boxes or subscriptions; balance strengths and weaknesses; give a verdict that makes clear who the game suits. Reviews of real or invented places, events and works are equally acceptable; do not reward or penalise the accuracy of details about real ones. Higher-level responses: evaluate rather than simply describe, supporting each judgement with precise, vivid detail; balance strengths with fair criticism; sustain a confident, engaging reviewing voice suited to the named readers; and reach a clear, justified verdict that tells readers who the subject would suit. Lower-level responses: mainly narrate the visit or retell the story in time order, offer vague praise or criticism ('it was good'), deal with only part of the task, or lose sight of the named readers. The bullets in the question are suggestions ('may include'): a response need not cover every one, but it should address the whole task. Mark by best fit: a response need not meet every descriptor of a level to be placed in it. Length is not assessed directly, but a very brief or unfinished response is unlikely to develop ideas enough for the higher levels.

  2. 18 marks

    Levels of response (18 marks). AO5 (technical accuracy).
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Expresses information and ideas with limited use of structural and grammatical features; basic vocabulary, often misspelt; punctuation with basic control; undeveloped, often repetitive sentence structures.
    Level 2 (4-7 marks): Expresses and orders information and ideas, using paragraphs and a range of structural and grammatical features; some correctly spelt vocabulary (e.g. words with regular patterns such as prefixes, suffixes and double consonants); punctuation with some control; a range of sentence structures including coordination and subordination.
    Level 3 (8-11 marks): Develops and connects appropriate information and ideas, with structural and grammatical features and paragraphing that make the meaning clear; varied vocabulary, with words containing irregular patterns spelt correctly; accurate and varied punctuation; sentence structures adapted as appropriate.
    Level 4 (12-15 marks): Manages information and ideas, with structural and grammatical features used cohesively and deliberately across the text; wide, selective vocabulary with only occasional spelling errors; a range of punctuation positioned for clarity; sentence structures managed for deliberate effect.
    Level 5 (16-18 marks): Manipulates complex ideas, using a range of structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion; extensive vocabulary used strategically, with rare spelling errors that do not detract from overall meaning; accurate punctuation used to aid emphasis and precision; a range of sentence structures used accurately and selectively to achieve particular effects.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Mark this point for technical accuracy only, by best fit, across the whole response (ideas, content and adaptation to purpose and audience are credited under AO4): the range, precision and spelling of vocabulary (including ambitious and irregular words); the variety and control of sentence structures (simple, compound and complex; questions, commands and short sentences used deliberately for effect); paragraphing and cohesion (topic sentences, clear links between and within paragraphs); and the accuracy and range of punctuation (secure sentence boundaries, commas in complex sentences, apostrophes, and colons, semicolons, dashes, brackets, question and exclamation marks used correctly and for effect), with consistent tense, agreement and Standard English. Informal touches suited to the audience are acceptable if clearly deliberate and controlled. Titles, ratings and subheadings are acceptable conventions of a review: do not treat them as errors, and do not count them as evidence of sentence control. Frequent comma splices, run-on sentences, missing paragraphs or errors in common spellings keep a response in Level 2 or Level 3 however ambitious its vocabulary; Level 5 needs accuracy and deliberate, selective control throughout, though rare slips do not prevent it. A very brief response offers limited evidence of range.

Question 3

45 marks

A travel website asks young travellers to review the places where they have stayed, to help other families choose where to go on holiday.

Write a review of a hotel, campsite, hostel or holiday home where you have stayed for the website.

Your review may include:
- the accommodation, the facilities and the location
- advice for families who are thinking of staying there
- any other points you wish to make.

Your response will be marked for the accurate and appropriate use of vocabulary, spelling, punctuation and grammar.

Model answer

Stillwater Lodges: A Lakeside Escape With a Few Rough Edges
Rating: 4 out of 5

Ask my younger brother what the best part of our summer holiday was, and he will tell you about the night a family of owls held a shouting match in the tree outside our cabin. Ask my mother, and she will mention the silence. Ask my father, and he will complain about the shower. All three answers, in their way, sum up Stillwater Lodges, a collection of wooden cabins on the shore of a mountain lake, where we spent a week in August.

The accommodation
There are twelve cabins, scattered among the pine trees so that each feels private, and ours slept five comfortably. Inside, everything was simple but spotless: two small bedrooms, a living area with a wood-burning stove and a kitchen equipped with everything we needed, from a decent kettle to a surprisingly sharp set of knives. The highlight was the veranda, which faced the lake directly. Eating breakfast there each morning, watching mist drift across the water while the mountains turned slowly from grey to gold, was worth the journey on its own.

The drawbacks were minor but real. The beds were firm enough to make my father mutter about his back, and the shower, as he will tell anyone who listens, lurched unpredictably between scalding and freezing. Wi-fi was available only in the reception building - a disaster or a blessing, depending on your age.

Facilities
The site has a small shop selling bread, milk and basic groceries at reasonable prices, though anything more ambitious requires a twenty-minute drive to the nearest town. Canoes and paddleboards can be hired by the hour, and the staff run free guided walks twice a week, which were excellent: our guide knew the name of every bird and mushroom we passed and told wonderful stories about the area's history. There is a small play area for younger children and a fire pit where families gather in the evenings to toast marshmallows and swap tales of the day's adventures.

The location
Stillwater is wonderfully remote, which is both its greatest strength and its main limitation. Walking trails start at the cabin doors, and the lake is clean, calm and perfect for swimming on hot afternoons. However, there is no public transport, so a car is essential, and families hoping for restaurants, shops or nightlife will be disappointed. This is a place for people who want to switch off, not for those who need constant entertainment.

Advice for families
Book early: the cabins nearest the water fill up months in advance, and they are well worth the small extra cost. Bring insect repellent, warm layers for the cool evenings and plenty of board games, because once the sun sets there is little to do but talk, read and play. Teenagers who cannot survive without their phones should be warned about the wi-fi in advance - although, speaking as a teenager myself, I found it oddly liberating after the first day. Families with very young children should note that the lake shore is not fenced, so close supervision is needed.

The verdict
Stillwater Lodges will not suit everyone. If you want luxury, entertainment or reliable plumbing, look elsewhere. But if your family wants a week of fresh air, starry skies and genuine peace, with the occasional owl argument for entertainment, it is hard to imagine a better place. We have already booked for next summer - and my father has promised to bring his own pillow.

Explanation

Top-band reviews blend vivid description with practical, trustworthy advice: they evaluate the accommodation, facilities and location honestly and tailor their advice to different kinds of family, so readers can judge whether the place suits them. A wry personal voice and a framing device (the family's three different answers, returning in the final line) show sophisticated control of tone and structure. Pitfalls include turning the review into a holiday diary ('on Monday we went to the beach'), giving no advice, or offering only praise, which makes a review far less credible.

Mark scheme
  1. 27 marks

    Levels of response (27 marks). AO4 (communication and organisation).
    Level 1 (1-5 marks): Communication is basic and limited in clarity; little awareness of the purpose of the writing or of the intended reader; little awareness of form, tone and register.
    Level 2 (6-11 marks): Communicates in a broadly appropriate way; some grasp of the purpose and of what the intended reader expects; straightforward use of form, tone and register for a review.
    Level 3 (12-17 marks): Communicates clearly; a clear sense of purpose and understanding of what the intended reader expects; appropriate use of form, tone and register for a review.
    Level 4 (18-22 marks): Communicates successfully; a secure realisation of the task according to its purpose and the intended reader's expectations; effective use of form, tone and register for a review.
    Level 5 (23-27 marks): Communication is perceptive and subtle; the task is sharply focused on its purpose and on the intended reader's expectations; sophisticated use of form, tone and register for a review.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to inform and advise families by evaluating a place to stay, helping them decide whether to book it. Audience: families using a travel website, including parents making decisions and young travellers, so the review should be practical and trustworthy as well as engaging. Form: a review. It may use conventions such as a title or headline, the name and key details of what is reviewed, a star or numerical rating, subheadings, a balance of description and evaluation, and a clear verdict or recommendation. Candidates do not need layout features such as columns or pictures. There should be clear organisation, with an engaging introduction, development of points and a conclusion. Responses may: describe and evaluate the rooms, cabins or pitches (comfort, cleanliness, beds, bathrooms, food); comment on facilities (pool, wi-fi, play areas, activities, shop, restaurant) and staff; evaluate the location (views, access, transport, nearby attractions, noise, safety); give advice for different kinds of family (young children, teenagers, those wanting peace or activity), when to book and what to bring; balance strengths and weaknesses; reach a verdict or rating. Reviews of real or invented places, events and works are equally acceptable; do not reward or penalise the accuracy of details about real ones. Higher-level responses: evaluate rather than simply describe, supporting each judgement with precise, vivid detail; balance strengths with fair criticism; sustain a confident, engaging reviewing voice suited to the named readers; and reach a clear, justified verdict that tells readers who the subject would suit. Lower-level responses: mainly narrate the visit or retell the story in time order, offer vague praise or criticism ('it was good'), deal with only part of the task, or lose sight of the named readers. The bullets in the question are suggestions ('may include'): a response need not cover every one, but it should address the whole task. Mark by best fit: a response need not meet every descriptor of a level to be placed in it. Length is not assessed directly, but a very brief or unfinished response is unlikely to develop ideas enough for the higher levels.

  2. 18 marks

    Levels of response (18 marks). AO5 (technical accuracy).
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Expresses information and ideas with limited use of structural and grammatical features; basic vocabulary, often misspelt; punctuation with basic control; undeveloped, often repetitive sentence structures.
    Level 2 (4-7 marks): Expresses and orders information and ideas, using paragraphs and a range of structural and grammatical features; some correctly spelt vocabulary (e.g. words with regular patterns such as prefixes, suffixes and double consonants); punctuation with some control; a range of sentence structures including coordination and subordination.
    Level 3 (8-11 marks): Develops and connects appropriate information and ideas, with structural and grammatical features and paragraphing that make the meaning clear; varied vocabulary, with words containing irregular patterns spelt correctly; accurate and varied punctuation; sentence structures adapted as appropriate.
    Level 4 (12-15 marks): Manages information and ideas, with structural and grammatical features used cohesively and deliberately across the text; wide, selective vocabulary with only occasional spelling errors; a range of punctuation positioned for clarity; sentence structures managed for deliberate effect.
    Level 5 (16-18 marks): Manipulates complex ideas, using a range of structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion; extensive vocabulary used strategically, with rare spelling errors that do not detract from overall meaning; accurate punctuation used to aid emphasis and precision; a range of sentence structures used accurately and selectively to achieve particular effects.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Mark this point for technical accuracy only, by best fit, across the whole response (ideas, content and adaptation to purpose and audience are credited under AO4): the range, precision and spelling of vocabulary (including ambitious and irregular words); the variety and control of sentence structures (simple, compound and complex; questions, commands and short sentences used deliberately for effect); paragraphing and cohesion (topic sentences, clear links between and within paragraphs); and the accuracy and range of punctuation (secure sentence boundaries, commas in complex sentences, apostrophes, and colons, semicolons, dashes, brackets, question and exclamation marks used correctly and for effect), with consistent tense, agreement and Standard English. Informal touches suited to the audience are acceptable if clearly deliberate and controlled. Titles, ratings and subheadings are acceptable conventions of a review: do not treat them as errors, and do not count them as evidence of sentence control. Frequent comma splices, run-on sentences, missing paragraphs or errors in common spellings keep a response in Level 2 or Level 3 however ambitious its vocabulary; Level 5 needs accuracy and deliberate, selective control throughout, though rare slips do not prevent it. A very brief response offers limited evidence of range.

Question 4

45 marks

An education website is collecting honest reviews of apps and websites that claim to help young people learn, so that students and their parents can choose wisely.

Write a review of a learning app or website you have used for the education website.

Your review may include:
- what the app or website offers and how easy and enjoyable it is to use
- how far it really helps students to learn, and whether it is worth the cost
- any other points you wish to make.

Your response will be marked for the accurate and appropriate use of vocabulary, spelling, punctuation and grammar.

Model answer

LinguaLeap: Fun, Addictive and Not Quite Enough
Rating: 3.5 out of 5

Three hundred and twelve days. That is the length of my current LinguaLeap 'streak': the number of consecutive days on which I have opened the language-learning app and completed at least one lesson. I am rather proud of it. I am also aware that, after nearly a year, my Spanish would struggle to get me through a conversation with a patient waiter. Both facts, I think, tell you a great deal about LinguaLeap.

What does it offer?
LinguaLeap teaches more than twenty languages through short, game-like lessons that take five to ten minutes each. You match words to pictures, translate sentences, listen to recordings and speak phrases into your phone's microphone. Correct answers earn points, which unlock new levels and lift you up a weekly league table against other learners. A cartoon parrot cheers you on, and sends increasingly guilt-inducing notifications if you forget to practise.

Is it easy and enjoyable to use?
Extremely. The design is bright, clean and intuitive; I was completing my first lesson within two minutes of downloading it. Lessons are pitched cleverly, so that you rarely feel either bored or overwhelmed, and the sense of progress is constant and satisfying. The league tables are genuinely motivating - perhaps too motivating, as anyone who has seen me frantically completing lessons at midnight on a Sunday to avoid relegation can confirm.

Does it actually help you learn?
Yes, but only up to a point. LinguaLeap is excellent for building vocabulary and for practising common phrases until they become automatic. My spelling and my grasp of basic grammar have improved noticeably, and my Spanish teacher has commented on how much vocabulary I now recall in class.

However, the app has serious limitations. Because most exercises involve choosing or rearranging words, you are rarely forced to produce language from scratch, which is exactly what real conversation demands. The speaking exercises are generous to the point of meaninglessness: on one occasion, the app accepted my attempt at a sentence even though I had sneezed halfway through it. And grammar is taught by repetition rather than explanation, so I often knew that a sentence was right without understanding why.

There is also the question of what the app is really designed to do. The streaks, points and leagues are brilliant at keeping you coming back, but at times I caught myself choosing the easiest lessons simply to protect my streak - which is the opposite of learning.

Is it worth the cost?
The basic version is free, though it includes frequent adverts and limits how many mistakes you can make each day. The premium subscription removes these restrictions and adds extra practice features. For most students, the free version is perfectly adequate; the subscription is only worth considering if you use the app every day and the adverts are driving you to distraction.

The verdict
LinguaLeap is a superb supplement to language learning and a poor substitute for it. Use it to build vocabulary, to keep a language ticking over in the holidays or to get started before a trip abroad, and you will find it enjoyable and useful. But if you want to speak a language with confidence, you will also need lessons, real conversation and the courage to make mistakes in front of other people. As for me, I am off to protect my streak - and then, perhaps, to find someone to talk to in Spanish.

Explanation

Because the readers want an honest verdict, the strongest responses weigh the app's claims against evidence: they explain what it offers and why it is enjoyable, then judge how far it really improves learning, recognising its limitations and the way its rewards are designed to keep users hooked. An engaging hook (the 312-day streak) and a memorable, balanced verdict ('a superb supplement ... and a poor substitute') show sophisticated control. Weaker answers read like an advert, describe features without evaluating them, or ignore the question of cost. The app in the model answer is invented: any real or invented app or website is acceptable.

Mark scheme
  1. 27 marks

    Levels of response (27 marks). AO4 (communication and organisation).
    Level 1 (1-5 marks): Communication is basic and limited in clarity; little awareness of the purpose of the writing or of the intended reader; little awareness of form, tone and register.
    Level 2 (6-11 marks): Communicates in a broadly appropriate way; some grasp of the purpose and of what the intended reader expects; straightforward use of form, tone and register for a review.
    Level 3 (12-17 marks): Communicates clearly; a clear sense of purpose and understanding of what the intended reader expects; appropriate use of form, tone and register for a review.
    Level 4 (18-22 marks): Communicates successfully; a secure realisation of the task according to its purpose and the intended reader's expectations; effective use of form, tone and register for a review.
    Level 5 (23-27 marks): Communication is perceptive and subtle; the task is sharply focused on its purpose and on the intended reader's expectations; sophisticated use of form, tone and register for a review.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to inform and advise students and parents by evaluating a learning app or website honestly. Audience: students and their parents using an education website: readers who want a trustworthy, balanced judgement, so the tone should be honest and considered, though it may be lively. Form: a review. It may use conventions such as a title or headline, the name and key details of what is reviewed, a star or numerical rating, subheadings, a balance of description and evaluation, and a clear verdict or recommendation. Candidates do not need layout features such as columns or pictures. There should be clear organisation, with an engaging introduction, development of points and a conclusion. Responses may: describe what the app or website offers (subjects, activities, quizzes, videos, games, progress tracking, rewards); evaluate its design, ease of use and enjoyment; judge how far it genuinely helps learning, with examples or evidence of progress, and its limitations (shallow learning, distraction, over-reliance on rewards, accuracy); consider cost (free version, subscriptions, adverts, in-app purchases) and value; compare it with other ways of learning; recommend how and by whom it is best used. Reviews of real or invented places, events and works are equally acceptable; do not reward or penalise the accuracy of details about real ones. Higher-level responses: evaluate rather than simply describe, supporting each judgement with precise, vivid detail; balance strengths with fair criticism; sustain a confident, engaging reviewing voice suited to the named readers; and reach a clear, justified verdict that tells readers who the subject would suit. Lower-level responses: mainly narrate the visit or retell the story in time order, offer vague praise or criticism ('it was good'), deal with only part of the task, or lose sight of the named readers. The bullets in the question are suggestions ('may include'): a response need not cover every one, but it should address the whole task. Mark by best fit: a response need not meet every descriptor of a level to be placed in it. Length is not assessed directly, but a very brief or unfinished response is unlikely to develop ideas enough for the higher levels.

  2. 18 marks

    Levels of response (18 marks). AO5 (technical accuracy).
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Expresses information and ideas with limited use of structural and grammatical features; basic vocabulary, often misspelt; punctuation with basic control; undeveloped, often repetitive sentence structures.
    Level 2 (4-7 marks): Expresses and orders information and ideas, using paragraphs and a range of structural and grammatical features; some correctly spelt vocabulary (e.g. words with regular patterns such as prefixes, suffixes and double consonants); punctuation with some control; a range of sentence structures including coordination and subordination.
    Level 3 (8-11 marks): Develops and connects appropriate information and ideas, with structural and grammatical features and paragraphing that make the meaning clear; varied vocabulary, with words containing irregular patterns spelt correctly; accurate and varied punctuation; sentence structures adapted as appropriate.
    Level 4 (12-15 marks): Manages information and ideas, with structural and grammatical features used cohesively and deliberately across the text; wide, selective vocabulary with only occasional spelling errors; a range of punctuation positioned for clarity; sentence structures managed for deliberate effect.
    Level 5 (16-18 marks): Manipulates complex ideas, using a range of structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion; extensive vocabulary used strategically, with rare spelling errors that do not detract from overall meaning; accurate punctuation used to aid emphasis and precision; a range of sentence structures used accurately and selectively to achieve particular effects.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Mark this point for technical accuracy only, by best fit, across the whole response (ideas, content and adaptation to purpose and audience are credited under AO4): the range, precision and spelling of vocabulary (including ambitious and irregular words); the variety and control of sentence structures (simple, compound and complex; questions, commands and short sentences used deliberately for effect); paragraphing and cohesion (topic sentences, clear links between and within paragraphs); and the accuracy and range of punctuation (secure sentence boundaries, commas in complex sentences, apostrophes, and colons, semicolons, dashes, brackets, question and exclamation marks used correctly and for effect), with consistent tense, agreement and Standard English. Informal touches suited to the audience are acceptable if clearly deliberate and controlled. Titles, ratings and subheadings are acceptable conventions of a review: do not treat them as errors, and do not count them as evidence of sentence control. Frequent comma splices, run-on sentences, missing paragraphs or errors in common spellings keep a response in Level 2 or Level 3 however ambitious its vocabulary; Level 5 needs accuracy and deliberate, selective control throughout, though rare slips do not prevent it. A very brief response offers limited evidence of range.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.