Question 1
45 marksYour school's student magazine is starting a regular page called 'Screen Time', on which students review films for other students.
Write a review of a film you have watched recently, either at the cinema or at home, for the magazine.
Your review may include:
- what the film is about and how well it is made
- who would enjoy the film and whether it is worth watching
- any other points you wish to make.
Your response will be marked for the accurate and appropriate use of vocabulary, spelling, punctuation and grammar.
Model answer
Ninety Miles of Snow
Four stars out of five
There is a moment, about halfway through Ninety Miles of Snow, when the cinema fell completely silent. Nobody rustled a sweet wrapper; nobody checked a phone. On screen, two teenagers stood at the edge of a frozen lake, deciding whether the ice would hold. I realised I was holding my breath, and I suspect I was not the only one. It is that kind of film: quiet, patient and, when it matters, absolutely gripping.
What is it about?
The premise is simple. When their father's truck breaks down on a remote mountain road in the middle of winter, sixteen-year-old Mara and her younger brother Teo set off on foot to find help, armed with little more than a torch, a flask of soup and a long-running argument about whose fault it all is. What follows is part survival thriller and part family drama, as the journey forces the siblings to confront the resentments that have been building since their mother left. I will say no more, because the film's twists deserve to be discovered, not spoiled in a school magazine.
How well is it made?
Exceptionally well, for the most part. The two young leads are the film's greatest strength. Mara is prickly, sarcastic and fiercely protective, and the actress playing her reveals the fear behind the attitude with nothing more than a glance. Teo could easily have been an irritating little brother, but he is played with such warmth and comic timing that he steals almost every scene. Their bickering feels real - anyone with a sibling will recognise it - which makes the moments of tenderness all the more powerful.
Visually, the film is stunning. The director uses vast, wide shots of white mountains to make the pair look tiny and helpless, then switches to tight, shaky close-ups when danger strikes, so that you feel trapped alongside them. The soundtrack is sparse: long stretches have no music at all, only the crunch of boots and the howl of the wind, and that silence is far more frightening than any orchestra.
Any weaknesses?
A few. The middle section drags; there is only so much trudging through snow that an audience can take, and twenty minutes could have been cut without losing anything important. The flashbacks to the family's life before the breakdown are clumsy, too, spelling out emotions that the actors had already shown us perfectly well. Some viewers may find the ending too neat - I won't say why - although I found it satisfying.
Who should watch it?
Ninety Miles of Snow is rated suitable for viewers aged twelve and over, and that feels right: there are tense moments and one scene involving an injury that might upset younger children, but nothing gratuitous. It is ideal for anyone who enjoys survival stories or character-driven drama, and it would make an excellent choice for a family film night, provided everyone is willing to put their phones away. If you need an explosion every ten minutes, though, this is not the film for you.
The verdict
This is a film that trusts its audience: it lets silences speak and allows its characters to be flawed. Despite a sluggish middle and some heavy-handed flashbacks, it delivers genuine tension and an emotional punch that stayed with me long after the credits rolled. Wrap up warm and go and see it.
Explanation
The best film reviews give just enough of the premise to hook the reader, then spend most of their length evaluating how the film is made - acting, camera work, sound, pacing - with specific moments as evidence. A spoiler-free approach, a clear sense of the viewer the film suits and a balanced verdict show secure awareness of audience and form. The commonest pitfall is retelling the whole storyline, including the ending, which leaves no room for judgement; others are vague praise ('the acting was really good') and a register too casual for a magazine. The film in the model answer is invented: any real or invented film is acceptable.
Mark scheme
-
27 marks
Levels of response (27 marks). AO4 (communication and organisation).
Level 1 (1-5 marks): Communication is basic and limited in clarity; little awareness of the purpose of the writing or of the intended reader; little awareness of form, tone and register.
Level 2 (6-11 marks): Communicates in a broadly appropriate way; some grasp of the purpose and of what the intended reader expects; straightforward use of form, tone and register for a review.
Level 3 (12-17 marks): Communicates clearly; a clear sense of purpose and understanding of what the intended reader expects; appropriate use of form, tone and register for a review.
Level 4 (18-22 marks): Communicates successfully; a secure realisation of the task according to its purpose and the intended reader's expectations; effective use of form, tone and register for a review.
Level 5 (23-27 marks): Communication is perceptive and subtle; the task is sharply focused on its purpose and on the intended reader's expectations; sophisticated use of form, tone and register for a review.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to inform students about a film and evaluate it, helping them decide whether to watch it; to entertain. Audience: students at the writer's school reading a student magazine: peers, so a lively, engaging register with some informality is appropriate, provided it remains controlled. Form: a review. It may use conventions such as a title or headline, the name and key details of what is reviewed, a star or numerical rating, subheadings, a balance of description and evaluation, and a clear verdict or recommendation. Candidates do not need layout features such as columns or pictures. There should be clear organisation, with an engaging introduction, development of points and a conclusion. Responses may: introduce the film's premise and genre without giving away the ending; evaluate the acting, characters, direction, camera work, music, special effects, dialogue and pacing, using specific moments as evidence; identify strengths and weaknesses; consider age suitability, the kind of viewer who would enjoy it and whether it is best seen at the cinema or at home; compare it with similar films where helpful; end with a verdict or rating. Reviews of real or invented places, events and works are equally acceptable; do not reward or penalise the accuracy of details about real ones. Higher-level responses: evaluate rather than simply describe, supporting each judgement with precise, vivid detail; balance strengths with fair criticism; sustain a confident, engaging reviewing voice suited to the named readers; and reach a clear, justified verdict that tells readers who the subject would suit. Lower-level responses: mainly narrate the visit or retell the story in time order, offer vague praise or criticism ('it was good'), deal with only part of the task, or lose sight of the named readers. The bullets in the question are suggestions ('may include'): a response need not cover every one, but it should address the whole task. Mark by best fit: a response need not meet every descriptor of a level to be placed in it. Length is not assessed directly, but a very brief or unfinished response is unlikely to develop ideas enough for the higher levels.
-
18 marks
Levels of response (18 marks). AO5 (technical accuracy).
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Expresses information and ideas with limited use of structural and grammatical features; basic vocabulary, often misspelt; punctuation with basic control; undeveloped, often repetitive sentence structures.
Level 2 (4-7 marks): Expresses and orders information and ideas, using paragraphs and a range of structural and grammatical features; some correctly spelt vocabulary (e.g. words with regular patterns such as prefixes, suffixes and double consonants); punctuation with some control; a range of sentence structures including coordination and subordination.
Level 3 (8-11 marks): Develops and connects appropriate information and ideas, with structural and grammatical features and paragraphing that make the meaning clear; varied vocabulary, with words containing irregular patterns spelt correctly; accurate and varied punctuation; sentence structures adapted as appropriate.
Level 4 (12-15 marks): Manages information and ideas, with structural and grammatical features used cohesively and deliberately across the text; wide, selective vocabulary with only occasional spelling errors; a range of punctuation positioned for clarity; sentence structures managed for deliberate effect.
Level 5 (16-18 marks): Manipulates complex ideas, using a range of structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion; extensive vocabulary used strategically, with rare spelling errors that do not detract from overall meaning; accurate punctuation used to aid emphasis and precision; a range of sentence structures used accurately and selectively to achieve particular effects.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Mark this point for technical accuracy only, by best fit, across the whole response (ideas, content and adaptation to purpose and audience are credited under AO4): the range, precision and spelling of vocabulary (including ambitious and irregular words); the variety and control of sentence structures (simple, compound and complex; questions, commands and short sentences used deliberately for effect); paragraphing and cohesion (topic sentences, clear links between and within paragraphs); and the accuracy and range of punctuation (secure sentence boundaries, commas in complex sentences, apostrophes, and colons, semicolons, dashes, brackets, question and exclamation marks used correctly and for effect), with consistent tense, agreement and Standard English. Informal touches suited to the audience are acceptable if clearly deliberate and controlled. Titles, ratings and subheadings are acceptable conventions of a review: do not treat them as errors, and do not count them as evidence of sentence control. Frequent comma splices, run-on sentences, missing paragraphs or errors in common spellings keep a response in Level 2 or Level 3 however ambitious its vocabulary; Level 5 needs accuracy and deliberate, selective control throughout, though rare slips do not prevent it. A very brief response offers limited evidence of range.