Remind yourself of the extract from 'The Explorer's Daughter' by Kari Herbert in the Pearson Edexcel International GCSE English Anthology.
How does the writer use language and structure to move between narrative, information and reflection in this extract?
You should support your answer with close reference to the extract, including brief quotations.
Model answer
Herbert opens in the middle of the action: 'Two hours after the last of the hunters had returned and eaten, narwhal were spotted again'. This in medias res opening plunges the reader into an ongoing hunt, and the past-tense narrative with time markers ('Within an hour') creates momentum. The first paragraph is a panoramic description from 'the lookout', full of light and colour ('butter-gold', 'glittering kingdom'), and it ends on a note of wonder as she questions whether the narwhal 'existed at all'.
The second and third paragraphs shift to information. The register becomes factual and explanatory: 'The narwhal rarely stray from High Arctic waters'; the mattak is 'rich in necessary minerals and vitamins'. Specialist vocabulary, statistics ('up to six feet in length'), parentheses and a list of the tusk's uses give these paragraphs the feel of a reference book. This slows the pace, but it also gives the reader the knowledge needed to understand why the hunt matters.
The fourth paragraph returns to narrative with the women 'clustered on the knoll', linking the facts to real families: 'it was crucial to her that her husband catch a narwhal'. The simile 'like watching a vast, waterborne game' reconnects with the visual scene. The fifth paragraph is again informative, about the narwhal's 'keen' senses, but it is tied directly to the action: 'That ... was why the hunters had to sit so very still'. This alternation keeps the reader moving between observing and understanding.
The sixth paragraph is the climax. One hunter takes aim, and the narrative slows to a single moment, 'in that split second'. Here the writing becomes most personal and emotional, with 'my heart leapt' and the tricolon 'to dive, to leave, to survive'.
The final paragraph moves into reflection and argument, and the tense shifts to the present: 'I understand', 'I know', 'I have been asked'. Herbert anticipates criticism with the quoted question 'How can you possibly eat seal?', concedes a point ('True') and rebuts it with facts about supply ships and planes. The extract ends with a short, emphatic declarative: 'Hunting is still an absolute necessity in Thule.'
This structure mirrors her dilemma. The narrative and descriptive sections show her emotional response to the narwhal, while the informative and argumentative sections show her rational understanding of the hunters' needs. Because the hunt's outcome is never revealed, the extract ends with her argument rather than a kill, guiding the reader to understand rather than to judge.
Explanation
This question rewards an overview of how the extract is built: narrative opening, informative paragraphs, return to the hunt, climax, and reflective argument in the present tense. The best answers explain why each shift happens and how the alternation mirrors Herbert's dilemma, while still analysing language. A summary of each paragraph in turn is not enough.