Question 1
4 marksRead the following extract from a speech given by a seventeen-year-old from Fiji, in the South Pacific, to an international youth conference on the environment, then answer the question at the end.
Listen to the Reef
by Losana Tuilau (fictional)
[1] Good morning. My name is Losana, I am seventeen years old, and I come from a small island in Fiji where, if you stand on the beach at low tide, you can hear the reef breathing. That is how my grandfather described it to me when I was a little girl: the hiss and sigh of the waves breaking on the coral far out, like the slow breath of a giant animal asleep in the sea. I would like you to hear it too. So, for a moment, please close your eyes and imagine that sound.
[2] Now imagine that it stops.
[3] I want to tell you about the first time I saw a reef die. I was twelve. My grandfather had taken me out in his boat, as he did most Saturdays, and I was snorkelling over a part of the reef I knew as well as my own bedroom. Usually it was a city: coral in every colour you can think of, purple and gold and electric blue, with clouds of tiny fish rising and falling above it, and a grumpy old grouper we called the Chief, who lived under a ledge and glared at me whenever I came too close. That day, it was white. Not a beautiful white, like sand or shells, but the white of bones. Stretch after stretch of it, silent and ghostly. Even the Chief had gone.
[4] I climbed back into the boat and cried. My grandfather did not tell me it would be all right. He simply said, 'The water is too hot. The coral is sick.' He was right. When the sea stays even a degree or two warmer than usual for too long, corals push out the tiny algae that live inside them - the algae that give them their colour and most of their food. The coral turns white. If the water cools in time, it can recover. If it does not, it starves.
[5] Some of you may be thinking: that is sad, but it is far away. It is not your reef. So let me tell you what a reef is. A reef is a wall that stands between my village and the ocean, breaking the strength of the waves before they reach our homes. A reef is a market, where families like mine have caught their food for hundreds of years. A reef is a nursery, where the young of countless species grow up. Coral reefs cover less than one per cent of the ocean floor, yet around a quarter of all the creatures in the sea depend on them at some point in their lives. When a reef dies, it does not die alone.
[6] And it is not only the coral that is in danger. In my country, villages that have stood beside the sea for generations have already had to move inland, away from the rising water. Imagine packing up your home, your school and the graves of your grandparents because the sea has decided it wants them. For us, this is not a warning about the future. It is the news.
[7] I am not here to make you feel guilty. Guilt is heavy, and people who are carrying something heavy tend to sit down. I am here to ask you to stand up. The decisions that will save or destroy reefs like mine are being made now - in parliaments and boardrooms, and also in classrooms like the ones you will go back to next week. You can push your schools and towns to cut their emissions. You can think about what you buy and what you waste. You can write to the people who represent you and ask them, politely and repeatedly, what they are doing. Above all, you can refuse to believe that it is too late. It is not.
[8] Because here is the part of the story I have not told you yet. Two years after that terrible white summer, I went back to the same place with my grandfather. And among the bleached skeletons there were small, stubborn patches of colour. New coral was growing - slowly, a few centimetres a year, but growing. Reefs can recover if we give them the chance. They are tougher than we think. So are we.
[9] My grandfather is eighty-one now, and he no longer takes the boat out. But he still sits on the beach at low tide, listening. I want him to hear the reef breathing for as long as he lives. I want my children to hear it, and theirs. Please help me make sure that they can. Thank you.
Look again at paragraphs 6 to 9.
In your own words, explain what the writer's thoughts and feelings are about the threat to her home and what should be done.
Model answer
The writer is clearly upset and angry that villages in Fiji have already been forced to move inland, abandoning homes and even graves, and she feels the danger is happening now rather than in the future. She does not want to make her audience feel guilty, because she believes guilt makes people give up; instead she wants them to act, and she is convinced that ordinary young people can make a difference through their schools, their choices and by pressing politicians. She is determined that it is not too late, and she feels hopeful because she has seen damaged coral recover. She admires the reef's toughness and believes people are just as strong, and she longs for her grandfather and her own future children to be able to hear the reef.
Explanation
In a speech, the writer's thoughts and feelings include her opinions and attitudes, so points such as 'she believes ordinary people can make a difference' are valid. Each point should be a separate idea in your own words; quoting "stand up" alone, without saying what she means, earns nothing. Cover the range of the section - anger, urgency, determination and hope.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
upset / angry / feels it is unjust that villages have been forced to move inland, leaving homes, schools and even family graves
Award 1 mark for each valid interpretation of the writer's thoughts and feelings, max 4. Answers must be in the student's own words: a quotation alone, without interpretation, scores 0, but a brief quotation used to support an own-words point is fine. Accept any reasonable interpretation supported by paragraphs 6 to 9. Credit each distinct thought or feeling once. Do not credit retelling of events that does not state a thought or feeling, or material from outside paragraphs 6 to 9. For example, do not credit crying when she first saw the bleached reef (paragraph 4).
-
1 mark
feels the danger is happening now, not in the future ("It is the news")
-
1 mark
does not want to blame the audience or make them feel guilty, because she thinks guilt makes people give up
-
1 mark
wants / urges people to take action now ("stand up"); believes decisions being made now matter
-
1 mark
believes ordinary young people can make a difference (through schools, what they buy and waste, and writing to their representatives)
-
1 mark
determined / insistent that it is not too late; refuses to give up hope
-
1 mark
hopeful / optimistic because she saw damaged coral starting to grow back
-
1 mark
admires the reef's toughness and believes people are just as resilient ("So are we")
-
1 mark
loves her grandfather and wants him, and future generations, to keep hearing the reef