Question 1
22 marksRead Text 1, an extract from a newspaper obituary of a Scottish nurse and writer who spent many years in the Canadian Arctic. Then answer the question at the end, which is about Text 1 and Text 2.
Text 1
Elspeth Rennie: the polar traveller who listened first
From a newspaper obituary by Callum Fraser (fictional)
[1] Elspeth Rennie, who has died aged 87, disliked being called an explorer. "You cannot explore a place where people have been living perfectly well for thousands of years," she told an interviewer in 1981. "I was a guest who stayed too long and asked too many questions." It was typical of a woman who spent more than a decade in the Canadian Arctic and came home with frostbitten toes, four books and a lifelong conviction that the North should be understood before it was admired.
[2] Born in Aberdeen in 1939, the daughter of a trawlerman, she trained as a nurse and in 1963 answered an advertisement for medical staff at a remote nursing station on Baffin Island. She expected to stay a year. She stayed eleven. In her first winter, she wrote later, the cold was "not a temperature but a living animal that waited outside the door". The Inuit family who lodged her laughed kindly at her heavy southern clothes, then sewed her a caribou-skin parka and taught her how to wear it.
[3] What followed was an education no university could have offered. She learned to drive a dog team, to build a snow house in under an hour and to wait, silent and motionless, beside a seal's breathing hole in temperatures of forty below. Her best-known book, The Patient Ice (1975), describes one such wait lasting nine hours. "My feet died, came back to life and died again," she wrote. "Beside me, Ipeelee did not move at all. When the seal came, he was ready and I was not. That is the difference between a hunter and a visitor."
[4] She was no romantic. Rennie described hunger, illness and the loss of a young friend through thin ice with a nurse's unflinching precision. But she grew increasingly angry at outsiders who judged Arctic life from comfortable distances. In the 1980s, when campaigns against seal hunting threatened Inuit livelihoods, she wrote furious letters to newspapers in London and Toronto. "People who buy their meat wrapped in plastic," she wrote, "should be slow to lecture people who thank the animal they have killed."
[5] Her own expeditions were modest by modern standards and stubbornly unglamorous. In 1972 she travelled 1,200 kilometres by dog sledge with two Inuit companions, carrying no radio. Asked whether that was reckless, she replied that the reckless thing would have been to go without people who knew the ice. When she fell through a crack in the sea ice in 1974 and was hauled out by those same companions, she wrote the episode up not as an adventure but as a lesson in humility.
[6] In later life she was a sharp critic of what she called "expeditions that are really advertisements" - record attempts sponsored by watch companies and drinks brands, which, she complained, treated the Arctic as a stage set and expected others to come running when things went wrong. "If you need rescuing, you were not ready to go," she told a lecture audience in Edinburgh in 2009, an audience that included several people she was clearly thinking of. Not everyone found her easy company. A fellow writer described her as "kind to everyone except fools, and she found a great many fools".
[7] She returned to Scotland in 1974 and worked as a district nurse in the Highlands until her retirement, writing in the long evenings. She never married. Each spring until her eighties, she flew north to visit the family who had first taken her in, and their grandchildren, who had grown up on her stories of Aberdeen, called her simply Auntie Elspeth.
[8] Elspeth Rennie, nurse and writer, born 3 March 1939; died 2 October 2026.
Text 2
Remind yourself of 'Explorers or boys messing about? Either way, taxpayer gets rescue bill' by Steven Morris in the Pearson Edexcel International GCSE English Anthology.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about explorers and adventurers.
Support your answer with detailed examples from both texts including brief quotations.
Model answer
Both texts are about people who travel to the polar regions, and both include rescues, but they present very different ideas about what makes a true explorer. The obituary celebrates Elspeth Rennie as a humble, serious traveller, while Morris's report questions whether Brooks and Smith are explorers at all.
The writers' perspectives are signalled from the start. Morris's headline asks whether the men are explorers "or boys messing about", and his first sentence says their last expedition "ended in farce". The obituary also opens with a challenge to the word "explorer", but it comes from Rennie herself: "You cannot explore a place where people have been living perfectly well for thousands of years." Both texts question the label, but Morris uses doubt to mock his subjects, while the obituary uses Rennie's doubt to show her modesty and her respect for the Inuit.
Both texts list achievements, but to different ends. Morris records that Brooks has been on expeditions to "70 countries in 15 years", trekked to Everest base camp and survived a gorilla charge; yet the list is undercut by phrases such as Smith "claims to have been flying since the age of five" and the reminder that they have "hit the headlines for the wrong reasons". The obituary lists Rennie's skills - driving a dog team, building a snow house, waiting at a seal's breathing hole - as "an education", stressing learning rather than conquest.
Attitudes to risk are sharply contrasted. Brooks and Smith flew a small single-engine helicopter far over the sea, and Morris quotes an expert who says they were "pushing it to the maximum". Rennie travelled without a radio but with companions who "knew the ice", and when she fell through the sea ice she wrote about it "not as an adventure but as a lesson in humility". Her later saying, "If you need rescuing, you were not ready to go", reads almost like a verdict on the men in Morris's article, whose rescue involved the Royal Navy, the RAF and a Chilean ship.
Both texts also criticise adventure as publicity. Rennie attacked "expeditions that are really advertisements", sponsored by "watch companies and drinks brands". Morris mentions a website promoting their expeditions, which claims they planned to fly pole to pole in their "trusty helicopter", and Brooks's "Breitling emergency watch"; quoted after the crash, "trusty helicopter" sounds absurd.
Each text uses other voices to shape our view. Morris quotes Brooks's wife calling them "boys messing about with a helicopter" and ends with her joke that they will "have their bottoms kicked", so the final impression is of naughty children. The obituary ends with Rennie's yearly visits to the family who took her in, then a formal line of dates - a dignified close. It admits her faults ("kind to everyone except fools"), which makes its admiration more convincing.
Overall, the obituary presents exploration as patient, respectful learning, whereas Morris presents it as reckless self-promotion that others must pay for. Ironically, the two texts agree on what a good explorer should be; they simply find it in different people.
Explanation
Strong answers see that the two texts share criteria for judging explorers (preparation, humility, responsibility, suspicion of publicity) but apply them to opposite subjects, and they explain how form and tone - an admiring obituary against an ironic news report - convey each perspective. Top-band responses compare specific methods, such as the opposing uses of lists of achievements and of quotation. A common weakness is to describe Rennie's life and then the helicopter rescue without linking them. Writing about only one text caps the mark at 8.
Mark scheme
-
22 marks
Levels of response (22 marks). AO3 (comparing writers' ideas and perspectives, and how they are conveyed).
Level 1 (1-4 marks): Basic. The response does not compare the texts; it describes the writers' ideas and perspectives, including theme, language and/or structure; the use of references is limited.
Level 2 (5-8 marks): Some. The response considers obvious comparisons between the texts; it comments on the writers' ideas and perspectives, including theme, language and/or structure; the selection of references is valid but not developed. Only ONE text considered: maximum top of Level 2 (8 marks).
Level 3 (9-13 marks): Clear. The response considers a range of comparisons between the texts; it explains the writers' ideas and perspectives, including theme, language and/or structure; references are appropriate and relevant to the points made.
Level 4 (14-18 marks): Thorough. The response considers a wide range of comparisons; it explores the writers' ideas and perspectives, including how theme, language and/or structure are used across the texts; references are balanced across both texts and fully support the points made.
Level 5 (19-22 marks): Perceptive. The response considers a varied and comprehensive range of comparisons; it analyses the writers' ideas and perspectives, including how theme, language and/or structure are used across the texts; references are balanced, discriminating and fully support the points made.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points). Responses may compare:
- Both concern people who travel to polar extremes (the Canadian Arctic; the seas off Antarctica), and both include rescues: Rennie, hauled out of the sea ice by her companions; Brooks and Smith, picked up by a Chilean naval vessel after a rescue involving the Royal Navy, the RAF and coastguards.
- Perspective: the obituary is admiring though not uncritical; Morris's report is sceptical and mocking, its headline asking whether the men are explorers "or boys messing about".
- The label "explorer": Rennie rejected it ("You cannot explore a place where people have been living perfectly well for thousands of years"), seeing herself as "a guest"; Morris questions whether Brooks and Smith deserve it and notes "confusion about what exactly the men were trying to achieve".
- Preparation and humility versus bravado: Rennie travelled with Inuit companions who "knew the ice" and treated her accident as "a lesson in humility"; Brooks and Smith took a small single-engine R44 far over the sea, "pushing it to the maximum", and their Bering Strait expedition "ended in farce".
- Publicity: Rennie attacked "expeditions that are really advertisements" sponsored by "watch companies and drinks brands"; Morris mentions a website promoting their expeditions, which claims they planned to fly pole to pole in their "trusty helicopter", and Brooks's "Breitling emergency watch" - Rennie's criticism could almost describe Morris's subjects.
- Responsibility to others: Rennie's "If you need rescuing, you were not ready to go"; Morris's taxpayer "bill", recovery "highly unlikely".
- Lists of achievements: Morris lists Brooks's feats (70 countries, Everest base camp, the Zambezi, a gorilla) with undermining irony ("claims to have been flying since the age of five"); the obituary lists Rennie's skills (dog team, snow house, waiting at a breathing hole) as "an education", stressing learning rather than conquest.
- Use of quotation: both rely on other voices - the obituary celebrates through Rennie's own witty words and a fellow writer's verdict; Morris selects quotations (Ms Vestey, Endres, the MoD) that belittle.
- Structure: Morris opens with "farce" and "tragedy", builds the rescue drama, then achievements, earlier failures and expert doubts, ending with Ms Vestey's comic "bottoms kicked"; the obituary opens with Rennie's challenge to a label, follows her life chronologically and ends with formal dates - a dignified close.
- Irony: the two texts agree about what a good explorer should be, but find it in different people.
Marking notes: reward comparison of how ideas and perspectives are conveyed (language, structure, form, tone), not retelling. Responses that treat the texts separately with little linking are unlikely to go above Level 2 or low Level 3. A response that considers only ONE text: maximum 8 marks. Credit brief, accurate quotation or close reference to the anthology text (students have it in the exam).