'The similarities between the six articles of faith and the five roots of Usul ad-Din are more important than the differences.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Muslim teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many Muslims would agree that the similarities are more important. The most important belief in Islam is Tawhid, the Oneness of God, and it comes first in both the six articles of faith and the five roots of Usul ad-Din. Surah 112 teaches 'Say: He is Allah, the One!', and every Sunni and Shi'a Muslim declares the same truth in the Shahadah. Both groups also believe in prophethood (Risalah or Nubuwwah), accepting the Prophet Muhammad as 'the Seal of the Prophets' (33:40) and following the same Qur'an. Both believe in the Day of Judgement, called Akhirah or Mi'ad, so they share the same purpose in life: to live as God commands, knowing they will be held accountable. As these are the beliefs that make someone a Muslim at all, the similarities seem more important. Sunni and Shi'a Muslims pray towards the same Ka'aba and perform Hajj side by side as one Ummah, and in the Amman Message (2004-2005) leading scholars from both traditions recognised each other as Muslims.
On the other hand, the differences are significant. The root of Imamah teaches that God appointed Imams, beginning with Ali, to guide the community after the Prophet. Most Shi'a Muslims believe in twelve infallible Imams and see this as essential, pointing to Qur'an 2:124, where God appoints Ibrahim 'a leader for mankind'. Sunni Muslims do not accept this, and the disagreement about leadership is at the heart of the division between the two traditions. Adalat also shows a different emphasis: Shi'a Muslims make God's justice a root, stressing that God never acts unjustly and that humans truly have free will, whereas Sunni Muslims list al-Qadr, God's decree, as an article of faith. These differences shape practice, for example in whose teaching is followed and in commemorations such as Ashura.
However, some of the differences are more about how beliefs are grouped than about what is believed. Shi'a Muslims still believe in angels and holy books, which they include within Nubuwwah, and Sunni Muslims believe that God is just, since al-Adl (the Just) is one of the 99 names of God.
In conclusion, I agree with the statement. The differences, especially over Imamah, are real and have shaped history, but the shared beliefs are the ones that define Islam itself: a Muslim is someone who believes in one God, his prophets and the Day of Judgement. Since both traditions share all three, and many of the differences are a matter of emphasis, the similarities are more important.
Explanation
A top-level answer explains specific similarities (Tawhid, prophethood, the Day of Judgement) and specific differences (Imamah, Adalat, al-Qadr) and then weighs which matter more, rather than just listing them. Use the correct Sunni and Shi'a terms and support points with Muslim teaching such as Surah 112 or Qur'an 2:124. The conclusion should give a reason for the judgement, for example that the shared beliefs are the ones that define being a Muslim.