'Ibrahim's willingness to sacrifice his son is the greatest example of faith in Islam.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Muslim teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many Muslims would agree with this statement. Ibrahim's willingness to sacrifice his son was the ultimate test of submission, because he was prepared to give up the person he loved most simply because God commanded it. The Qur'an calls it 'a clear test' (37:106). His son's reply, 'O my father! Do that which thou art commanded' (37:102), shows that the faith was shared by both. Since the word Islam means submission to God, this story seems to show the heart of the religion. Its importance is shown by the fact that millions of Muslims remember it every year at Id-ul-Adha, and the Qur'an says that because Ibrahim fulfilled God's commands, God made him 'a leader for mankind' (2:124).
However, other Muslims would argue that there are equally great, or greater, examples. The Qur'an describes the Prophet Muhammad, not Ibrahim, as 'a good example' (33:21) for Muslims. He kept his faith through years of persecution in Makkah, rejection in Ta'if and the dangers of the Hijrah, and his faith was shown over a whole lifetime rather than in one moment. Even in Ibrahim's own life, being thrown into a fire for rejecting idols was an equally serious test, and Hajar showed great faith when she was left in a barren valley, trusting that God would not abandon her and her son.
Shi'a Muslims, and many Sunni Muslims, would also point to Imam Husayn, who gave his life and saw members of his family killed at Karbala rather than accept injustice. Unlike Ibrahim's son, Husayn's sacrifice actually took place. Others might say that the greatest faith is shown in ordinary daily obedience, such as praying five times a day, and that the Qur'an teaches that it is 'the devotion from you' (22:37), not the sacrifice itself, that reaches God.
In conclusion, I think Ibrahim's willingness to sacrifice his son is one of the greatest examples of faith in Islam, because it shows complete submission. However, I do not agree that it is clearly the greatest. The Qur'an presents the Prophet Muhammad's whole life as the best example, and the faith of Hajar and Imam Husayn is just as remarkable, so it is impossible to name one single greatest example.
Explanation
High-level answers explain why Ibrahim's willingness to sacrifice his son is so significant (submission, 37:102-107, Id-ul-Adha) and then weigh it against other examples, such as the Prophet Muhammad, Hajar or Imam Husayn. Including both Sunni and Shi'a perspectives shows reasoned consideration of different views. Avoid retelling the story at length: use it as evidence in an argument that leads to a justified conclusion.