'If God has already decided everything, it is unfair for God to judge people on the Day of Judgement.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Muslim teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some people agree with this statement. Sunni Muslims believe in al-Qadr, one of the Six Articles of Faith, which teaches that God knows everything and has recorded it in advance. The Qur'an says that no disaster happens 'but it is in a Book before we bring it into being' (57:22), and a hadith teaches that an angel writes down a person's deeds and whether they will be among the blessed or the wretched before they are born. If everything is already written, it can seem that people could not have acted differently, so punishing them on Yawm al-Din would be like punishing an actor for following a script. The Qur'an also says 'ye will not, unless (it be) that Allah willeth' (81:29), which seems to leave little room for real choice.
However, most Muslims argue that God's judgement is completely fair. They explain that God's knowledge is not the same as forcing: God knows what each person will freely choose, but this knowledge does not cause the choice. The Qur'an says, 'whosoever will, let him believe, and whosoever will, let him disbelieve' (18:29), and teaches that each soul is judged only for what it has earned and is never burdened 'beyond its scope' (2:286). Because humans do not know what is written for them, they experience life as a series of genuine decisions, which is why the Prophet told a man to tie his camel and then trust in God.
Shi'a Muslims place even more emphasis on this. Adalat (God's justice) is one of the five roots of Usul ad-Din, and a just God would never punish people for actions they were forced to commit. Imam Ja'far al-Sadiq taught that there is neither compulsion nor complete delegation of power to humans, but a position between the two. Both Sunni and Shi'a Muslims also believe that God judges intentions, forgives those who repent and weighs every deed on 'a just balance' (21:47).
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. It would be unfair if God forced people's choices, but Muslim teaching separates God's knowledge and decree from compulsion. Since people really choose, have been warned through the prophets and are judged only on what was within their power, the Day of Judgement is just. The statement treats al-Qadr as a fate that removes freedom, which neither Sunni nor Shi'a teaching accepts.
Explanation
A top-level answer explains why the statement seems convincing (al-Qadr, the hadith of the angel writing a person's destiny) before weighing the Muslim responses: knowledge is not compulsion, guidance has been given, and God is just and merciful. Showing the Sunni and Shi'a emphases accurately strengthens the evaluation. Make sure your conclusion follows from your reasoning, and avoid the common mistake of describing the Day of Judgement without ever discussing whether it is fair.