'Greater jihad is more important than lesser jihad.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Muslim teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Most Muslims would agree that greater jihad is more important. Greater jihad is the inner struggle against one's own selfish desires (nafs) in order to live as God wants, and the Prophet taught that 'the mujahid is the one who strives against himself' (Tirmidhi). A well-known hadith, which many scholars regard as weak but which is widely quoted, describes the Prophet returning from battle and saying that the Muslims had come back from the lesser jihad to the greater jihad. Greater jihad is a duty for every Muslim every day, young or old, male or female: it is the effort to wake for Fajr prayer, to fast in Ramadan, to give zakah, to be honest and to control anger. Since 'Islam' means submission to God, this daily struggle is at the heart of the religion. By contrast, lesser jihad is only allowed in rare situations and under strict conditions, and many Twelver Shi'a scholars teach that only defensive jihad is possible while the twelfth Imam is hidden.
On the other hand, some Muslims argue that lesser jihad can be just as important, because without it the Muslim community might not have survived. When the early Muslims in Madinah were attacked, God gave permission to fight 'because they have been wronged' (22:39), and Qur'an 22:40 says that without such defence places of worship, including churches and mosques, would have been destroyed. Protecting the weak and oppressed is a serious duty, and those who die in a lawful lesser jihad are honoured as martyrs. Others say that the two cannot be separated: a Muslim in a lawful lesser jihad must also overcome fear, anger and the desire for revenge in order to keep the strict rules against harming civilians, so lesser jihad itself depends on greater jihad. In Shi'a Islam, jihad as a whole is one of the Ten Obligatory Acts, which suggests that both forms are part of a single duty.
In conclusion, I agree with the statement. Lesser jihad may be necessary in extreme situations, but it is rare, limited by strict conditions and only acceptable when it is carried out with the self-control that greater jihad develops. Greater jihad, on the other hand, is the lifelong struggle that every Muslim must make to submit to God, so it is more important.
Explanation
High-level answers explain both forms of jihad accurately, weigh them with developed reasons and use teachings such as Tirmidhi's hadith and Qur'an 22:39. Showing that the two are connected, for example that lawful fighting needs self-control, is a good route to a justified conclusion. Never present lesser jihad as unlimited violence or link it to terrorism, which Muslims reject as contrary to Islamic teaching.