'Muslims should all mark Ashura in the same way.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Muslim teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some Muslims would agree that it would be better if all Muslims marked Ashura in the same way. The Qur'an tells Muslims to 'hold fast, all of you together, to the cable of Allah, and do not separate' (3:103), and a shared practice could show the unity of the ummah, especially in Britain, where Sunni and Shi'a Muslims often live and worship close together. Both events remembered on Ashura matter to all Muslims: Sunni Muslims also love the Prophet's family, and many mourn Husayn's death at Karbala as a terrible injustice, since the Prophet said, 'Husayn is from me and I am from Husayn' (Tirmidhi). Equally, Shi'a Muslims honour the Prophet Musa. If all Muslims remembered both Musa and Husayn, Ashura could become a day that brings Muslims together rather than one that highlights their differences.
However, most Muslims would disagree. Sunni and Shi'a Muslims mark Ashura differently because of their different histories and beliefs. For many Sunni Muslims the day is mainly about the fast that the Prophet himself kept and recommended, remembering God's rescue of Musa from Pharaoh (Sahih al-Bukhari). For Shi'a Muslims, Husayn is the third Imam, chosen by God, so his martyrdom is at the centre of their faith, and it is marked with majalis, processions and mourning. Many Shi'a Muslims do not keep the Ashura fast; instead some go without food and drink until the afternoon in sorrow, remembering Husayn's thirst. Forcing everyone to follow one practice would ignore these sincere beliefs. Even within each group there is variety: Sunni Muslims choose whether to fast on the 9th and 10th or the 10th and 11th, and many Shi'a scholars discourage practices that cause harm. Many Muslims would say that unity does not mean uniformity, and that respecting each other's practices is a better way to show the unity of the ummah.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. It is good for all Muslims to remember both Musa and Husayn, but the different ways of marking Ashura come from genuine and long-held beliefs about the Prophet's Sunnah and the imamate. Unity is better shown through mutual respect than by insisting that everyone does exactly the same thing.
Explanation
Top answers explain accurately why Sunni and Shi'a practices differ and then judge whether unity requires the same practice, using teachings such as Qur'an 3:103 and the hadith about Husayn. Treat both traditions with equal respect and avoid describing either practice as wrong. A justified conclusion might distinguish between unity and uniformity.