'The main purpose of fasting is to help Muslims understand the suffering of the poor.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Muslim teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some Muslims would agree that helping Muslims understand the suffering of the poor is the main purpose of fasting. By going without food and drink from dawn to sunset, Muslims experience a little of the hunger that poor people face every day, and this empathy often leads to action. Ramadan is a month of generosity: a hadith in Bukhari says the Prophet was at his most generous in Ramadan, and Muslims pay Zakat-ul-Fitr before the Id prayer so that poor families can celebrate too. Even those who cannot fast are linked to the poor, because fidyah is paid by feeding the hungry (Qur'an 2:184). In Britain many mosques run open iftars and collections for food banks during Ramadan, showing how fasting turns into care for others.
However, most Muslims would say that this is an important benefit of fasting rather than its main purpose. The Qur'an itself states the purpose: fasting is prescribed 'that ye may ward off (evil)' (Qur'an 2:183), which Muslims understand as taqwa, a constant awareness of God. Fasting is first an act of obedience, one of the Five Pillars for Sunni Muslims and one of the Ten Obligatory Acts for Shi'a Muslims. A hadith qudsi teaches that fasting is for God and that he will reward it, which shows its purpose is spiritual. Ramadan also commemorates the revelation of the Qur'an (Qur'an 2:185). Moreover, poor Muslims fast too, and they already know hunger; if empathy were the main purpose, fasting would mean little for them, yet it is equally their duty.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Understanding the suffering of the poor is a real and valuable result of fasting, and it is clearly connected to Ramadan through zakah, Zakat-ul-Fitr and fidyah. But the Qur'an names taqwa as the purpose, and the fact that every adult Muslim, rich or poor, must fast shows that the main aim is to draw closer to God. Empathy for the poor grows out of that closeness, so it is best seen as a fruit of fasting rather than its main purpose.
Explanation
High-level answers weigh empathy against the purpose stated in Qur'an 2:183 (taqwa), and use evidence such as Zakat-ul-Fitr, fidyah or the hadith qudsi. The point that poor Muslims also fast is a strong evaluative argument. Avoid simply listing benefits of fasting without deciding which is the main purpose.