'The imamate is the most important difference between Sunni and Shi'a Muslims.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Muslim teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many Muslims would agree with this statement, because the division between Sunni and Shi'a Islam began with the question of leadership. When the Prophet Muhammad died in 632 CE, Shi'a Muslims believe he had already appointed Ali as his successor at Ghadir Khumm, saying, 'For whoever I am his master, Ali is his master.' Sunni Muslims believe the Prophet left the choice to the community, which chose Abu Bakr as the first caliph. For Shi'a Muslims the imamate is one of the five roots of Usul ad-Din, so it is a matter of core belief, whereas it is not among the Sunni six articles of faith. Many other differences grow out of it: Shi'a Muslims follow hadith passed on by the infallible Imams and Ja'fari law, named after the sixth Imam; they follow a marja while the twelfth Imam is hidden; and their mourning at Ashura and pilgrimages to the shrines of the Imams come from their love of the Imams. This suggests the imamate is the root difference, not just one among many.
On the other hand, Sunni and Shi'a Muslims share far more than divides them. Both believe in Tawhid, the prophethood of Muhammad, the Qur'an and the Day of Judgement, and both pray, fast, give alms and perform Hajj side by side in Makkah. Sunni Muslims also love the Prophet's family: they honour Ali as the fourth Rightly Guided Caliph and mourn Husayn as a martyr, and many believe that a Mahdi will come. Some would say that the differences people notice most are practical ones, such as the Shi'a practice of combining the five prayers into three sessions, or the payment of khums. Many British Muslims also stress the Qur'an's command to 'hold fast, all of you together, to the cable of Allah, and do not separate' (3:103), arguing that no difference should be treated as so important that it divides the ummah.
In conclusion, I agree that the imamate is the most important difference. The differences in prayer, law and festivals are real, but most of them can be traced back to different beliefs about who should lead and interpret Islam after the Prophet. However, it remains a difference within one faith, because both groups share the same central beliefs and acts of worship.
Explanation
Top-level answers explain why the imamate matters to Shi'a Muslims (one of the roots of Usul ad-Din) and weigh it against other differences or against what the two groups share. Use accurate details, such as Ghadir Khumm and the choice of Abu Bakr, and treat both groups respectfully. A common weakness is to describe the differences without judging whether the imamate is the 'most important' one.