Question 1
1 markRead the passage, then answer the question.
Buying Modestine
From Travels with a Donkey in the Cevennes by Robert Louis Stevenson (1879)
(In the autumn of 1878, the Scottish writer Robert Louis Stevenson planned to walk alone through the Cevennes, a mountain region in the south of France, sleeping out of doors on the way. While he got ready in the little town of Le Monastier, he had a large sleeping-bag made, which he calls 'the sack'. He was writing in the 1870s, and a few of his ideas, such as the way he compares a horse to a fine lady, are old-fashioned views of his time.)
1 This child of my invention was nearly six feet square, exclusive
2 of two triangular flaps to serve as a pillow by night and as the
3 top and bottom of the sack by day. I call it 'the sack,' but it
4 was never a sack by more than courtesy: only a sort of long roll
5 or sausage, green waterproof cart-cloth without and blue sheep's
6 fur within. It was commodious as a valise, warm and dry for a
7 bed. There was luxurious turning room for one; and at a pinch
8 the thing might serve for two. I could bury myself in it up to
9 the neck; for my head I trusted to a fur cap, with a hood to
10 fold down over my ears and a band to pass under my nose like a
11 respirator; and in case of heavy rain I proposed to make myself
12 a little tent, or tentlet, with my waterproof coat, three
13 stones, and a bent branch.
14 It will readily be conceived that I could not carry this huge
15 package on my own, merely human, shoulders. It remained to
16 choose a beast of burden. Now, a horse is a fine lady among
17 animals, flighty, timid, delicate in eating, of tender health;
18 he is too valuable and too restive to be left alone, so that you
19 are chained to your brute as to a fellow galley-slave; a
20 dangerous road puts him out of his wits; in short, he's an
21 uncertain and exacting ally, and adds thirty-fold to the
22 troubles of the voyager. What I required was something cheap and
23 small and hardy, and of a stolid and peaceful temper; and all
24 these requisites pointed to a donkey.
25 There dwelt an old man in Monastier, [...] known to fame as
26 Father Adam. Father Adam had a cart, and to draw the cart a
27 diminutive she-ass, not much bigger than a dog, the colour of a
28 mouse, with a kindly eye and a determined under-jaw. There was
29 something neat and high-bred, a quakerish elegance, about the
30 rogue that hit my fancy on the spot. Our first interview was in
31 Monastier market-place. To prove her good temper, one child
32 after another was set upon her back to ride, and one after
33 another went head over heels into the air; until a want of
34 confidence began to reign in youthful bosoms, and the experiment
35 was discontinued from a dearth of subjects. I was already backed
36 by a deputation of my friends; but as if this were not enough,
37 all the buyers and sellers came round and helped me in the
38 bargain; and the ass and I and Father Adam were the centre of a
39 hubbub for near half an hour. At length she passed into my
40 service for the consideration of sixty-five francs [...]. The
41 sack had already cost eighty francs [...]; so that Modestine, as
42 I instantly baptized her, was upon all accounts the cheaper
43 article. Indeed, that was as it should be; for she was only an
44 appurtenance of my mattress, or self-acting bedstead on four
45 castors.
Glossary: child of my invention = something I had invented; six feet = about 1.8 metres; exclusive of = not counting; courtesy = politeness; cart-cloth = strong cloth used for covering carts; without = on the outside; within = on the inside; commodious = roomy; valise = a travelling bag; respirator = a mask worn over the nose and mouth; conceived = understood; beast of burden = an animal used for carrying loads; restive = restless and hard to control; galley-slave = a prisoner chained to the oars of a ship; exacting = demanding a lot; thirty-fold = thirty times; voyager = traveller; dwelt = lived; she-ass = a female donkey; high-bred = of a fine breed; quakerish = plain and neat, like the simple clothes of the Quakers; rogue = a likeable rascal; interview = here, meeting; want = lack; youthful bosoms = the hearts of the children; discontinued = stopped; dearth = shortage; deputation = a group of people acting for someone; consideration = payment; francs = French money; baptized = named; appurtenance = an extra part that belongs with something bigger; castors = small wheels under a piece of furniture
In line 16, the writer says that "a horse is a fine lady among animals". What does he mean?
Model answer
Horses are delicate and need a lot of looking after - the writer goes on to say a horse is "flighty, timid, delicate in eating, of tender health".
Explanation
This is a metaphor: the writer describes a horse as if it were a "fine lady", using an old-fashioned idea from the 1870s that rich ladies were delicate and fussy (his view then, not a fact about women). The list that follows tells you what he means about horses: easily frightened, fussy about food and often unwell. A common mistake is to take the words literally and think the writer is talking about who rides horses.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
Horses are delicate and need a lot of looking after.
The words that follow explain the comparison: a horse is "flighty, timid, delicate in eating, of tender health" (line 17) and "an uncertain and exacting ally" (lines 20-21), so it needs careful looking after. He compares it to a "fine lady" because of an old-fashioned idea of the 1870s that rich ladies were delicate and fussy: that was his view, not a fact about women. 'Gentle and easy to get along with' is the opposite of "exacting"; the passage never praises a horse's strength; the comparison is about how a horse behaves, not who rides it.