Question 1
20 marksYour local library is holding a 'Stories by Torchlight' evening, when children aged 8 to 11 will curl up in sleeping bags to listen to stories read aloud by the light of torches. The librarian wants funny stories with a touch of magic, and every one must start with this line:
Tonight is the museum sleepover, and I am the only one still awake when the dinosaur skeleton sneezes.
Write a story for the evening that begins with this line. Copy the line out as the first sentence of your story.
You have 30 minutes, including 5 minutes to plan. Aim to write about 300 to 400 words.
Model answer
Tonight is the museum sleepover, and I am the only one still awake when the dinosaur skeleton sneezes.
It is not a small sneeze. It is a huge, rattling, bone-shaking ACHOO that echoes round the Great Hall and makes the glass cases tremble. I sit bolt upright in my sleeping bag. All around me, twenty-nine children from Class 5L are snoring. Ms Petrov is snoring loudest of all.
I shine my torch upwards. The Stegosaurus towers over us, all spikes and plates and ribs, its long tail curling into the shadows. As I watch, its skull turns slowly towards me.
"Excuse me," it says, in a voice like a creaky door. "I don't suppose you have a tissue?"
I don't have a tissue, so I hold up my sock.
"It's the dust," it explains. "Nobody has dusted me for eighty-three years. It gets right up my nose holes."
"You don't have a nose," I point out.
"That," says the Stegosaurus, "makes it worse."
I creep across the hall, past the sleeping bags, to the cleaner's cupboard. Inside, I find what I need: a feather duster on a long pole.
For the next hour, I dust. I dust its skull and its spiky plates. I dust every one of its ribs. The Stegosaurus giggles when I do its tail, because apparently that is the ticklish bit. Clouds of grey dust float down like snow, and I have to hold my nose to stop myself sneezing too.
"Better?" I whisper at last.
The Stegosaurus takes a long, slow breath. "Wonderful," it sighs. "Now, could you possibly do one more thing? I have been staring at that wall for eighty-three years. I would love to see the stars."
So I find the switch that opens the blinds on the glass roof. Moonlight floods the hall, and above us, the sky is sprinkled with stars. The Stegosaurus tilts its head back and gazes up for a long time.
"I had forgotten," it says softly, "how beautiful they are."
I must fall asleep after that, because the next thing I know, Ms Petrov is shaking my shoulder and the hall is full of morning light.
"Who opened the blinds?" she asks, frowning. "And why is the Stegosaurus so ... shiny?"
Nobody knows. Except me.
And when I look up, I am almost certain the Stegosaurus winks.
Explanation
Writing in the present tense, as the opening line does, makes the night feel as if it is happening right now, and this story keeps that tense from start to finish. The joke in the first line is followed up at once, and the Stegosaurus has a personality of its own, shown through what it says ('That makes it worse'). The shiny skeleton in the morning hints that the night really happened, which is more satisfying than 'it was all a dream'. A common mistake is to begin in the present tense and slip back into the past ('I looked up') without noticing.
Mark scheme
-
15 marks
Levels of response: content and organisation (15 marks).
Level 4 (12-15 marks): Strong writing for a 10-11 year old. Engages the reader throughout and clearly suits the purpose, reader and form; imaginative (or, for non-fiction, well-chosen) ideas developed with relevant, well-selected detail; a controlled structure - an opening that draws the reader in, a developed middle and a satisfying ending (or, for non-fiction, a clear introduction, logically ordered sections and a conclusion); paragraphs linked smoothly; techniques chosen deliberately for effect (description through the senses, dialogue that shows character and moves the story on, figurative language, rhetorical devices).
Level 3 (8-11 marks): Secure writing of the standard most 11+ candidates reach. Mostly engaging and suited to the purpose and reader; relevant ideas, developed in places, though some parts are thin or predictable; a clear beginning, middle and end (or sensible sections); paragraphs, with some linking between them; some techniques used with some effect.
Level 2 (4-7 marks): Developing writing. Some relevant ideas, but simple, uneven or listed with little development; the purpose or reader is only partly kept in mind; a basic structure that may lose its way (a story that is mostly a list of events, an ending that stops suddenly); paragraphs used little or inconsistently; few techniques.
Level 1 (1-3 marks): A few simple ideas linked to the task; little sense of purpose, reader or form; little organisation and no paragraphs.
0 marks: Nothing relevant written.What the task needs: purpose - to entertain listeners with a funny story with a touch of magic; reader - children aged 8 to 11 listening at a cosy evening event, so the story should be easy to follow when read aloud, funny or gently magical, and never frightening; form - a complete story in paragraphs that begins with the given line and keeps the voice and tense it sets up (the first person and the present tense, as if the night is happening now), in which the sneezing skeleton matters; length - about 300 to 400 words. The word count is a guide: do not count words or lower the mark for a piece a little shorter or longer. A piece much shorter than asked (under about 200 words) has too little development for Level 4 and is at most Level 3; a piece of only a few sentences (under about 100 words) is at most Level 2. A story that carries straight on from the given line without copying it out is marked as if the line were there. Only a story that moves the line later, changes its meaning or does not follow on from it at all is at most Level 2; a title above the line, or a small slip in copying it, does not matter. A story that copies the line and then never comes back to the skeleton is at most Level 3. A story that stops with no ending is at most Level 3. A story that turns frightening (a skeleton that chases or harms the children) does not suit the cosy evening and is at most Level 3. A story that changes to the third person, or moves into the past tense after the line and stays there, is at most Level 3; single tense slips are marked in the second point. Judge by the standard of a strong 10-11 year old: Level 4 does not need the polish of an adult writer. What would make it engaging (indicative content, not a checklist; credit other good ideas): following up the joke of the line at once (the sneeze itself, the narrator's reaction); the museum at night brought to life through the senses (torchlight, echoes, shadows, glass cases), with any spooky hints turned into humour; a dinosaur with a personality (polite, grumpy, shy, bored after years on display) shown through dialogue; a problem the narrator helps with (dust, loneliness, a missing bone, wanting to see outside), or other exhibits joining in; a build-up and a climax that stay fun; an ending that rounds off the night, perhaps with a clue in the morning that it really happened. What limits a response: a tour of the exhibits with no story; jokes with no problem or shape; an ending that stops suddenly or says 'it was all a dream'; no paragraphs. Do not lower this mark for spelling or punctuation errors: they are marked in the second point.
-
5 marks
Levels of response: vocabulary, sentences and accuracy (technical accuracy) (5 marks).
Level 4 (5 marks): Ambitious, precise vocabulary used correctly; a range of sentence structures (simple, compound and complex, with varied openings) used for effect; spelling almost always correct, including ambitious words; punctuation almost always correct, including apostrophes and, where speech is used, inverted commas, and more advanced marks (colons, semi-colons, dashes, brackets) used correctly where they are used.
Level 3 (4 marks): Some ambitious vocabulary; sentences varied in length and structure; spelling mostly correct, with errors mainly in ambitious words; sentence punctuation secure, with some errors in commas, apostrophes or speech punctuation.
Level 2 (2-3 marks): Mostly simple, everyday vocabulary; some variety in sentences, but many begin the same way or run on; spelling errors in common words; sentence punctuation sometimes missed (commas joining sentences, missing full stops), though the meaning is clear.
Level 1 (1 mark): Limited vocabulary; simple or incomplete sentences; errors often get in the way of the meaning.
0 marks: Nothing written.Mark the writing itself, judged by the standard of a strong 10-11 year old. The opening line is given, so judge the vocabulary and sentences the child adds, not the line itself. In a story to be read aloud, ambitious vocabulary means vivid, well-chosen words that listeners enjoy, not rare ones: verbs of sound and movement in the dark (rattled, creaked, echoed, towered, tiptoed), sound words (ACHOO), and word choices that make a dinosaur funny, such as a very polite way of speaking. Credit sentences used for effect: a one-line paragraph for a joke or surprise, longer sentences that build up the scene, questions, and varied openings ('As I watch, ...'). Level 4 needs the present tense kept throughout, inverted commas with a new line for each new speaker, commas after fronted adverbials and in lists, and apostrophes. Errors to watch for at this age: missing full stops between sentences, commas joining two sentences, its/it's, there/their/they're, 'could of', speech punctuation outside the inverted commas, and slipping into the past tense ('I looked up'), the commonest slip in a present-tense story. A piece under about 100 words shows too little range for Level 4.