Question 1
1 markRead the passage, then answer the question.
Bring Back the Afternoon Break
Written for Tutor Hunt
1 Think back to your own days at primary school. When the bell
2 rang in the middle of the afternoon, what happened? If you are a
3 parent, there is a good chance that you burst out of the
4 classroom for a precious quarter of an hour of tag, skipping and
5 chatting before the last lesson of the day. For most children
6 today, that bell never rings.
7 The afternoon break is quietly disappearing from our schools. It
8 is time to bring it back.
9 This is not just my opinion: the figures are startling. In 2017,
10 researchers at University College London collected information
11 from more than 1,000 schools. They found that children aged five
12 to seven had 45 minutes less break time each week than children
13 of the same age in 1995. Among seven- to eleven-year-olds, only
14 15 children in every 100 still had an afternoon break at all.
15 Even lunchtimes have been squeezed.
16 Why does this matter? First, children need to move. According to
17 the NHS, children need at least an hour of activity a day on
18 average, and it should be lively enough to make them breathe
19 faster and feel warmer. A child who sits at a desk for most of
20 the morning, and again for most of the afternoon, will find that
21 hard to reach. Fifteen minutes spent racing round the playground
22 is a simple way to win back some of those minutes.
23 Second, tired brains need a rest. Every teacher knows the glazed
24 eyes and fidgeting fingers of a class that has been sitting
25 still for too long. A short burst of fresh air works like magic:
26 children come back calmer, brighter and ready to learn. We
27 grown-ups know this feeling well. Few of us would choose to work
28 all day without a cup of tea, a chat or a stretch of our legs.
29 Why should we expect more of a seven-year-old?
30 Third, break time is when children learn some of life's most
31 important lessons, and none of them is on the timetable. How do
32 you join a game when you feel shy? How do you settle an argument
33 about whose turn it is? How do you cheer up a friend who has had
34 a bad day? No worksheet can teach these things. Children know
35 how much breaks matter, too: in the same study, 87 out of every
36 100 pupils said that they liked or really liked their break
37 times.
38 Of course, some head teachers argue that there is simply not
39 enough time in the school day. There is so much to fit in, they
40 say, from fractions to French. I understand the pressure they
41 are under. But does a class that has been sitting still all
42 afternoon really learn more? A short break could make every
43 lesson that follows better, not worse. Others worry that breaks
44 lead to squabbles. Yet sorting out squabbles, with a caring
45 adult nearby, is exactly how children learn to get along.
46 There is one more reason, and it may be the most important of
47 all. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child,
48 which came into force in the UK in 1992, says that every child
49 has the right to relax and play. Play is not a treat to be
50 handed out for good behaviour, or an extra to squeeze in if
51 there is time. It is a right.
52 So here is my plea to every head teacher: give children back
53 their afternoon break. It costs nothing. It needs no new
54 equipment. It simply needs fifteen minutes and a bell. And to
55 every parent reading this: ask your child's school whether it
56 has an afternoon break, and if it does not, ask why not. Our
57 children deserve time to run, to rest and to laugh together.
58 Let's give it to them.
Glossary: glazed = dull and sleepy-looking; United Nations = an organisation that nearly every country in the world belongs to; Convention = an agreement between countries; came into force = began to apply; plea = an urgent request
In lines 38-45, how does the writer answer the head teachers who say there is not enough time in the school day?
Model answer
by suggesting a break could make later lessons better - lines 42-43 say "A short break could make every lesson that follows better, not worse."
Explanation
Persuasive writers often give the other side's argument and then answer it. Here the writer asks whether a class that sits still all afternoon "really" learns more, then suggests that a break would make lessons better. A common mistake is to choose the fractions and French option, but those are only examples of what schools have to fit in.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
by suggesting a break could make later lessons better
Lines 41-43: "does a class that has been sitting still all afternoon really learn more? A short break could make every lesson that follows better, not worse." The writer never says fractions and French matter less: they are only examples of what schools must fit in. The writer does not agree that breaks should be shorter. The writer never claims head teachers do not understand children, and even says "I understand the pressure they are under" (lines 40-41).