Question 1
20 marksYour town council looks after Elm Park, where the grass is cut short every two weeks from spring to autumn. A local wildlife group would like one corner of the park to be left uncut so that wildflowers can grow there, and the council will decide at its next meeting.
Write a letter to Councillor Bryant, who is in charge of the town's parks, persuading the council to turn part of Elm Park into a wildflower meadow. You do not need to write any addresses.
Here are some facts you may find useful:
- Since the 1930s, the UK has lost about 97 per cent of its wildflower meadows.
- Bees, butterflies and many other insects feed on the nectar and pollen of wildflowers.
- Bees and other insects pollinate many of the fruits and vegetables that people eat.
- Grass left uncut from spring to late summer gives flowers such as clover, buttercups and oxeye daisies time to bloom.
You have 30 minutes, including 5 minutes to plan. Aim to write about 300 to 400 words.
Model answer
Dear Councillor Bryant,
My name is Tomasz Nowak. I am ten years old, and I have played in Elm Park almost every weekend of my life. I am writing to ask you and the council to leave one corner of the park uncut, so that it can become a wildflower meadow.
Since the 1930s, our country has lost about 97 per cent of its wildflower meadows. That means that for every hundred meadows my great-grandparents could have walked through, only three are left. Without them, bees and butterflies are running out of places to feed. Elm Park cannot solve this problem on its own, of course, but it could be a small part of the answer.
Wildflowers matter to people as well as insects. Bees pollinate many of the foods that we eat every day, from apples and strawberries to tomatoes. If we want to keep eating them, we need to look after the insects that help them to grow. A meadow full of clover, buttercups and oxeye daisies would be like a cafe for bees, open all summer long.
A meadow would also make the park a better place to visit. At the moment, Elm Park is mostly very short grass. Imagine walking past a corner full of colour, humming with insects, with butterflies drifting from flower to flower. My school could use it for nature lessons, and families could stop to count how many different flowers they can spot.
I realise that some people may think a meadow looks messy, and that others want plenty of space for football and picnics. However, I am only asking for one corner, not the whole park. The rest could still be cut as usual. A mown path through the middle would show that the long grass is there on purpose, and a small sign could explain why. Our school eco club would be delighted to design it.
Finally, a meadow would save the council time and money. If one corner is cut only once a year, at the end of the summer, your gardeners will have less grass to mow.
Will you and the other councillors please vote to give the wildflowers a chance? I would be very grateful if you could let me know what the council decides.
Yours sincerely,
Tomasz Nowak
Explanation
This letter uses the facts in the task as evidence, but it explains what they mean ('only three are left') so that they make the reader stop and think. It answers the worry that a meadow looks messy with sensible ideas (one corner, a mown path and a sign) and ends with a polite question that asks for a decision. A common mistake is to copy the facts out as a list without using them to back up a point.
Mark scheme
-
15 marks
Levels of response: content and organisation (15 marks).
Level 4 (12-15 marks): Strong writing for a 10-11 year old. Engages the reader throughout and clearly suits the purpose, reader and form; imaginative (or, for non-fiction, well-chosen) ideas developed with relevant, well-selected detail; a controlled structure - an opening that draws the reader in, a developed middle and a satisfying ending (or, for non-fiction, a clear introduction, logically ordered sections and a conclusion); paragraphs linked smoothly; techniques chosen deliberately for effect (description through the senses, dialogue that shows character and moves the story on, figurative language, rhetorical devices).
Level 3 (8-11 marks): Secure writing of the standard most 11+ candidates reach. Mostly engaging and suited to the purpose and reader; relevant ideas, developed in places, though some parts are thin or predictable; a clear beginning, middle and end (or sensible sections); paragraphs, with some linking between them; some techniques used with some effect.
Level 2 (4-7 marks): Developing writing. Some relevant ideas, but simple, uneven or listed with little development; the purpose or reader is only partly kept in mind; a basic structure that may lose its way (a story that is mostly a list of events, an ending that stops suddenly); paragraphs used little or inconsistently; few techniques.
Level 1 (1-3 marks): A few simple ideas linked to the task; little sense of purpose, reader or form; little organisation and no paragraphs.
0 marks: Nothing relevant written.What the task needs: purpose - to persuade the council to leave part of a park uncut as a wildflower meadow; reader - Councillor Bryant, in charge of the town's parks, who must convince other councillors and think about cost and other park users, so the letter should be formal, polite and backed by evidence; form - a letter: a greeting ('Dear Councillor Bryant'), an opening that says who is writing and why, a paragraph for each main reason, and a sign-off such as 'Yours sincerely' with a name (no addresses needed); length - about 300 to 400 words. The word count is a guide: do not count words or lower the mark for a piece a little shorter or longer. A piece much shorter than asked (under about 200 words) has too little development for Level 4 and is at most Level 3; a piece of only a few sentences (under about 100 words) is at most Level 2. A piece with no letter form (no greeting and no sign-off) is at most Level 3. A letter that is rude or unsuitable in tone for a councillor (demands, insults, blaming the council for destroying nature) is at most Level 3. A piece that does not try to persuade, or only copies out the facts, is at most Level 2. Judge by the standard of a strong 10-11 year old: Level 4 does not need the polish of an adult writer. What would make it engaging (indicative content, not a checklist; credit other good ideas): an opening that makes the request clear and shows why the writer cares (a local child who uses the park); the facts in the task used as evidence and explained rather than copied (what losing 97 per cent of meadows means, why pollinating insects matter to the food people eat), with the writer's own knowledge added; a picture of the meadow to help the reader imagine it; benefits for people as well as wildlife (nature lessons, a more interesting park, less mowing to pay for); a counter-argument stated fairly (a meadow may look untidy, people need space for games) and answered sensibly (only one corner, a mown path, a sign); polite persuasive techniques (a rhetorical question, a list of three, 'Imagine ...'); a conclusion with a specific request, such as a vote in favour or a trial for one summer. What limits a response: the four facts copied out as a list with nothing added; reasons that are only feelings ('flowers are pretty'); forgetting the reader, for example writing as if to other children; no clear request; no paragraphs. Do not lower this mark for spelling or punctuation errors: they are marked in the second point.
-
5 marks
Levels of response: vocabulary, sentences and accuracy (technical accuracy) (5 marks).
Level 4 (5 marks): Ambitious, precise vocabulary used correctly; a range of sentence structures (simple, compound and complex, with varied openings) used for effect; spelling almost always correct, including ambitious words; punctuation almost always correct, including apostrophes and, where speech is used, inverted commas, and more advanced marks (colons, semi-colons, dashes, brackets) used correctly where they are used.
Level 3 (4 marks): Some ambitious vocabulary; sentences varied in length and structure; spelling mostly correct, with errors mainly in ambitious words; sentence punctuation secure, with some errors in commas, apostrophes or speech punctuation.
Level 2 (2-3 marks): Mostly simple, everyday vocabulary; some variety in sentences, but many begin the same way or run on; spelling errors in common words; sentence punctuation sometimes missed (commas joining sentences, missing full stops), though the meaning is clear.
Level 1 (1 mark): Limited vocabulary; simple or incomplete sentences; errors often get in the way of the meaning.
0 marks: Nothing written.Mark the writing itself, judged by the standard of a strong 10-11 year old. Credit formal, precise vocabulary for a letter about nature (pollinate, insects, habitat, nectar, decline, wildlife, consider) and polite, persuasive phrasing ('I would be very grateful if ...', 'I realise that ...', 'Surely ...'). Credit sentences used for effect: a rhetorical question, a list of three, a short sentence that makes a fact stand out, a sentence beginning 'Imagine ...', and varied openings with linking words (Firstly, Furthermore, However, Finally). Numbers and facts taken from the task should be copied correctly. Level 4 needs accurate sentence punctuation with commas after fronted adverbials and in lists, apostrophes, question marks, and a colon or dash used correctly where one is used. Errors to watch for at this age: missing full stops between sentences, commas joining two sentences, its/it's, there/their/they're, 'could of', 'sincerly', a capital letter missing from 'Councillor Bryant' or 'Elm Park', and slang or text-speak in a formal letter. A piece under about 100 words shows too little range for Level 4.