Question 1
20 marksThe children's ward at your local hospital has a reading trolley, and the nurses are collecting stories written by children to cheer up young patients. This month, they would like mysteries.
Here is the opening of a story:
I only borrowed the book because it was the oldest one on the library shelf. It had a faded green cover, it smelled like Grandma's attic, and the date stamps inside went all the way back to 1979.
I was halfway through chapter three when an envelope slid out from between the pages and landed in my lap. It was small and yellow, and on the front, in neat, curly handwriting, it said: For the next person who reads this book all the way to chapter three.
That was me.
Inside was a sheet of paper, folded into a tiny square. When I opened it out, I found a map of our town in blue ink, with the library, the park and the river all marked. Beside the park gates was a small red cross, and underneath, someone had written:
Look where the stone lion sleeps. Good luck!
Continue the story and give it an ending. Carry on from the moment the opening stops, without copying it out, and keep it in the first person and the past tense, so that the same narrator tells the rest of the story.
You could write about:
- what the narrator finds at the stone lion
- who wrote the note, and why
- what the narrator does at the end
You have 30 minutes, including 5 minutes to plan. Aim to write about 300 to 400 words.
Model answer
I read it three times. Then I ran.
Everyone in our town knew the stone lion. It lay beside the park gates with its chin on its paws, its nose worn smooth by all the hands that had patted it. Little children climbed on its back. Pigeons sat on its head. Nobody ever looked at it properly.
I did. I walked round it slowly. Mane. Paws. Tail. A pigeon that glared at me. No secrets.
Then I noticed the base. Under the lion's right paw, one stone was a slightly different colour. I knelt down and pushed it. It wobbled. With a scrape, it slid out, leaving a dark gap about the size of a shoebox. I took a deep breath and reached inside.
My fingers touched something cold and smooth: a glass jar with a metal lid. Inside was another note, in the same curly writing.
Well done! Now go back to where you started, and ask for the book that is never lent out.
I frowned. Libraries were all about lending books out. Still, I tucked the jar under my arm and hurried back, my mind buzzing like a beehive.
Mrs Achebe, who had been the librarian for as long as anyone could remember, was at the front desk. I put the jar down in front of her.
"Excuse me," I said. "Please may I see the book that is never lent out?"
For a moment, she stared. Then a slow smile spread across her face, and she lifted a thick notebook from under the desk. It had a faded green cover, just like my library book.
"I hid that envelope when I was ten," she said softly. "I have waited more than forty years for somebody to read that book all the way to chapter three."
Every page of the notebook was filled with the same curly writing: stories, poems and puzzles by a girl who loved this library more than anywhere else.
"You may read it," said Mrs Achebe, "on one condition. Every good mystery needs someone to keep it going."
That evening, I sat down with a small envelope and my best pen, thinking about the dustiest books in the library. Then, very carefully, I wrote on the front: For the next person who reads this book all the way to the end.
Explanation
This continuation keeps the narrator's voice, with its short, punchy sentences, and stays in the past tense all the way through. The search at the stone lion is slowed down with small details, so the find feels earned, and the second clue leads back to the library, where the mystery is solved and then passed on to someone new. A common mistake is to let the narrator find a treasure in one sentence and stop, without ever explaining who wrote the note or why.
Mark scheme
-
15 marks
Levels of response: content and organisation (15 marks).
Level 4 (12-15 marks): Strong writing for a 10-11 year old. Engages the reader throughout and clearly suits the purpose, reader and form; imaginative (or, for non-fiction, well-chosen) ideas developed with relevant, well-selected detail; a controlled structure - an opening that draws the reader in, a developed middle and a satisfying ending (or, for non-fiction, a clear introduction, logically ordered sections and a conclusion); paragraphs linked smoothly; techniques chosen deliberately for effect (description through the senses, dialogue that shows character and moves the story on, figurative language, rhetorical devices).
Level 3 (8-11 marks): Secure writing of the standard most 11+ candidates reach. Mostly engaging and suited to the purpose and reader; relevant ideas, developed in places, though some parts are thin or predictable; a clear beginning, middle and end (or sensible sections); paragraphs, with some linking between them; some techniques used with some effect.
Level 2 (4-7 marks): Developing writing. Some relevant ideas, but simple, uneven or listed with little development; the purpose or reader is only partly kept in mind; a basic structure that may lose its way (a story that is mostly a list of events, an ending that stops suddenly); paragraphs used little or inconsistently; few techniques.
Level 1 (1-3 marks): A few simple ideas linked to the task; little sense of purpose, reader or form; little organisation and no paragraphs.
0 marks: Nothing relevant written.What the task needs: purpose - to entertain by continuing a mystery and solving it in a satisfying way; reader - young patients of different ages in a hospital ward, so the story should keep them guessing, reward them at the end and stay comforting rather than frightening; form - a continuation in paragraphs that picks up just after the narrator reads the note, keeps the same narrator, the old book, the note and the town, and keeps the first person and the past tense, building to an ending; the opening does not need to be copied out; length - about 300 to 400 words of new writing. The word count is a guide: do not count words or lower the mark for a piece a little shorter or longer. A piece much shorter than asked (under about 200 words) has too little development for Level 4 and is at most Level 3; a piece of only a few sentences (under about 100 words) is at most Level 2. If the opening is copied out, mark only what is added. A piece that does not continue this opening (a new story, or one in which the note and the stone lion play no part) is at most Level 2. A continuation that drops the opening's voice or tense for much of the piece (changing from 'I' to 'he' or 'she', or moving into the present tense) is at most Level 3; an occasional slip is marked in the second point. A story that stops with no ending (the narrator reaches the lion and the story simply stops) is at most Level 3. Judge by the standard of a strong 10-11 year old: Level 4 does not need the polish of an adult writer. What would make it engaging (indicative content, not a checklist; credit other good ideas): a quick, purposeful start (the narrator setting off, perhaps with a friend or a family member); the search at the lion built up through careful detail (its paws, its base, a loose stone) so that the find feels earned; a find that makes sense of the note, whether a treasure, another clue or a message from the past; a link back to the old book, its date stamps or its curly handwriting; the narrator's thoughts and feelings shown as the mystery unfolds; dialogue that moves the story on; an ending that answers the main question (who wrote the note, and why) or leaves a pleasing secret, perhaps passing the mystery on. What limits a response: a search that succeeds in one sentence; a find with no link to the note; a long list of clues with no ending; telling rather than showing ('I was really excited'); an ending that stops suddenly; no paragraphs. Do not lower this mark for spelling or punctuation errors: they are marked in the second point.
-
5 marks
Levels of response: vocabulary, sentences and accuracy (technical accuracy) (5 marks).
Level 4 (5 marks): Ambitious, precise vocabulary used correctly; a range of sentence structures (simple, compound and complex, with varied openings) used for effect; spelling almost always correct, including ambitious words; punctuation almost always correct, including apostrophes and, where speech is used, inverted commas, and more advanced marks (colons, semi-colons, dashes, brackets) used correctly where they are used.
Level 3 (4 marks): Some ambitious vocabulary; sentences varied in length and structure; spelling mostly correct, with errors mainly in ambitious words; sentence punctuation secure, with some errors in commas, apostrophes or speech punctuation.
Level 2 (2-3 marks): Mostly simple, everyday vocabulary; some variety in sentences, but many begin the same way or run on; spelling errors in common words; sentence punctuation sometimes missed (commas joining sentences, missing full stops), though the meaning is clear.
Level 1 (1 mark): Limited vocabulary; simple or incomplete sentences; errors often get in the way of the meaning.
0 marks: Nothing written.Mark the writing itself, judged by the standard of a strong 10-11 year old. Credit precise vocabulary for the search and the narrator's feelings (weathered, mossy, crumbling, peered, rummaged, puzzled) and the narrator's own voice, which the opening sets up with short, confident sentences ('That was me.'). Credit sentences used for effect: a one-line paragraph at a moment of surprise, a question in the narrator's thoughts, a run of short sentences for a careful search, and varied openings, including fronted adverbials of time and place ('Ten minutes later, ...', 'Beneath its paw, ...'). Level 4 needs accurate punctuation, including inverted commas with a new line for each new speaker, commas after fronted adverbials, apostrophes (the lion's paw, couldn't), and a colon used correctly before a note or a list, as the opening does. Errors to watch for at this age: missing full stops between sentences, commas joining two sentences, its/it's (easily confused when writing about the lion), there/their/they're, 'could of', speech punctuation outside the inverted commas, and drifting from the past tense into the present. A piece under about 100 words shows too little range for Level 4.