Question 1
20 marksYour local nature reserve is making a booklet of nature stories written by children, to give to families who visit. The editors want stories that help readers to care about wild animals. This is your title:
The Night of the Turtles
Here is something you may find useful. Sea turtles lay their eggs in nests that they dig in sandy beaches. About two months later, the baby turtles hatch, dig their way up through the sand, usually at night, and scramble down the beach to the sea.
Write a story with this title for the booklet.
You have 30 minutes, including 5 minutes to plan. Aim to write about 300 to 400 words.
Model answer
For six nights, Aunt Eleni and I have sat beside the nest, and for six nights nothing has happened.
The nest doesn't look like much: a patch of sand on a Greek beach, circled by a fence of sticks and tape. But underneath it, Aunt Eleni says, are about a hundred loggerhead turtle eggs, laid by a mother turtle two months ago.
Tonight, the moon is almost full. It lays a silver path across the water, and the waves whisper as they slide up the shore. I am nearly asleep when Aunt Eleni squeezes my arm.
"Look," she breathes.
The sand in the middle of the nest is trembling. A tiny flipper pokes out. Then a head, no bigger than my thumb. Then, all at once, the sand bubbles with baby turtles, scrambling over each other like children racing out at home time.
They know exactly where to go: towards the brightest light, which should be the moonlight on the sea. But some of them are heading the wrong way.
I spin round. At the top of the beach, the restaurant has switched on its coloured lights, and a group of hatchlings is crawling straight towards them.
"They think the lights are the sea!" I gasp.
"Run," says Aunt Eleni. "Ask Mr Stavros to switch them off."
I race up the beach. Mr Stavros is stacking chairs, and when I explain, panting, he doesn't ask a single question. He just flicks a switch, and the lights go out.
When I get back, the lost hatchlings are already turning towards the silver path. We are not allowed to pick them up: they have to make this journey themselves. So I walk beside them, holding my breath, as they flap and slip and keep on going.
One by one, the waves scoop them up and carry them away. The last one is a small, sandy turtle with a crooked shell. It stops at the water's edge, as if it is saying goodbye. Then a wave rolls in, and it is gone.
Aunt Eleni puts her arm round me. "If that one is a girl," she says softly, "she might come back to this very beach in twenty or thirty years to lay her own eggs."
I stare out at the moonlit sea and make a promise. When she comes back, I'll be waiting.
Explanation
The story makes the reader care about the turtles by slowing down the moment they hatch and describing them closely, then adds a problem (the restaurant lights) that the narrator helps to solve. The present tense makes the night feel as if it is happening now, so it must be kept the whole way through. A common mistake is to turn a nature story into a list of facts, so that it stops being a story at all.
Mark scheme
-
15 marks
Levels of response: content and organisation (15 marks).
Level 4 (12-15 marks): Strong writing for a 10-11 year old. Engages the reader throughout and clearly suits the purpose, reader and form; imaginative (or, for non-fiction, well-chosen) ideas developed with relevant, well-selected detail; a controlled structure - an opening that draws the reader in, a developed middle and a satisfying ending (or, for non-fiction, a clear introduction, logically ordered sections and a conclusion); paragraphs linked smoothly; techniques chosen deliberately for effect (description through the senses, dialogue that shows character and moves the story on, figurative language, rhetorical devices).
Level 3 (8-11 marks): Secure writing of the standard most 11+ candidates reach. Mostly engaging and suited to the purpose and reader; relevant ideas, developed in places, though some parts are thin or predictable; a clear beginning, middle and end (or sensible sections); paragraphs, with some linking between them; some techniques used with some effect.
Level 2 (4-7 marks): Developing writing. Some relevant ideas, but simple, uneven or listed with little development; the purpose or reader is only partly kept in mind; a basic structure that may lose its way (a story that is mostly a list of events, an ending that stops suddenly); paragraphs used little or inconsistently; few techniques.
Level 1 (1-3 marks): A few simple ideas linked to the task; little sense of purpose, reader or form; little organisation and no paragraphs.
0 marks: Nothing relevant written.What the task needs: purpose - to entertain readers with a complete story set in the natural world that helps them to care about wild animals; reader - families visiting a nature reserve, adults and children together, so the story should be clear, gripping and true to nature; form - a complete story in paragraphs, with an opening, a problem and an ending, in which turtles (most likely hatchlings on their way to the sea) are at the heart of one night; length - about 300 to 400 words. The word count is a guide: do not count words or lower the mark for a piece a little shorter or longer. A piece much shorter than asked (under about 200 words) has too little development for Level 4 and is at most Level 3; a piece of only a few sentences (under about 100 words) is at most Level 2. A story with no clear link to the title (no turtles, or turtles mentioned only in passing) is at most Level 2. A story that stops with no ending is at most Level 3. The story need not be scientifically exact: credit believable detail and do not lower the mark for small errors of fact. Judge by the standard of a strong 10-11 year old: Level 4 does not need the polish of an adult writer. What would make it engaging (indicative content, not a checklist; credit other good ideas): an opening that builds anticipation (waiting by the nest, the darkness, the sound of the waves, a first movement in the sand); the beach brought to life through the senses (cool sand, moonlight on the water, the smell of salt); the hatchlings described closely (tiny flippers, the effort of every crawl) so that the reader cares about them; a problem or danger that is not frightening, such as bright lights drawing them the wrong way, a hole or a sandcastle in their path, hungry gulls or crabs, or a long, tiring wait; a main character who acts to help, or who learns something; dialogue that moves the story on; an ending that brings the night to a satisfying close (the last hatchling reaching the sea, a hope for the future). A story told by a turtle, or a fantasy story, can work well if it fits the title. What limits a response: a story that turns into an information text about turtles; a list of events with little detail; telling the reader how to feel ('it was really sad and then really happy'); an ending that stops suddenly; no paragraphs. Do not lower this mark for spelling or punctuation errors: they are marked in the second point.
-
5 marks
Levels of response: vocabulary, sentences and accuracy (technical accuracy) (5 marks).
Level 4 (5 marks): Ambitious, precise vocabulary used correctly; a range of sentence structures (simple, compound and complex, with varied openings) used for effect; spelling almost always correct, including ambitious words; punctuation almost always correct, including apostrophes and, where speech is used, inverted commas, and more advanced marks (colons, semi-colons, dashes, brackets) used correctly where they are used.
Level 3 (4 marks): Some ambitious vocabulary; sentences varied in length and structure; spelling mostly correct, with errors mainly in ambitious words; sentence punctuation secure, with some errors in commas, apostrophes or speech punctuation.
Level 2 (2-3 marks): Mostly simple, everyday vocabulary; some variety in sentences, but many begin the same way or run on; spelling errors in common words; sentence punctuation sometimes missed (commas joining sentences, missing full stops), though the meaning is clear.
Level 1 (1 mark): Limited vocabulary; simple or incomplete sentences; errors often get in the way of the meaning.
0 marks: Nothing written.Mark the writing itself, judged by the standard of a strong 10-11 year old. Credit precise vocabulary for the setting and the animals (shimmering, rippled, scrambled, flippers, hatchlings, shoreline) and sentences used for effect: a short sentence for the first movement in the sand, longer sentences that follow the turtles down the beach, and sentences that open in different ways, including fronted adverbials of time and place ('Just after midnight, ...', 'Across the sand, ...'). Level 4 needs accurate sentence punctuation and a range of other marks used correctly: commas after fronted adverbials and in lists, apostrophes, inverted commas with a new line for each new speaker if dialogue is used, and a colon, dash or semi-colon used correctly where one is used. Errors to watch for at this age: missing full stops between sentences, commas joining two sentences, its/it's (common in writing about an animal), there/their/they're, 'could of', speech punctuation outside the inverted commas, and changing tense by mistake, especially in a story told in the present tense. A piece under about 100 words shows too little range for Level 4.