"Sewa is the most important duty for a Sikh."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Sewa is selfless service of others, done without expecting reward. It is a central part of Sikh life, but whether it is the most important duty is debated.
There are strong reasons to agree. Sikhs believe God is present in every person, so serving others is a way of serving God. Sewa also helps to overcome haumai: humble tasks such as washing dishes in the langar or cleaning the shoes of the sangat develop nimrata (humility) and help a person move from manmukh to gurmukh. The Sikh Rahit Maryada describes sewa as a prominent part of Sikh religion. The Gurus set the example: Guru Nanak began the langar, Guru Amar Das served Guru Angad humbly for many years before becoming Guru, and Bhai Kanhaiya gave water to wounded soldiers on both sides of a battle, which Guru Gobind Singh approved. The sangat itself depends on sewa: the langar, the cleaning of the gurdwara and the teaching of children are all done by volunteers. Sewa shows that faith is genuine, not just words, and it benefits society, for example through Khalsa Aid's disaster relief and Pingalwara's care for the sick and disabled. It is also open to everyone, because it can be tan (physical), man (mental) or dhan (financial).
On the other hand, many Sikhs would argue that nam japna, remembering God's name, is even more fundamental. The Guru Granth Sahib begins with the Mool Mantra and is centred on praise of the Name; Guru Nanak taught that the true sangat is where the Name of the One God is praised (GGS 72). Without nam simran, sewa can easily become a way of earning praise and so feed haumai rather than remove it. Guru Nanak also taught kirat karni (honest work) and vand chakna (sharing) as duties alongside nam japna, which suggests that the Gurus intended a balanced life rather than one supreme duty. For khalsa Sikhs, keeping the commitments made at Amrit Sanskar, such as daily Nitnem, the five Ks and the Rahit Maryada, is an essential duty, and the sant-sipahi ideal adds a duty to defend justice and protect the weak. Finally, Sikhs believe that becoming gurmukh depends on God's grace (nadar), so no single duty guarantees spiritual progress.
Some Sikhs would say the question creates a false choice. They believe sewa and simran belong together: nam simran fills the mind with God, and sewa expresses that love in action. Sahaj-dhari Sikhs often play a very full part in sewa, while khalsa Sikhs see it as part of a wider discipline, but both would agree that sewa done without remembrance of God is incomplete.
In conclusion, I think sewa is one of the most important duties for a Sikh, because it puts belief in God's presence in everyone into practice and directly attacks haumai. However, it is not the most important on its own. Nam japna is the foundation from which true sewa grows, and the Gurus taught that the three duties form a single way of life.
Explanation
To evaluate 'most important', compare sewa with the other duties: nam japna, kirat karni, vand chakna and, for khalsa Sikhs, the Rahit Maryada. The point that sewa without nam simran can increase pride is a strong evaluative argument. A good conclusion explains how the duties relate rather than simply picking one.