"There should be no separate Bhatra or Ramgarhia gurdwaras."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Some Sikhs strongly agree with this statement. The Gurus taught that all people are equal and rejected the caste system. Guru Nanak taught that people should recognise God's light in everyone and not ask about their caste, because caste counts for nothing in the hereafter (GGS 349). The langar was established partly to break down caste, as people of every background sat and ate together. When Guru Gobind Singh created the Khalsa in 1699, the Panj Pyare came from different castes and drank amrit from the same bowl, and men took the name Singh and women Kaur, partly to remove caste surnames. From this point of view, gurdwaras linked to particular communities, such as Bhatra or Ramgarhia gurdwaras, keep alive the very distinctions that the Gurus tried to remove. Critics also argue that they divide the Sikh Panth at a time when Sikhs in Britain, a small minority, need to be united, especially to pass on their faith to young people, and that running several gurdwaras in one town duplicates effort and money.
However, many Sikhs would disagree. First, Bhatra and Ramgarhia gurdwaras are fully gurdwaras: they install the same Guru Granth Sahib, hold the same kirtan, Ardas and langar, and are open to everyone, Sikh or not. They do not claim that their members are superior to anyone. Secondly, they arose from real history. Bhatra Sikhs were among the first Sikhs in Britain, settling as travelling traders in port cities such as Cardiff and Glasgow from the 1920s and 1930s, and they set up some of the earliest gurdwaras in Britain. Ramgarhia Sikhs, traditionally craftsmen, came to Britain mainly from East Africa in the 1960s and 1970s, with experience of running their own community organisations. It is natural that people who share a history, customs and family networks should worship and organise together. Thirdly, these gurdwaras provide social support: they help newcomers, care for the elderly, run Punjabi classes and youth groups, and keep family traditions alive. The name Ramgarhia itself honours Jassa Singh Ramgarhia, an eighteenth-century Sikh hero, rather than making a claim to status. Some communities also set up their own gurdwaras because they wanted a voice in running them, which can be seen as a response to unfair treatment rather than a cause of division. Finally, many members of these communities also attend other gurdwaras, and their sangats do sewa for everyone.
A middle view is that these gurdwaras are acceptable, but Sikhs must make sure that community identity never becomes caste discrimination - for example, in who is welcome to serve in the langar, sit on committees or marry. The test is whether a gurdwara lives up to the Gurus' teaching of equality.
In conclusion, I do not fully agree with the statement. Bhatra and Ramgarhia gurdwaras do the same work as any gurdwara, are open to all and grew out of real migration histories, so getting rid of them would be unfair and would remove valuable community support. However, the Gurus' teaching on equality is clear, and these gurdwaras must make sure that a shared heritage is celebrated without becoming a barrier between Sikhs. Unity in the Panth does not require every gurdwara to be identical, but it does require every gurdwara to welcome everyone as equal.