"Every Sikh should take amrit and join the Khalsa."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Many Sikhs, especially khalsa (amritdhari) Sikhs, would agree with this statement. When Guru Gobind Singh founded the Khalsa at Vaisakhi in 1699, he created a community of committed Sikhs and gave them the Five Ks and a code of conduct. For many Sikhs, taking amrit is therefore obeying the Guru's command, and the Rahit Maryada's definition of a Sikh includes belief in the amrit initiation given by the tenth Guru. Joining the Khalsa is seen as the natural goal of a Sikh's life: it is a public commitment to live as a saint-soldier, to recite the daily Nitnem, to keep the Five Ks and to avoid the four cardinal misdeeds, such as cutting the hair and using tobacco. The Five Ks give a clear identity and act as constant reminders of Sikh values: the kara of God's eternity, the kirpan of the duty to protect the weak. Joining the Khalsa also expresses equality, since all initiates drink amrit from the same bowl and take the names Singh and Kaur. Some khalsa Sikhs would argue that a person who never intends to take amrit is not fully following the Guru.
However, sahaj-dhari Sikhs, and others, would disagree that every Sikh should take amrit, or at least that they should do so now. 'Sahaj' suggests a gradual path, and many sahaj-dhari Sikhs believe that a person should take amrit only when they are truly ready to keep the vows for life; taking amrit without sincere commitment and then breaking the vows would be worse than waiting. They point out that the Guru Granth Sahib, the living Guru, teaches that inner devotion - nam simran, honest living and sewa - is what brings a person close to God, and it criticises outward religious forms that are not matched by a pure heart. The followers of Guru Nanak and the next eight Gurus were Sikhs long before the Khalsa existed. Many sahaj-dhari Sikhs attend the gurdwara, wear the kara, recite prayers and serve in the langar, and see themselves as fully part of the sangat. Some Sikhs also find it hard to keep the full Rahit in Britain because of pressures at school or work, although UK law protects the right to wear the turban and to carry the kirpan for religious reasons.
Others might take a middle position: taking amrit is the ideal for every Sikh, but it must be freely chosen, and the Gurus taught that God is known by grace, so no one should be pressured. There is also diversity among Sikhs who keep some of the Ks: keshdhari Sikhs keep their hair uncut and wear a turban without being initiated.
In conclusion, I think the statement is right that taking amrit is the ideal set out by Guru Gobind Singh and in the Rahit Maryada, and for khalsa Sikhs it is the fullest way to live as a Sikh. However, 'should' is too strong if it means that every Sikh must take amrit now or is not a real Sikh. The Guru Granth Sahib emphasises sincere devotion above outward form, and amrit is a serious lifelong commitment that should be taken freely and when ready. So every Sikh should aim towards the Khalsa ideal, but sahaj-dhari Sikhs who are still on that path are still Sikhs.
Explanation
This statement tests the specification's focus on the different views of khalsa and sahaj-dhari Sikhs. A top answer explains both views with their sources (Guru Gobind Singh, the Rahit Maryada, the Guru Granth Sahib) and reaches a judgement, for example distinguishing an ideal from a demand. Treat both groups respectfully.