"Sikhs should not celebrate Divali because it is a Hindu festival."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Some Sikhs have sympathy with this statement. Sikhism is a distinct religion with its own beliefs, scripture and identity. The Hindu meanings of Divali, such as the return of Rama to Ayodhya and the worship of the goddess Lakshmi, are not Sikh beliefs, and the Rahit Maryada teaches that Sikhs should not follow the rituals of other faiths. Sikhism also rejects the worship of images. Some customs that have become linked with Divali, such as gambling, conflict with Sikh teaching. Some Sikhs, especially in Britain, worry that when Sikhs celebrate Divali alongside Hindus, the differences between the two religions become blurred, and that young Sikhs may grow up thinking Sikhism is a branch of Hinduism. Guru Nanak taught that rituals performed without true devotion are empty, so Sikhs should not join in a festival simply because others do.
However, most Sikhs would disagree, because they do not celebrate the Hindu Divali at all: they celebrate Bandi Chhor Divas, a Sikh festival with its own history. It remembers Guru Hargobind's release from Gwalior Fort, when he refused to leave unless 52 imprisoned princes were freed with him, and his arrival at Amritsar, where people lit lamps to welcome him. The illumination of the Golden Temple at Divali goes back to this event. Divali had become a Sikh occasion even earlier, when Guru Amar Das asked Sikhs to gather with the Guru at that time. In the 18th century the Sarbat Khalsa met at Amritsar at Divali, and Bhai Mani Singh, a granthi of the Harmandir Sahib, was martyred after trying to hold a Divali gathering. So Divali has deep Sikh roots of its own. The festival also carries important Sikh values: freedom, justice and care for others. The 52 princes Guru Hargobind helped were Hindus, which shows the Sikh duty to stand up for people of all faiths.
There is also a positive argument for sharing the day with others. The Guru Granth Sahib contains hymns by Hindu and Muslim saints, such as Kabir and Namdev, and teaches respect for people of all religions. Celebrating on the same day as Hindu neighbours, while keeping a distinct Sikh meaning, can build friendship and understanding between communities.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. It is based on the mistaken idea that Sikhs are simply celebrating a Hindu festival. In fact, Sikhs celebrate Bandi Chhor Divas, which has its own history going back to Guru Amar Das and Guru Hargobind, and its own Sikh message of freedom and justice. The concern behind the statement is still valuable: Sikhs should take care to celebrate the festival in a Sikh way, with kirtan, Ardas and remembrance of Guru Hargobind, rather than adopting Hindu rituals. As long as they do this, sharing the day with people of other faiths is a strength, not a weakness.
Explanation
Strong answers recognise that Sikhs celebrate Bandi Chhor Divas, a festival with its own Sikh history (Guru Amar Das, Guru Hargobind, Bhai Mani Singh), while taking seriously the concern for a distinct Sikh identity and the Rahit Maryada's teaching on other faiths' rituals. Answers that do not mention the Sikh meaning of the festival cannot reach the higher levels.