"Doing sewa is the most important part of a visit to the Golden Temple."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Many Sikhs would agree with this statement. Sewa, selfless service, is at the heart of Sikh life, because Sikhs believe that serving others is a way of serving God. It helps a person overcome haumai, the pride and self-centredness that separate people from God, and become gurmukh. The Gurus set the example: by tradition Guru Amar Das served Guru Angad devotedly for many years before becoming Guru himself, and the langar was begun by Guru Nanak. The Golden Temple depends on sewa. The Guru Ram Das Langar, which feeds tens of thousands of people every day, is run largely by volunteers, and pilgrims make rotis, wash dishes, clean the marble and look after shoes. These humble tasks put equality into practice, since rich and poor, powerful and ordinary, work side by side. Guru Nanak taught that pilgrimage on its own brings only a sesame seed's worth of merit (Japji Sahib 21, GGS 4), so a visit that changes a person through service is arguably worth more than one spent only on rituals. Sewa also benefits other people, which makes it a very practical expression of faith.
However, others would argue that sewa is not the most important part of a visit. The centre of the Golden Temple is the Guru Granth Sahib, the living Guru, installed in the Harmandir Sahib where the Adi Granth was first placed in 1604. For many pilgrims, the most important moment is having darshan of the Guru, bowing before it and hearing the hukamnama. Nam japna, meditating on God's Name, is the first of the three pillars of Sikhism and the root from which true sewa grows. The almost continuous kirtan at the Harmandir offers a unique chance to focus on God. Bathing in the sarovar fulfils the prayer in Ardas for the gift of seeing and bathing at Sri Amritsar, and Guru Arjan wrote that bathing in the pool of Ram Das washes away sins (GGS 625). Sewa can be done at any local gurdwara, but darshan at the Harmandir Sahib can only happen in Amritsar. Some would also warn that sewa done for show, or to feel good about oneself, loses its value.
A third view is that the question sets up a false choice. In Sikhism, worship and service belong together: sewa done with the remembrance of God is itself a form of worship, and worship should lead to service. A pilgrim who washes dishes in the langar while repeating 'Waheguru' is doing both at once.
In conclusion, I partly agree with the statement. Sewa is one of the most important parts of a visit, because it puts the Gurus' teaching into practice and helps overcome haumai, and the Golden Temple is one of the greatest examples of sewa in the world. However, I think the remembrance of God that lies behind all Sikh practice, expressed in darshan of the Guru Granth Sahib and kirtan, is even more fundamental. The best visit combines both, so that worship inspires service and service becomes worship.
Explanation
The best answers evaluate sewa against darshan of the Guru Granth Sahib, kirtan and bathing in the sarovar, using concepts such as haumai, gurmukh and nam japna and sources such as Japji Sahib and Ardas. Recognising that worship and sewa are linked in Sikhism often leads to a well-supported conclusion. One-sided answers stay at Level 2.