"In modern Britain, Sikhs should use only Singh or Kaur as their surname."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Some Sikhs would strongly agree with this statement. When Guru Gobind Singh founded the Khalsa in 1699, he gave the names Singh and Kaur to replace surnames that showed a person's caste, and he changed his own name from Gobind Rai to Gobind Singh. In Punjab, family names often indicate caste or clan, and although the Gurus taught that all human beings are equal, caste attitudes have not completely disappeared: they can still affect, for example, some families' choice of marriage partners. Using only Singh or Kaur would make it impossible to judge a person by caste and would carry out the Guru's intention. The name Kaur also gives women an independent identity. A Sikh woman who keeps Kaur as her surname does not take her husband's name on marriage, which expresses the Sikh belief in the equality of men and women, reflected in Guru Nanak's teaching that woman should not be called inferior (GGS 473). Using only Singh or Kaur is also a proud public statement of Sikh identity in a multicultural society, and many amritdhari Sikhs in Britain already do this, some using Khalsa as a surname instead.
On the other hand, many Sikhs in Britain think the statement goes too far. Guru Gobind Singh gave the names Singh and Kaur, but the main concern of the Gurus was caste discrimination, not names as such. A Sikh can reject caste completely while still using a family name. In Britain, official systems such as passports, schools, banks and medical records usually need a distinct family name, and because so many people share the names Singh and Kaur, this can cause confusion. For practical reasons, therefore, many British Sikhs use Singh or Kaur as a middle name followed by a family name. They argue that the spiritual meaning of the names is kept, since they still use the names given to them at the naming ceremony through the hukam. Family names can also express a connection with ancestors and relatives without any sense of superiority. Some Sikh women choose to share a family name with their husband and children because it makes family life simpler, and they see this as a personal decision. Finally, Sikhism teaches that faith and commitment cannot be forced, so many think choosing a name should be left to individuals and families.
There is also a middle view: that Sikhs should use Singh and Kaur prominently, as the Guru intended, but that it matters less whether these are legally recorded as surnames than whether Sikhs reject caste in their attitudes and actions, for example in choosing marriage partners and running gurdwaras.
In conclusion, I think the statement is right that Singh and Kaur were intended to replace caste names and that using them as surnames is a powerful way of living out Sikh equality. However, I do not think every Sikh in Britain must do so. The Guru's real target was caste discrimination, and a Sikh who uses a family name for practical reasons but rejects caste completely is arguably closer to the Guru's teaching than someone who uses only Singh or Kaur but still holds caste prejudices.
Explanation
Strong answers explain why Guru Gobind Singh gave the names (to end caste and give dignity to men and women) and weigh this against practical realities in Britain and the idea that the Guru's target was discrimination rather than names. A judgement that distinguishes between the name and the attitude behind it is effective. Answers based only on practical convenience, with no religious teaching, stay at Level 2.