Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/21

Kamikaze (Garland)

Practise 10 exam-style questions on Kamikaze (Garland) for Eduqas GCSE English Literature (Component 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 10 questions
  • 15–25 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
10 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

15 marks

Remind yourself of 'Kamikaze' by Beatrice Garland from the Eduqas GCSE Poetry Anthology.

In this poem Garland explores ideas about duty. Write about the ways in which Garland presents duty in this poem. Remember to refer to the contexts of the poem in your answer. [15]

Model answer

In 'Kamikaze' duty is imposed from outside and then enforced by the people closest to the pilot, who punish him harshly for failing in it.

The first stanza is full of the objects and language of military duty. The pilot sets out with "a samurai sword", "a shaven head" and a mind "full of powerful incantations". The samurai sword gives the mission a ceremonial weight, and "incantations" suggests chants repeated until they work like a spell. The sword fits the historical record: some kamikaze pilots carried swords on their final flights, and wartime propaganda presented them as men who went willingly to die for the emperor. Historians also record pressure and coercion, however, and "incantations" may hint that his sense of duty has been chanted into him rather than chosen. His fuel is for a "one-way" flight, a "journey into history": duty is dressed as glory, and the enjambment that separates "one-way" from "journey" leaves a pause in which the reader feels its finality.

Against this, the daughter imagines her father remembering a different kind of duty: waiting with his brothers for their father's fishing boat to come home safe, in a family that depends on one another and on the sea. Garland never says why the pilot came back, but by placing these memories between the take-off and the return she lets the reader sense that the claims of family and life may have outweighed the duty to die.

The sixth stanza turns on "And though he came back". The concession in "though" implies that he was never meant to, and now his community enforces the duty he did not fulfil. His wife will not speak to him and the neighbours behave as if "he no longer existed". A 1941 military code told Japanese soldiers never to live with the shame of capture, and the poem imagines how such an idea of honour could pass from the army into the home.

Form supports this. The first thirty lines are one sentence, carrying the pilot from duty into memory without a pause, while the second sentence, ten lines long, piles up the family's rejection clause by clause ("nor did she", "and the neighbours too") until it ends on "the father we loved". The final line, in which the daughter imagines him wondering about "the better way to die", questions duty itself: the death he was sent to seek and the living death he received are both presented as ways of dying.

Published in 2013 in Garland's first collection, The Invention of Fireworks, the poem looks back on missions in which nearly 4,000 Japanese airmen died, and asks the reader to question a duty that demanded such a price.

Explanation

A top-band answer explores both the duty the pilot is sent to perform and the duty his family and neighbours enforce when he returns, analysing the ritual language of the opening, the remembered shore, the turn in the sixth stanza and the final question, with accurate historical context linked to the poem. Common errors are inventing a reason for the pilot's return, stating that all kamikaze pilots were volunteers, and repeating the myth that the planes carried fuel for only a one-way flight.

Mark scheme
  1. 15 marks

    Levels of response (15 marks). AO1, AO2 and AO3 are equally weighted in this question. (Eduqas's bands 5 to 1 are Levels 5 to 1.) AO3 in every level: "... understanding of the relationships between texts and the contexts in which they were written, including, where relevant, those of period, location, social structures and literary contexts such as genre, and the contexts in which texts are engaged with by different audiences." [...] below stands for this shared wording.
    Level 5 (13-15 marks): AO1: Sustain focus on the task, including overview, convey ideas with consistent coherence and use an appropriate register; use a sensitive and evaluative approach to the task and analyse the text critically; show a perceptive understanding of the text, engaging fully, perhaps with some originality in their personal response; their responses include pertinent, direct references from across the text, including quotations. AO2: Analyse and appreciate writers' use of language, form and structure, make assured reference to meanings and effects exploring and evaluating the way meaning and ideas are conveyed through language structure and form; use precise subject terminology in an appropriate context. AO3: Show an assured understanding [...].
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): AO1: Sustain focus on the task, convey ideas with coherence and use an appropriate register; use a thoughtful approach to the task; show a secure understanding of key aspects of the text, with considerable engagement; support and justify their responses by well-chosen direct reference to the text, including quotations. (Level 4 continues at the start of the comments.)
    Level 3 (7-9 marks), Level 2 (4-6 marks), Level 1 (1-3 marks): Eduqas's descriptors for these levels are given word for word at the start of the comments.
    0 marks: Nothing worthy of credit.

    Level 4 (continued): AO2: Discuss and increasingly analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make thoughtful reference to the meanings and effects of stylistic features used by the writer; use apt subject terminology. AO3: Show a secure understanding [...].
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): AO1: Focus on the task, convey ideas with general coherence and use a mostly appropriate register; use a straightforward approach to the task; show an understanding of key aspects of the text, with engagement; support and justify their responses by appropriate direct reference to the text, including quotations. AO2: Comment on and begin to analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make some reference to meanings and effects; use relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show an understanding [...].
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): AO1: Have some focus on the task, convey ideas with some coherence and sometimes use an appropriate register; use a limited approach to the task; show some understanding of key aspects of the text, with some engagement; support and justify their responses by some direct reference to the text, including some quotations. AO2: Recognise and make simple comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make limited reference to meanings and effects; may use some relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show some understanding [...].
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): AO1: Have limited focus on the task, convey ideas with occasional coherence and may sometimes use an appropriate register; use a simple approach to the task; show a basic understanding of some key aspects of the text, with a little engagement; may support and justify their responses by some general reference to the text, perhaps including some quotations. AO2: May make generalised comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make basic reference to meanings and effects; may use some subject terminology but not always accurately. AO3: Show limited understanding [...].
    Indicative content. Responses may include: AO1: - An overview of duty as imposed by the nation and then enforced by family and community; - Discussion of the contrast between the duty to die and the family life remembered on the shore; - Exploration of the final question, which sets two kinds of death against each other. AO2: - Comments on the ritual objects and language of the first stanza ("a samurai sword", "incantations"); - Comments on the enjambment after "one-way" and the grandeur of a journey into history; - Exploration of the turn at "And though he came back" and the rejection that follows; - An appreciation of the thirty-line opening sentence against the ten-line sentence of rejection and the two-line close. AO3: - Kamikaze missions ran from October 1944 to August 1945; propaganda presented the pilots as willing to die for the emperor, though historians record pressure and coercion; - Some pilots carried swords on their final flights; a 1941 military code told soldiers never to live with the shame of capture; - Officially, a pilot who found no target was expected to return; the poem was published in 2013 in The Invention of Fireworks. This is not a checklist. Please reward valid alternatives.

Question 2

15 marks

Remind yourself of 'Kamikaze' by Beatrice Garland from the Eduqas GCSE Poetry Anthology.

In this poem Garland explores ideas about memory. Write about the ways in which Garland presents memory in this poem. Remember to refer to the contexts of the poem in your answer. [15]

Model answer

Memory in 'Kamikaze' is layered like the generations of a family. An unnamed narrator reports what the pilot's daughter thought as she told the story to her children; she in turn imagines what her father remembered as he flew towards death. Garland presents memory as something that may save a life, that is passed down and reshaped, and that can be deliberately suppressed.

The pilot's memories are imagined, not reported. The modal in "he must have looked" reminds us that the daughter can only guess. Yet her imagining is vivid: fishing boats "strung out like bunting" and shoals of fish turning "in a figure of eight". The memory then deepens into childhood, as he recalls building "cairns of pearl-grey pebbles" with his brothers and seeing his father's boat come home full of fish, "the loose silver of whitebait" among them. These images of colour, light and play suggest a memory powerful enough to draw a man back from death, although the poem never says that it did.

Garland's form imitates the flow of memory. The opening sentence runs for thirty lines across five stanzas without a full stop, and most lines begin in lower case, so one image slides into the next as memories do. The repetition of "safe" across the stanza break, and the daughter's aside "yes, grandfather's boat", set between dashes, make the poem sound like someone remembering aloud, correcting and confirming as she goes.

The last two stanzas turn to the daughter's own memories of what happened after his return. The family learned "to live as though" he had never come back. Here memory is deliberately suppressed: the punishment is to behave as if the return had not happened and to erase him from the present. The irony is sharp, because the pilot set out on a journey "into history", one of the organised suicide missions Japan flew from October 1944, as though he would be remembered as a hero; instead his family tries to forget him while he lives. Yet this painful memory is what she now passes on.

The poem never names Japan or the war; only its title and the "samurai sword" point to them. Published in 2013, nearly seventy years after the war, in Garland's first collection, The Invention of Fireworks, it is itself an act of remembering, carrying the story of that war to a much later generation.

The final lines return to the frame: "And sometimes, she said", her father must have wondered which way of dying had been better. "And sometimes" suggests a thought the daughter returns to, softening into sympathy. Garland ends by showing that memory is never fixed: the family story is still being retold, and reconsidered.

Explanation

A top-band answer explores the layers of memory in the poem, the narrator's, the daughter's and the pilot's imagined memories, analysing the speculative "must have", the long opening sentence and the family's attempt to erase him, with context linked to the poem's backward look at the war. Common errors are treating the daughter's imaginings as facts about why the pilot returned, overlooking the shifts between the narrator's voice and the daughter's, and using context that has nothing to do with memory.

Mark scheme
  1. 15 marks

    Levels of response (15 marks). AO1, AO2 and AO3 are equally weighted in this question. (Eduqas's bands 5 to 1 are Levels 5 to 1.) AO3 in every level: "... understanding of the relationships between texts and the contexts in which they were written, including, where relevant, those of period, location, social structures and literary contexts such as genre, and the contexts in which texts are engaged with by different audiences." [...] below stands for this shared wording.
    Level 5 (13-15 marks): AO1: Sustain focus on the task, including overview, convey ideas with consistent coherence and use an appropriate register; use a sensitive and evaluative approach to the task and analyse the text critically; show a perceptive understanding of the text, engaging fully, perhaps with some originality in their personal response; their responses include pertinent, direct references from across the text, including quotations. AO2: Analyse and appreciate writers' use of language, form and structure, make assured reference to meanings and effects exploring and evaluating the way meaning and ideas are conveyed through language structure and form; use precise subject terminology in an appropriate context. AO3: Show an assured understanding [...].
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): AO1: Sustain focus on the task, convey ideas with coherence and use an appropriate register; use a thoughtful approach to the task; show a secure understanding of key aspects of the text, with considerable engagement; support and justify their responses by well-chosen direct reference to the text, including quotations. (Level 4 continues at the start of the comments.)
    Level 3 (7-9 marks), Level 2 (4-6 marks), Level 1 (1-3 marks): Eduqas's descriptors for these levels are given word for word at the start of the comments.
    0 marks: Nothing worthy of credit.

    Level 4 (continued): AO2: Discuss and increasingly analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make thoughtful reference to the meanings and effects of stylistic features used by the writer; use apt subject terminology. AO3: Show a secure understanding [...].
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): AO1: Focus on the task, convey ideas with general coherence and use a mostly appropriate register; use a straightforward approach to the task; show an understanding of key aspects of the text, with engagement; support and justify their responses by appropriate direct reference to the text, including quotations. AO2: Comment on and begin to analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make some reference to meanings and effects; use relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show an understanding [...].
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): AO1: Have some focus on the task, convey ideas with some coherence and sometimes use an appropriate register; use a limited approach to the task; show some understanding of key aspects of the text, with some engagement; support and justify their responses by some direct reference to the text, including some quotations. AO2: Recognise and make simple comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make limited reference to meanings and effects; may use some relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show some understanding [...].
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): AO1: Have limited focus on the task, convey ideas with occasional coherence and may sometimes use an appropriate register; use a simple approach to the task; show a basic understanding of some key aspects of the text, with a little engagement; may support and justify their responses by some general reference to the text, perhaps including some quotations. AO2: May make generalised comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make basic reference to meanings and effects; may use some subject terminology but not always accurately. AO3: Show limited understanding [...].
    Indicative content. Responses may include: AO1: - An overview of layered memory: the narrator's, the daughter's, the pilot's imagined memories, and the story passed to the daughter's children; - Discussion of the pilot's imagined memories of sea and childhood, and their apparent power; - Exploration of memory suppressed: the family living as if he had not returned. AO2: - Comments on the speculative "must have" and the frame of the daughter "recounting it later"; - Comments on the thirty-line opening sentence, lower-case line openings and enjambment that imitate the flow of memory; - Exploration of the aside between dashes and the repeated "safe"; - An appreciation of the return to the frame at the end and the word "sometimes". AO3: - The kamikaze missions of 1944-45, recalled from 2013, nearly seventy years later; - Propaganda presented the pilots as willing to die for the emperor; the poem shows a family trying to forget one who returned; - Published in Garland's first collection, The Invention of Fireworks (2013). This is not a checklist. Please reward valid alternatives.

Question 3

25 marks

Remind yourself of 'Kamikaze' by Beatrice Garland from the Eduqas GCSE Poetry Anthology.

Choose one other poem from the anthology in which the poet also writes about death. Compare the way the poet presents death in your chosen poem with the way Beatrice Garland presents death in Kamikaze. [25]

In your answer you should:
- compare the content and structure of the poems - what they are about and how they are organised
- compare how the writers create effects, using appropriate terminology where relevant
- compare the contexts of the poems, and how these may have influenced the ideas in them.

The other poems in the anthology are: The Schoolboy by William Blake; I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud by William Wordsworth; Cousin Kate by Christina Rossetti; Sonnet 29 by Elizabeth Barrett Browning; Drummer Hodge by Thomas Hardy; Disabled by Wilfred Owen; I Shall Return by Claude McKay; Decomposition by Zulfikar Ghose; Catrin by Gillian Clarke; Blackberry Picking by Seamus Heaney; War Photographer by Carol Ann Duffy; Dusting the Phone by Jackie Kay; Remains by Simon Armitage; Origin Story by Eve L Ewing.

Model answer

Thomas Hardy's 'Drummer Hodge' and Beatrice Garland's 'Kamikaze' both present death in war, but in strikingly different ways. Hodge dies and is buried far from home, absorbed for ever into a foreign landscape; Garland's pilot was sent to die but came back, and his punishment is a kind of death in life.

Each poem frames death through a ritual, or the lack of one. Hardy begins after the death: "They throw in Drummer Hodge, to rest / Uncoffined -- just as found". The careless verb "throw" and the anonymous "They" show how little ceremony the young drummer receives. Garland's pilot sets off with ritual: a sword, "a shaven head" and a mind full of chanted words, with fuel for a "one-way" flight that is also a "journey into history". His death is meant to be glorious and remembered; Hodge's is ordinary and unmarked. Hardy's opening quietly protests at an anonymous death, while Garland's shows death dressed as honour.

Both poets surround death with the natural world. Hodge's grave is marked only by a "kopje-crest" on the "veldt", South African words for a small hill and open grassland that he would never have known. He came "Fresh from his Wessex home", Hardy's name for the rural south-west of England where Hardy himself was born, so the alien landscape measures how far the war has carried him. Above the grave "foreign constellations west / Each night above his mound". In death he will "for ever be" a "portion of that unknown plain", his "homely Northern breast and brain" growing into a Southern tree. Nature receives him, but it is alien. Garland's natural images, imagined by the daughter, belong to home: little fishing boats, "the dark shoals of fishes" flashing silver in the sun, and a childhood shore where the pilot and his brothers waited for their father's boat. Where Hardy's nature buries a man in a strange land, Garland's seems to call a man back towards life, and the great tuna that the boat once brought home, "muscular, dangerous", is full of the vitality the sea still holds.

The poems differ most in what death means. Hodge's death is final, but Hardy gives it a strange permanence: the "strange-eyed constellations reign / His stars eternally". Garland's pilot survives, yet his neighbours treat him as if "he no longer existed", and his children learn to live as though he had never come home. Social death replaces physical death. The final line makes the comparison explicit, as the daughter imagines her father asking himself which was "the better way to die": his life after returning is itself presented as a way of dying.

Form shapes these meanings. Hardy's three stanzas rhyme ababab and alternate lines of eight and six syllables, the metre of a ballad or hymn, which lends Hodge's burial a solemn dignity that his treatment lacked. Each stanza moves from Hodge to the landscape to the stars. Garland's seven unrhymed six-line stanzas begin with a sentence that runs for thirty lines, carrying the pilot from take-off into memory; a ten-line sentence then lists the family's rejection, and a two-line sentence ends the poem. Hardy's poem keeps an impersonal third-person voice throughout; Garland's shifts into the daughter's first person, so that the father's death in life becomes a family's lived experience.

Each poem grows out of a particular war. Hardy's was first printed, as 'The Dead Drummer', in November 1899, only about six weeks after the Boer War began, and is said to have been prompted by news that a drummer from his own area of Dorset had been killed. "Hodge" was a stock, often mocking, name for a farm labourer, so his death stands for that of countless ordinary soldiers. Garland's poem, published in 2013, looks back on attacks in which nearly 4,000 Japanese airmen died, and which were heaviest during the Battle of Okinawa (April-June 1945); against that record of organised deaths, the poem imagines a family and community who treat survival itself as a disgrace.

Both poets therefore question the value that war places on death. Hardy mourns a young life thrown away in a land the drummer never understood, yet finds a cold consolation in the stars. Garland goes further, suggesting that a society which honours dying can make living unbearable. 'Drummer Hodge' asks us to notice a death no one marked; 'Kamikaze' asks whether dying was ever the only way to be honoured.

Explanation

A top-band answer compares the two kinds of death throughout, Hodge's physical death and burial against the pilot's death in life, analysing imagery of nature, the endings and the contrasting forms, with the Boer War and kamikaze contexts linked to each poem's view of death. Common errors are giving Hodge an age or a cause of death the poem does not state, inventing a reason for the pilot's return, and claiming that all returning kamikaze pilots were shunned.

Mark scheme
  1. 25 marks

    Levels of response (25 marks). AO1, AO2 and AO3 are equally weighted in this question. (Eduqas's bands 5 to 1 are Levels 5 to 1.) AO3 in every level: "... understanding of the relationships between texts and the contexts in which they were written, including, where relevant, those of period, location, social structures and literary contexts such as genre, and the contexts in which texts are engaged with by different audiences." [...] below stands for this shared wording.
    Level 5 (21-25 marks): Comparison is critical, illuminating and sustained across AO1, AO2 and AO3. There will be a wide ranging discussion of the similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Sustain focus on the task, including overview, convey ideas with consistent coherence and use an appropriate register; use a sensitive and evaluative approach to the task and analyse the texts critically; show a perceptive understanding of the texts, engaging fully, perhaps with some originality in their personal response; their responses include pertinent, direct references from across the texts, including quotations. AO2: Analyse and appreciate writers' use of language, form and structure, make assured reference to meanings and effects exploring and evaluating the way meaning and ideas are conveyed through language structure and form; use precise subject terminology in an appropriate context. AO3: Show an assured understanding [...].
    Level 4 (16-20 marks): Comparison is focussed, coherent and sustained across AO1, AO2 and AO3. There will be a clear discussion of the similarities and/or differences between the poems. (Level 4 continues at the start of the comments.)
    Level 3 (11-15 marks), Level 2 (6-10 marks), Level 1 (1-5 marks): Eduqas's descriptors for these levels are given word for word at the start of the comments.
    0 marks: Nothing worthy of credit.

    Level 4 (continued): AO1: Sustain focus on the task, convey ideas with coherence and use an appropriate register; use a thoughtful approach to the task; show a secure understanding of key aspects of the texts, with considerable engagement; support and justify their responses by well-chosen direct reference to the texts, including quotations. AO2: Discuss and increasingly analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make thoughtful reference to the meanings and effects of stylistic features used by the writer; use apt subject terminology. AO3: Show a secure understanding [...].
    Level 3 (11-15 marks): Comparison is focussed across AO1, AO2 and AO3 with some valid discussion of the similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Focus on the task, convey ideas with general coherence and use a mostly appropriate register; use a straightforward approach to the task; show an understanding of key aspects of the texts, with engagement; support and justify their responses by appropriate direct reference to the texts, including quotations. AO2: Comment on and begin to analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make some reference to meanings and effects; use relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show an understanding [...].
    Level 2 (6-10 marks): Comparison is general with some discussion of the obvious similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Have some focus on the task, convey ideas with some coherence and sometimes use an appropriate register; use a limited approach to the task; show some understanding of key aspects of the texts, with some engagement; support and justify their responses by some direct reference to the texts, including some quotations. AO2: Recognise and make simple comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make limited reference to meanings and effects; may use some relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show some understanding [...].
    Level 1 (1-5 marks): Comparison is very limited. There may be a basic awareness of the obvious similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Have limited focus on the task, convey ideas with occasional coherence and may sometimes use an appropriate register; use a simple approach to the task; show a basic understanding of some key aspects of the texts, with a little engagement; may support and justify their responses by some general reference to the texts, perhaps including some quotations. AO2: May make generalised comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make basic reference to meanings and effects; may use some subject terminology but not always accurately. AO3: Show limited understanding [...].
    Indicative content. Second poem: credit any appropriate anthology poem about death. For example, if candidates choose Drummer Hodge, responses may include: AO1: - Hodge dies and is buried far from home; Garland's pilot survives his mission but suffers a death in life; - Both poems question the value placed on dying in war. AO2: - Hardy's careless "throw" and the anonymous "They" against the ritual of Garland's opening; - Nature as an alien grave ("foreign constellations") against nature as a memory of home; - Regular ababab stanzas in ballad metre against unrhymed six-line stanzas ending on "the better way to die". AO3: - Hardy: the Boer War; the poem first printed as 'The Dead Drummer' in November 1899; "Hodge" as a stock name for a country labourer; - Garland: published 2013; the kamikaze attacks of 1944-45, in which nearly 4,000 airmen died; propaganda and the 1941 code on the shame of capture. This is not a checklist. Please reward valid alternatives.

Question 4

25 marks

Remind yourself of 'Kamikaze' by Beatrice Garland from the Eduqas GCSE Poetry Anthology.

Choose one other poem from the anthology in which the poet also writes about people who are shunned. Compare the way the poet presents people who are shunned in your chosen poem with the way Beatrice Garland presents people who are shunned in Kamikaze. [25]

In your answer you should:
- compare the content and structure of the poems - what they are about and how they are organised
- compare how the writers create effects, using appropriate terminology where relevant
- compare the contexts of the poems, and how these may have influenced the ideas in them.

The other poems in the anthology are: The Schoolboy by William Blake; I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud by William Wordsworth; Cousin Kate by Christina Rossetti; Sonnet 29 by Elizabeth Barrett Browning; Drummer Hodge by Thomas Hardy; Disabled by Wilfred Owen; I Shall Return by Claude McKay; Decomposition by Zulfikar Ghose; Catrin by Gillian Clarke; Blackberry Picking by Seamus Heaney; War Photographer by Carol Ann Duffy; Dusting the Phone by Jackie Kay; Remains by Simon Armitage; Origin Story by Eve L Ewing.

Model answer

Zulfikar Ghose's 'Decomposition' and Beatrice Garland's 'Kamikaze' both present people pushed to the edge of their communities: a beggar asleep on a Bombay pavement whom a crowd ignores, and a pilot whose family and neighbours behave as if he does not exist. Both poems also make the reader consider who does the shunning, because each is shaped by someone who later looks back with a changed view.

The poets present shunning through the reactions of others. In 'Kamikaze' the rejection is active and personal: the pilot's wife "never spoke again" in his presence and would not look him in the eye, and the neighbours treat him as if "he no longer existed". Wartime propaganda presented kamikaze pilots as men who went willingly to die for the emperor, and the poem imagines how such an ideal could turn a community against one who came back. In 'Decomposition' it is passive and collective: the crowd behind the beggar is "passingly / bemused" by a street entertainer and "quite / indifferent" to "this very common sight". Garland's pilot is shunned because of what he has done, or failed to do; Ghose's beggar is ignored because poverty has become ordinary. Both are, in different ways, made invisible.

Both poets use images that reduce a person to something less than human. Ghose's beggar lies "veined into stone", "a fossil man", his limbs like "cracks in the stone" over which ants and flies travel. The metaphors suggest how completely he has been absorbed into the street and forgotten. The street is in Bombay, where Ghose lived for about ten years from 1942, though the poem never identifies its speaker. Garland's pilot is not described at all after his return; instead the poem erases him through his family, until his own daughter can say that he was no longer "the father we loved". In each poem the shunned man loses his presence: the beggar becomes stone, the pilot a ghost in his own home.

The changing responses of those who tell the stories are central to both poems. Ghose's speaker once took the photograph, thought it "a good composition" and "glibly" gave it a title, but now the beggar's head, bowed like someone weeping into a pillow, "chides me now". The speaker recognises their own share in the indifference. The pilot's daughter changes too. As a child she learned "to be silent" alongside the adults, but she tells the story "later" to her own children, and the closing words, "And sometimes, she said", introduce her imagining of her father's painful question: which way of dying had been better? Retelling the story becomes a way of giving back the voice the shunned man was denied.

Form and structure support these shifts. Ghose's poem is a single stanza of twenty unrhymed lines of roughly equal length, as still and framed as the photograph, but its tense moves from the present of the picture to the past ("I thought it then") and back to a reproachful present. Garland's seven six-line stanzas begin with one sentence that runs for thirty lines through the pilot's flight and memories, and the next, ten lines long, lists the family's rejection clause after clause before a two-line sentence closes the poem. The change from flowing memory to that relentless list marks the moment he becomes an outcast.

The poems' origins point to different causes of shunning. Ghose, born in 1935 in Sialkot, then in British India, moved to England with his family in 1952, and his poem, published in 1967, looks back at a photograph taken in Bombay (now Mumbai). The speaker's title for the photograph, "The Man in the Street", is an idiom for an ordinary person, but here it is literally true, which exposes how easily poverty can be accepted as normal. 'Kamikaze', published in Garland's first collection in 2013, never names Japan or the war; its title alone points to the pilots of 1944-45, and the family's rejection is imagined, not a recorded event.

Both poems ask the reader to see someone who has been made invisible, but they place the blame differently. In 'Decomposition' the shunning is a whole society's indifference, which the speaker comes to share and regret; in 'Kamikaze' it is a community's harsh code of honour, enforced by the people closest to the pilot. Garland's is the more painful, because the rejection comes from those who loved him, but Ghose's is the more uncomfortable, because it implicates the observer, and perhaps the reader too.

Explanation

A top-band answer compares the two kinds of shunning in every paragraph, active rejection by a family against the indifference of a crowd, analysing imagery, the speakers' changed views and the contrasting forms, with context for both poems linked to the causes of shunning. Common errors are treating the poems separately, saying that Ghose's beggar is dead, and stating that all returning kamikaze pilots were rejected by their families.

Mark scheme
  1. 25 marks

    Levels of response (25 marks). AO1, AO2 and AO3 are equally weighted in this question. (Eduqas's bands 5 to 1 are Levels 5 to 1.) AO3 in every level: "... understanding of the relationships between texts and the contexts in which they were written, including, where relevant, those of period, location, social structures and literary contexts such as genre, and the contexts in which texts are engaged with by different audiences." [...] below stands for this shared wording.
    Level 5 (21-25 marks): Comparison is critical, illuminating and sustained across AO1, AO2 and AO3. There will be a wide ranging discussion of the similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Sustain focus on the task, including overview, convey ideas with consistent coherence and use an appropriate register; use a sensitive and evaluative approach to the task and analyse the texts critically; show a perceptive understanding of the texts, engaging fully, perhaps with some originality in their personal response; their responses include pertinent, direct references from across the texts, including quotations. AO2: Analyse and appreciate writers' use of language, form and structure, make assured reference to meanings and effects exploring and evaluating the way meaning and ideas are conveyed through language structure and form; use precise subject terminology in an appropriate context. AO3: Show an assured understanding [...].
    Level 4 (16-20 marks): Comparison is focussed, coherent and sustained across AO1, AO2 and AO3. There will be a clear discussion of the similarities and/or differences between the poems. (Level 4 continues at the start of the comments.)
    Level 3 (11-15 marks), Level 2 (6-10 marks), Level 1 (1-5 marks): Eduqas's descriptors for these levels are given word for word at the start of the comments.
    0 marks: Nothing worthy of credit.

    Level 4 (continued): AO1: Sustain focus on the task, convey ideas with coherence and use an appropriate register; use a thoughtful approach to the task; show a secure understanding of key aspects of the texts, with considerable engagement; support and justify their responses by well-chosen direct reference to the texts, including quotations. AO2: Discuss and increasingly analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make thoughtful reference to the meanings and effects of stylistic features used by the writer; use apt subject terminology. AO3: Show a secure understanding [...].
    Level 3 (11-15 marks): Comparison is focussed across AO1, AO2 and AO3 with some valid discussion of the similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Focus on the task, convey ideas with general coherence and use a mostly appropriate register; use a straightforward approach to the task; show an understanding of key aspects of the texts, with engagement; support and justify their responses by appropriate direct reference to the texts, including quotations. AO2: Comment on and begin to analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make some reference to meanings and effects; use relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show an understanding [...].
    Level 2 (6-10 marks): Comparison is general with some discussion of the obvious similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Have some focus on the task, convey ideas with some coherence and sometimes use an appropriate register; use a limited approach to the task; show some understanding of key aspects of the texts, with some engagement; support and justify their responses by some direct reference to the texts, including some quotations. AO2: Recognise and make simple comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make limited reference to meanings and effects; may use some relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show some understanding [...].
    Level 1 (1-5 marks): Comparison is very limited. There may be a basic awareness of the obvious similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Have limited focus on the task, convey ideas with occasional coherence and may sometimes use an appropriate register; use a simple approach to the task; show a basic understanding of some key aspects of the texts, with a little engagement; may support and justify their responses by some general reference to the texts, perhaps including some quotations. AO2: May make generalised comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make basic reference to meanings and effects; may use some subject terminology but not always accurately. AO3: Show limited understanding [...].
    Indicative content. Second poem: credit any appropriate anthology poem about people who are shunned. For example, if candidates choose Decomposition, responses may include: AO1: - Garland's pilot is actively rejected by family and neighbours; Ghose's beggar is passively ignored by a crowd; - Both poems are shaped by someone who looks back with a changed view: the daughter retells her father's story; Ghose's speaker feels rebuked. AO2: - Ghose's metaphors of stone and fossil against Garland's erasure of the pilot ("the father we loved"); - Silence and indifference: "never spoke again" against "quite / indifferent"; - One framed twenty-line stanza against seven six-line stanzas whose thirty-line first sentence gives way to a ten-line sentence listing the family's rejection. AO3: - Ghose: born 1935 in Sialkot, grew up in Bombay, moved to England in 1952; poem published 1967; the idiom "The Man in the Street"; - Garland: published 2013; kamikaze pilots 1944-45; propaganda and the 1941 code on the shame of capture. This is not a checklist. Please reward valid alternatives.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.