Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/21

Catrin (Clarke)

Practise 10 exam-style questions on Catrin (Clarke) for Eduqas GCSE English Literature (Component 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 10 questions
  • 15–25 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
10 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

15 marks

Remind yourself of 'Catrin' by Gillian Clarke from the Eduqas GCSE Poetry Anthology.

In this poem Clarke explores ideas about love. Write about the ways in which Clarke presents love in this poem. Remember to refer to the contexts of the poem in your answer. [15]

Model answer

Clarke presents love between mother and child as fierce and physical, a bond that holds even when it hurts. The poem avoids any sentimental picture of motherhood; instead its central symbol of love is a rope, something that binds, pulls and can be fought over.

The poem opens with intimacy. Its title is the name of Clarke's daughter, so the poem is itself an act of love, and the speaker addresses the "child" directly, and the second person runs through the whole poem, so that it reads like a private conversation. Yet love first appears in the middle of a struggle: the "Red rope of love". The colour red suggests blood, passion and life, and the rope, which Clarke has identified as the umbilical cord that joined her to Catrin until Catrin was born, makes love a physical tie between two bodies. That mother and baby both fought over it shows love and conflict beginning together.

The speaker's account of the birth presents love as creative. In the bare room the mother wrote on the walls and coloured the squares "With the wild, tender circles" of their struggle. The pairing of "wild" and "tender", close to an oxymoron, captures love's contradictions: it is gentle and savage at once. The circles, set against the "clean squares", suggest something whole and unending breaking into a sterile space, as love breaks into the clinical room.

In the second stanza love has grown more complicated. The daughter's defiance brings up, "From the heart's pool", "that old rope". The pool makes love a deep reservoir of feeling, and "old" suggests a bond that has lasted for years, worn but unbroken. The rope is now "Tightening about my life", an image that suggests both closeness and constriction: love can feel like a noose as well as a lifeline.

The ending places love in a small, everyday moment. The child asks to skate for one more hour, and the mother's love is felt in the tension of the request, which is reported without an answer: to protect is to refuse, but to love is also to let go. Clarke leaves the decision unspoken, as if love had no simple response.

Clarke's own comments add depth. In notes published on her website she says the poem is about her baby becoming a teenager, and explains that "that old rope" is the invisible umbilical cord that ties parents to children as they grow up, which makes love the bond that outlasts birth. The poem is honest that a mother's love can include anger, which may be why it still feels true to many readers.

Explanation

A top-band answer explores love as fierce and mixed with conflict, analysing the "Red rope of love", the oxymoron "wild, tender", the pool of the heart and the tightening rope, and links Clarke's comments on the rope to the poem's meaning. Common errors are describing love only as tenderness, ignoring the second stanza, and quoting long passages instead of short, analysed phrases.

Mark scheme
  1. 15 marks

    Levels of response (15 marks). AO1, AO2 and AO3 are equally weighted in this question. (Eduqas's bands 5 to 1 are Levels 5 to 1.) AO3 in every level: "... understanding of the relationships between texts and the contexts in which they were written, including, where relevant, those of period, location, social structures and literary contexts such as genre, and the contexts in which texts are engaged with by different audiences." [...] below stands for this shared wording.
    Level 5 (13-15 marks): AO1: Sustain focus on the task, including overview, convey ideas with consistent coherence and use an appropriate register; use a sensitive and evaluative approach to the task and analyse the text critically; show a perceptive understanding of the text, engaging fully, perhaps with some originality in their personal response; their responses include pertinent, direct references from across the text, including quotations. AO2: Analyse and appreciate writers' use of language, form and structure, make assured reference to meanings and effects exploring and evaluating the way meaning and ideas are conveyed through language structure and form; use precise subject terminology in an appropriate context. AO3: Show an assured understanding [...].
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): AO1: Sustain focus on the task, convey ideas with coherence and use an appropriate register; use a thoughtful approach to the task; show a secure understanding of key aspects of the text, with considerable engagement; support and justify their responses by well-chosen direct reference to the text, including quotations. (Level 4 continues at the start of the comments.)
    Level 3 (7-9 marks), Level 2 (4-6 marks), Level 1 (1-3 marks): Eduqas's descriptors for these levels are given word for word at the start of the comments.
    0 marks: Nothing worthy of credit.

    Level 4 (continued): AO2: Discuss and increasingly analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make thoughtful reference to the meanings and effects of stylistic features used by the writer; use apt subject terminology. AO3: Show a secure understanding [...].
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): AO1: Focus on the task, convey ideas with general coherence and use a mostly appropriate register; use a straightforward approach to the task; show an understanding of key aspects of the text, with engagement; support and justify their responses by appropriate direct reference to the text, including quotations. AO2: Comment on and begin to analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make some reference to meanings and effects; use relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show an understanding [...].
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): AO1: Have some focus on the task, convey ideas with some coherence and sometimes use an appropriate register; use a limited approach to the task; show some understanding of key aspects of the text, with some engagement; support and justify their responses by some direct reference to the text, including some quotations. AO2: Recognise and make simple comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make limited reference to meanings and effects; may use some relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show some understanding [...].
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): AO1: Have limited focus on the task, convey ideas with occasional coherence and may sometimes use an appropriate register; use a simple approach to the task; show a basic understanding of some key aspects of the text, with a little engagement; may support and justify their responses by some general reference to the text, perhaps including some quotations. AO2: May make generalised comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make basic reference to meanings and effects; may use some subject terminology but not always accurately. AO3: Show limited understanding [...].
    Indicative content. Responses may include: AO1: - An understanding of love between mother and child as fierce, physical and lasting, a bond that holds even when it hurts; - Love as a bond that connects and constricts: the rope at birth and "that old rope" in the present; - Love tested in an everyday moment: the child's request to stay out. AO2: - The symbol of the "Red rope of love" and its colour; - The oxymoron (or juxtaposition) of "wild, tender"; circles set against squares; - Metaphors of depth and tightening in the second stanza; direct address to the child. AO3: - Catrin is Clarke's daughter; the poem was published in 1978 in The Sundial; - Clarke has said the rope is the umbilical cord and "that old rope" the invisible cord between parents and growing children. This is not a checklist. Please reward valid alternatives.

Question 2

15 marks

Remind yourself of 'Catrin' by Gillian Clarke from the Eduqas GCSE Poetry Anthology.

In this poem Clarke explores ideas about birth. Write about the ways in which Clarke presents birth in this poem. Remember to refer to the contexts of the poem in your answer. [15]

Model answer

Clarke presents birth not as a gentle, joyful event but as an intense, physical struggle: the first meeting of two people who will spend years loving and fighting each other. The first stanza is a memory of labour and birth; the second shows that what began then has not ended.

The setting is presented in stark, clinical terms. The mother stood in "a hot, white / Room", and the adjectives suggest discomfort and sterility, while the enjambment leaves "white" hanging before the bare noun arrives. The room is an "Environmental blank", "disinfected / Of paintings or toys", as if everything personal or playful had been removed. The poem never uses the word hospital, but Clarke has said that "the glass tank" of the second stanza is the hospital where Catrin was born, and the clinical vocabulary fits. Outside the window, ordinary traffic carries on, which makes the room feel cut off: a place where something extraordinary is happening while the world goes about its business.

Into this blank space the birth brings colour and feeling. The mother says she "wrote" on the walls with her words and "coloured the clean squares" with the "circles" of their struggle. The writing and colouring may suggest her cries filling the silent room, or the poem itself being created out of the experience. Round shapes breaking into a square, sterile room suggest new life refusing to be contained.

Birth is also a battle. The "Fierce confrontation" is over the "Red rope" that joins mother and child, which Clarke has identified as the umbilical cord: birth is a fight over the very thing that connects them. The struggle ends in separation, the outcome both mother and baby seem to want.

The second stanza looks back on the birth as having happened in "the glass tank", an image that suggests being watched, or enclosed like a specimen. Yet the tank was "clouded with feelings": the emotion of the birth fogged the clinical glass. The birth is not simply over, because its struggle continues in the present quarrel with the daughter, and the cord of the birth returns as an "old" rope still binding them.

Clarke's own comments add to the drama. She has said that when Catrin was born babies in the womb were not scanned, so the birth was also the mother's first sight of her child, which may explain why it is remembered so vividly. By naming the poem after her daughter, Clarke makes the birth the beginning of an individual identity. The free verse, with its short, enjambed lines each opening with a capital, gives the birth an urgent, broken rhythm, like breathing under strain.

Explanation

A top-band answer explores the birth as a struggle in a clinical setting, analysing the bare room, the colouring of the "clean squares", the "Red rope" and "the glass tank", and uses Clarke's comments on the rope, the hospital and scanning accurately. Common errors are naming a hospital or place the poem does not give, misquoting the "circles" as cries, and ignoring the second stanza's link back to the birth.

Mark scheme
  1. 15 marks

    Levels of response (15 marks). AO1, AO2 and AO3 are equally weighted in this question. (Eduqas's bands 5 to 1 are Levels 5 to 1.) AO3 in every level: "... understanding of the relationships between texts and the contexts in which they were written, including, where relevant, those of period, location, social structures and literary contexts such as genre, and the contexts in which texts are engaged with by different audiences." [...] below stands for this shared wording.
    Level 5 (13-15 marks): AO1: Sustain focus on the task, including overview, convey ideas with consistent coherence and use an appropriate register; use a sensitive and evaluative approach to the task and analyse the text critically; show a perceptive understanding of the text, engaging fully, perhaps with some originality in their personal response; their responses include pertinent, direct references from across the text, including quotations. AO2: Analyse and appreciate writers' use of language, form and structure, make assured reference to meanings and effects exploring and evaluating the way meaning and ideas are conveyed through language structure and form; use precise subject terminology in an appropriate context. AO3: Show an assured understanding [...].
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): AO1: Sustain focus on the task, convey ideas with coherence and use an appropriate register; use a thoughtful approach to the task; show a secure understanding of key aspects of the text, with considerable engagement; support and justify their responses by well-chosen direct reference to the text, including quotations. (Level 4 continues at the start of the comments.)
    Level 3 (7-9 marks), Level 2 (4-6 marks), Level 1 (1-3 marks): Eduqas's descriptors for these levels are given word for word at the start of the comments.
    0 marks: Nothing worthy of credit.

    Level 4 (continued): AO2: Discuss and increasingly analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make thoughtful reference to the meanings and effects of stylistic features used by the writer; use apt subject terminology. AO3: Show a secure understanding [...].
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): AO1: Focus on the task, convey ideas with general coherence and use a mostly appropriate register; use a straightforward approach to the task; show an understanding of key aspects of the text, with engagement; support and justify their responses by appropriate direct reference to the text, including quotations. AO2: Comment on and begin to analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make some reference to meanings and effects; use relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show an understanding [...].
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): AO1: Have some focus on the task, convey ideas with some coherence and sometimes use an appropriate register; use a limited approach to the task; show some understanding of key aspects of the text, with some engagement; support and justify their responses by some direct reference to the text, including some quotations. AO2: Recognise and make simple comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make limited reference to meanings and effects; may use some relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show some understanding [...].
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): AO1: Have limited focus on the task, convey ideas with occasional coherence and may sometimes use an appropriate register; use a simple approach to the task; show a basic understanding of some key aspects of the text, with a little engagement; may support and justify their responses by some general reference to the text, perhaps including some quotations. AO2: May make generalised comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make basic reference to meanings and effects; may use some subject terminology but not always accurately. AO3: Show limited understanding [...].
    Indicative content. Responses may include: AO1: - An understanding of birth as an intense, physical struggle and the first meeting of two people; - The clinical setting transformed by colour and feeling; - Birth as the start of a bond and a conflict that continue into the present. AO2: - Clinical vocabulary: "Environmental blank", "disinfected"; the room described without the word hospital; - The mother's writing and colouring on the walls; circles against squares; - The metaphor of "the glass tank" and battle language around the "Red rope". AO3: - Clarke has said the rope is the umbilical cord and "the glass tank" the hospital; - Clarke has said babies were not scanned when Catrin was born; the poem was published in 1978. This is not a checklist. Please reward valid alternatives.

Question 3

25 marks

Remind yourself of 'Catrin' by Gillian Clarke from the Eduqas GCSE Poetry Anthology.

Choose one other poem from the anthology in which the poet also writes about identity. Compare the way the poet presents identity in your chosen poem with the way Gillian Clarke presents identity in Catrin. [25]

In your answer you should:
- compare the content and structure of the poems - what they are about and how they are organised
- compare how the writers create effects, using appropriate terminology where relevant
- compare the contexts of the poems, and how these may have influenced the ideas in them.

The other poems in the anthology are: The Schoolboy by William Blake; I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud by William Wordsworth; Cousin Kate by Christina Rossetti; Sonnet 29 by Elizabeth Barrett Browning; Drummer Hodge by Thomas Hardy; Disabled by Wilfred Owen; I Shall Return by Claude McKay; Decomposition by Zulfikar Ghose; Blackberry Picking by Seamus Heaney; Kamikaze by Beatrice Garland; War Photographer by Carol Ann Duffy; Dusting the Phone by Jackie Kay; Remains by Simon Armitage; Origin Story by Eve L Ewing.

Model answer

Gillian Clarke's 'Catrin' and Thomas Hardy's 'Drummer Hodge' both explore identity, but in opposite directions. In 'Catrin' a child's identity is fought for and won: from birth, mother and daughter struggle "to be ourselves". In 'Drummer Hodge' a young soldier's identity is lost: buried in a foreign land, Hodge dissolves into a landscape he never understood.

The titles tell us much. Clarke's title is her daughter's name, Catrin, a Welsh girl's name, which gives the child an individual identity before the poem begins, even though the name never appears in the poem itself. Hardy's title gives a role and a name, but "Hodge" was a traditional, often mocking, name for an English farm labourer, a stereotype Hardy had criticised in his 1883 essay 'The Dorsetshire Labourer'. Hodge is presented almost as a type, an everyman, while Catrin is a particular person.

Both poems link identity to separation. In 'Catrin' separation is the purpose of the struggle at birth: mother and baby shouted their wish "To be two", and then "to be ourselves". The plural "ourselves" is striking: out of one shared "we" come two selves, so identity is born from division. In 'Drummer Hodge' separation is a loss. Hodge is "Fresh from his Wessex home", among "foreign constellations" and "Strange stars", and the poem stresses that "Young Hodge the drummer never knew" the meaning of the land he died in. His identity belonged to England; in South Africa it means nothing.

The poems end with very different ideas of what identity becomes. Clarke's daughter emerges strongly defined: she stands before her mother with a "Defiant glare", asking for more freedom, a person in her own right. Hardy's Hodge is absorbed into the land: "Yet portion of that unknown plain / Will Hodge for ever be". His "homely Northern breast and brain" will "Grow up some Southern tree", so the very things that made him English become part of the African landscape. The final image, "strange-eyed constellations reign / His stars eternally", suggests that even the stars that rule over him are foreign.

Both poets use opposition to define identity. Clarke sets mother against daughter, "I" against "you", and the conflict shapes each of them. Hardy sets "Northern" against "Southern", Wessex against "the broad Karoo", home against "unknown". Clarke's opposites are two people learning to be separate; Hardy's are two worlds, one of which swallows the other.

Form supports this. 'Drummer Hodge' has three six-line stanzas rhyming ababab, in lines that alternate between eight and six syllables, the regular rhythm of ballad or hymn metre. Each stanza moves from Hodge to the landscape to the stars, so that he is always surrounded and outweighed by the foreign world. 'Catrin' is free verse, with no rhyme scheme and constant enjambment, its irregular shape suiting a relationship and an identity that are still being worked out.

The poems' origins deepen the contrast. 'Drummer Hodge' was first published, as 'The Dead Drummer', on 25 November 1899, about six weeks after the Boer War began. Drummers were usually among the youngest soldiers, which fits the poem's "Young Hodge", and Hardy filled the poem with South African words, "kopje", "veldt" and "Karoo", that Hodge would never have known. 'Catrin' was published in 1978 in The Sundial, and Clarke has said that it is about her daughter growing up, her baby becoming a teenager. Hardy writes about a young man whose identity is taken by war and empire; Clarke writes about a young person whose identity is claimed within a family.

The poems can be read as mirror images. Catrin wins her identity by struggling against the person closest to her; Hodge loses his, quietly, among strangers. Clarke's poem ends with a child asking for more life; Hardy's with a young man who has become part of the earth.

Explanation

A top-band answer compares how identity is won through separation in 'Catrin' and lost through distance in 'Drummer Hodge', analysing the titles, the shout "to be ourselves" and Hardy's North-South contrasts, with accurate context for both (the Boer War in 1899 and the 'Hodge' stereotype; Clarke's daughter). Common errors are giving Hodge or Catrin an exact age, quoting other printings of Hardy's line about the tree instead of the anthology's "Grow up some Southern tree", and treating the poems separately.

Mark scheme
  1. 25 marks

    Levels of response (25 marks). AO1, AO2 and AO3 are equally weighted in this question. (Eduqas's bands 5 to 1 are Levels 5 to 1.) AO3 in every level: "... understanding of the relationships between texts and the contexts in which they were written, including, where relevant, those of period, location, social structures and literary contexts such as genre, and the contexts in which texts are engaged with by different audiences." [...] below stands for this shared wording.
    Level 5 (21-25 marks): Comparison is critical, illuminating and sustained across AO1, AO2 and AO3. There will be a wide ranging discussion of the similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Sustain focus on the task, including overview, convey ideas with consistent coherence and use an appropriate register; use a sensitive and evaluative approach to the task and analyse the texts critically; show a perceptive understanding of the texts, engaging fully, perhaps with some originality in their personal response; their responses include pertinent, direct references from across the texts, including quotations. AO2: Analyse and appreciate writers' use of language, form and structure, make assured reference to meanings and effects exploring and evaluating the way meaning and ideas are conveyed through language structure and form; use precise subject terminology in an appropriate context. AO3: Show an assured understanding [...].
    Level 4 (16-20 marks): Comparison is focussed, coherent and sustained across AO1, AO2 and AO3. There will be a clear discussion of the similarities and/or differences between the poems. (Level 4 continues at the start of the comments.)
    Level 3 (11-15 marks), Level 2 (6-10 marks), Level 1 (1-5 marks): Eduqas's descriptors for these levels are given word for word at the start of the comments.
    0 marks: Nothing worthy of credit.

    Level 4 (continued): AO1: Sustain focus on the task, convey ideas with coherence and use an appropriate register; use a thoughtful approach to the task; show a secure understanding of key aspects of the texts, with considerable engagement; support and justify their responses by well-chosen direct reference to the texts, including quotations. AO2: Discuss and increasingly analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make thoughtful reference to the meanings and effects of stylistic features used by the writer; use apt subject terminology. AO3: Show a secure understanding [...].
    Level 3 (11-15 marks): Comparison is focussed across AO1, AO2 and AO3 with some valid discussion of the similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Focus on the task, convey ideas with general coherence and use a mostly appropriate register; use a straightforward approach to the task; show an understanding of key aspects of the texts, with engagement; support and justify their responses by appropriate direct reference to the texts, including quotations. AO2: Comment on and begin to analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make some reference to meanings and effects; use relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show an understanding [...].
    Level 2 (6-10 marks): Comparison is general with some discussion of the obvious similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Have some focus on the task, convey ideas with some coherence and sometimes use an appropriate register; use a limited approach to the task; show some understanding of key aspects of the texts, with some engagement; support and justify their responses by some direct reference to the texts, including some quotations. AO2: Recognise and make simple comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make limited reference to meanings and effects; may use some relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show some understanding [...].
    Level 1 (1-5 marks): Comparison is very limited. There may be a basic awareness of the obvious similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Have limited focus on the task, convey ideas with occasional coherence and may sometimes use an appropriate register; use a simple approach to the task; show a basic understanding of some key aspects of the texts, with a little engagement; may support and justify their responses by some general reference to the texts, perhaps including some quotations. AO2: May make generalised comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make basic reference to meanings and effects; may use some subject terminology but not always accurately. AO3: Show limited understanding [...].
    Indicative content. Second poem: credit any appropriate anthology poem about identity. For example, if candidates choose Drummer Hodge, responses may include: AO1: - Identity fought for and won in Catrin; identity lost in a foreign land in Drummer Hodge; - The titles: a daughter's own name against a stock name for a country labourer; - Separation as independence in one poem and as loss in the other. AO2: - The shout "to be ourselves" against Hardy's contrasts of "Northern" and "Southern", home and "unknown"; - Free verse against regular ababab stanzas in ballad or hymn metre. AO3: - Drummer Hodge: first published as 'The Dead Drummer' in November 1899, six weeks into the Boer War; 'Hodge' as a stereotype; - Catrin: published in 1978; Clarke's poem about her daughter growing up. This is not a checklist. Please reward valid alternatives.

Question 4

25 marks

Remind yourself of 'Catrin' by Gillian Clarke from the Eduqas GCSE Poetry Anthology.

Choose one other poem from the anthology in which the poet also writes about memories that return. Compare the way the poet presents memories that return in your chosen poem with the way Gillian Clarke presents memories that return in Catrin. [25]

In your answer you should:
- compare the content and structure of the poems - what they are about and how they are organised
- compare how the writers create effects, using appropriate terminology where relevant
- compare the contexts of the poems, and how these may have influenced the ideas in them.

The other poems in the anthology are: The Schoolboy by William Blake; I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud by William Wordsworth; Cousin Kate by Christina Rossetti; Sonnet 29 by Elizabeth Barrett Browning; Drummer Hodge by Thomas Hardy; Disabled by Wilfred Owen; I Shall Return by Claude McKay; Decomposition by Zulfikar Ghose; Blackberry Picking by Seamus Heaney; Kamikaze by Beatrice Garland; War Photographer by Carol Ann Duffy; Dusting the Phone by Jackie Kay; Remains by Simon Armitage; Origin Story by Eve L Ewing.

Model answer

Gillian Clarke's 'Catrin' and Carol Ann Duffy's 'War Photographer' both show memories that return, triggered by something in the present. In 'Catrin' a mother's quarrel with her daughter brings back the memory of the birth; in 'War Photographer' a photographer developing his pictures at home sees the faces of war rise up again. But the memories are very different: one is of a fierce, loving beginning, the other of suffering the photographer could not prevent.

Both poems turn on an act of remembering. Clarke's speaker states it directly, "I can remember you", and repeats the words at the start of the second sentence, as if the memory had to be summoned twice. Duffy's poem begins in the present, in the darkroom, but memory soon breaks in: "He remembers the cries" of a stranger's wife. In both, remembering is presented as something that happens almost of its own accord.

Each poem shows memory rising from below the surface. In Duffy's darkroom the image literally develops before the photographer's eyes: a stranger's features "faintly start to twist" until "a half-formed ghost" appears. The developing photograph becomes a metaphor for memory returning, slow, blurred and haunting. In 'Catrin' the daughter's defiant stare is "bringing up" the old rope from "the heart's pool". The pool suggests depths of feeling, and the rope pulled up out of it suggests a memory hauled into the present.

The returning memories bring back the original emotion. Duffy's photographer's hands "did not tremble then" but seem to now: the feeling he suppressed while working arrives later, at home. Clarke's mother finds the struggle of the birth repeated in the present, "Still" fighting her daughter off, so the memory is relived rather than merely recalled. The birth room was "clouded with feelings", and those feelings cloud the present quarrel too.

The settings of the memories contrast. Clarke's is "a hot, white / Room", sterile and enclosed, filled by the drama of a birth: it is a beginning. The memories in Duffy's poem are of places of death, "Belfast. Beirut. Phnom Penh.", cities that had all seen armed conflict in the years before the poem appeared in 1985, of places where, unlike England's fields, the ground can explode beneath children's feet, and of blood soaking "into foreign dust". Clarke's returning memory is painful but life-giving; Duffy's is a trauma.

The poems differ in what memory leads to. For Clarke's speaker the memory explains the present: the rope of the birth has become "that old rope", still binding mother and daughter, and the poem ends on a present request, the child asking to skate for one more hour. For Duffy's photographer memory isolates: the public's tears are brief, and "they do not care". He cannot share what he remembers, and in the final stanza he stares "impassively" from an aeroplane, as if he has had to switch off feeling.

Form reflects the two kinds of memory. Duffy's regular stanzas, each closing on a rhyming couplet, frame the returning memories, although her enjambment keeps letting them spill from one line into the next. Clarke's free verse, with its sudden enjambments and its move into the present tense in the middle of a line early in the second stanza, lets memory and present run together.

The poems' backgrounds sharpen the comparison. 'War Photographer' appeared in Duffy's first full collection, Standing Female Nude, and its cities point to the Troubles in Northern Ireland, the Lebanese civil war and the Khmer Rouge regime in Cambodia, so the photographer's memories carry the weight of real conflicts. 'Catrin' was published in 1978 in The Sundial; Clarke has said it is about her own daughter, her baby becoming a teenager, and that "that old rope" is the invisible cord that ties parents and children as they grow up. That helps to explain why the memory of the birth returns at the moment the grown child defies her mother.

Both poems show that the past is never simply over. Clarke's speaker finds in the memory of birth the source of a love and a conflict that continue; Duffy's photographer finds in his memories a burden no one at home will share. Duffy's is the darker vision, but Clarke's is no less honest about how memory shapes the present.

Explanation

A top-band answer compares how memory is triggered and how it returns in each poem, analysing "the heart's pool" and "a half-formed ghost", the delayed or relived emotion and the two forms, and links both to accurate context (the conflicts named by Duffy; Clarke's comments on her daughter and the rope). Common errors are writing about war in general rather than returning memories, naming a real photographer as Duffy's subject, and quoting long stretches of these in-copyright poems.

Mark scheme
  1. 25 marks

    Levels of response (25 marks). AO1, AO2 and AO3 are equally weighted in this question. (Eduqas's bands 5 to 1 are Levels 5 to 1.) AO3 in every level: "... understanding of the relationships between texts and the contexts in which they were written, including, where relevant, those of period, location, social structures and literary contexts such as genre, and the contexts in which texts are engaged with by different audiences." [...] below stands for this shared wording.
    Level 5 (21-25 marks): Comparison is critical, illuminating and sustained across AO1, AO2 and AO3. There will be a wide ranging discussion of the similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Sustain focus on the task, including overview, convey ideas with consistent coherence and use an appropriate register; use a sensitive and evaluative approach to the task and analyse the texts critically; show a perceptive understanding of the texts, engaging fully, perhaps with some originality in their personal response; their responses include pertinent, direct references from across the texts, including quotations. AO2: Analyse and appreciate writers' use of language, form and structure, make assured reference to meanings and effects exploring and evaluating the way meaning and ideas are conveyed through language structure and form; use precise subject terminology in an appropriate context. AO3: Show an assured understanding [...].
    Level 4 (16-20 marks): Comparison is focussed, coherent and sustained across AO1, AO2 and AO3. There will be a clear discussion of the similarities and/or differences between the poems. (Level 4 continues at the start of the comments.)
    Level 3 (11-15 marks), Level 2 (6-10 marks), Level 1 (1-5 marks): Eduqas's descriptors for these levels are given word for word at the start of the comments.
    0 marks: Nothing worthy of credit.

    Level 4 (continued): AO1: Sustain focus on the task, convey ideas with coherence and use an appropriate register; use a thoughtful approach to the task; show a secure understanding of key aspects of the texts, with considerable engagement; support and justify their responses by well-chosen direct reference to the texts, including quotations. AO2: Discuss and increasingly analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make thoughtful reference to the meanings and effects of stylistic features used by the writer; use apt subject terminology. AO3: Show a secure understanding [...].
    Level 3 (11-15 marks): Comparison is focussed across AO1, AO2 and AO3 with some valid discussion of the similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Focus on the task, convey ideas with general coherence and use a mostly appropriate register; use a straightforward approach to the task; show an understanding of key aspects of the texts, with engagement; support and justify their responses by appropriate direct reference to the texts, including quotations. AO2: Comment on and begin to analyse writers' use of language, form and structure, make some reference to meanings and effects; use relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show an understanding [...].
    Level 2 (6-10 marks): Comparison is general with some discussion of the obvious similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Have some focus on the task, convey ideas with some coherence and sometimes use an appropriate register; use a limited approach to the task; show some understanding of key aspects of the texts, with some engagement; support and justify their responses by some direct reference to the texts, including some quotations. AO2: Recognise and make simple comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make limited reference to meanings and effects; may use some relevant subject terminology. AO3: Show some understanding [...].
    Level 1 (1-5 marks): Comparison is very limited. There may be a basic awareness of the obvious similarities and/or differences between the poems. AO1: Have limited focus on the task, convey ideas with occasional coherence and may sometimes use an appropriate register; use a simple approach to the task; show a basic understanding of some key aspects of the texts, with a little engagement; may support and justify their responses by some general reference to the texts, perhaps including some quotations. AO2: May make generalised comments on writers' use of language, form and structure, may make basic reference to meanings and effects; may use some subject terminology but not always accurately. AO3: Show limited understanding [...].
    Indicative content. Second poem: credit any appropriate anthology poem about memories that return. For example, if candidates choose War Photographer, responses may include: AO1: - Memories triggered by the present: a quarrel with a daughter; photographs developing in a darkroom; - A remembered beginning (a birth) against remembered death and suffering; - Memory that explains and binds (Catrin) against memory that isolates ("they do not care"). AO2: - Images of memory rising: "the heart's pool" against "a half-formed ghost"; - Emotion delayed or relived: "did not tremble then"; the move into the present tense in Catrin; - Free verse against ordered six-line stanzas ending in rhyming couplets. AO3: - War Photographer (Standing Female Nude, 1985): Belfast, Beirut, Phnom Penh; - Catrin (1978): Clarke has said "that old rope" is the invisible cord between parents and growing children. This is not a checklist. Please reward valid alternatives.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.