Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the blood bank created for the Battle of Cambrai (1917).
Model answer
Before the Battle of Cambrai, the American army doctor Oswald Robertson collected and stored blood so that it was ready for wounded soldiers. The blood was taken from 'universal donors' (type O), mixed with a citrate and glucose solution to stop it clotting, and kept in bottles in an ice box.
Explanation
The best answers give one clear feature of the blood bank, such as who set it up, how the blood was stored or which donors were used, and support it with a precise detail. Weaker answers describe blood transfusion in general, or the discovery of blood groups in 1901, rather than the blood bank itself. Keep the answer to the store of blood before Cambrai: the battle began on 20 November 1917.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the blood bank identified, e.g. blood was collected and stored before the battle began / it was set up by Oswald Robertson, an American army doctor working with the British Third Army / the donors were 'universal donors' (type O, then called group IV) / the blood was mixed with a citrate and glucose solution so that it did not clot / it was kept cold in bottles in an ice box / stored blood could be kept for about four weeks / the stored blood was used up within a few days of the fighting.
Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. The blood was collected before the battle began (1). This meant that blood was ready for transfusions as soon as badly wounded men arrived, without having to find a donor at the time (1). e.g. It was organised by Captain Oswald Robertson, a doctor in the US Army (1). He brought the method of storing blood to the casualty clearing stations of the British Third Army in November 1917 (1). e.g. Only donors of one blood group were used (1). Blood from 'universal donors' (the group now called type O) could be given to any patient without testing which group he belonged to (1). e.g. The blood was mixed with a solution of sodium citrate and glucose (1). The citrate stopped the blood clotting and the glucose kept the red cells alive, so it could be stored for up to about four weeks (1). e.g. It was kept cold (1). The bottles were stored in an ice box, which could be made from two packing cases with sawdust between them (1). e.g. The store was soon used up (1). In his 1918 report Robertson wrote that a store of twenty pints laid in just before an attack gave enough for fourteen transfusions and ran out on the third day, and that few lightly wounded men were available as donors to refill it (1). (His report does not name the battle; the official medical history says his method was tested at a Third Army casualty clearing station during the Battle of Cambrai.) Accept approximate figures that students may have learned for the size of the store (for example about 20 pints, or 22 units), but do not require one: Robertson's own report gives twenty pints for the store and 22 transfusions to 20 men in all. Accept type O or 'universal donor'. Credit donors being lightly wounded soldiers who volunteered. Do not credit the claim that blood groups were discovered at Cambrai (Landsteiner identified them in 1901), or confusion with direct transfusion from a donor lying next to the patient. Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for collecting in advance: blood was ready when the wounded arrived, without a donor having to be present; for Robertson: an American doctor (US Army Medical Officers' Reserve Corps) working with the Third Army from November 1917; for donors: type O (universal donors) so no matching tests were needed, taken from lightly wounded men; for the solution: sodium citrate stopped clotting and glucose kept the cells alive; for storage: glass bottles in an ice box, kept for up to about 26 days; for being used up: Robertson reported that a store of twenty pints gave fourteen transfusions and ran out on the third day of the attack, with few lightly wounded donors to refill it.
The supporting information must develop the feature given for the first mark. Do not credit a repeat of the feature, or a general comment such as 'it helped the soldiers' or 'it was a big step forward'.