Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Edexcel GCSE History (Medicine in Britain c1250-present) Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
c1250-c1500: Medicine in medieval England
Unit 2
c1500-c1700: The Medical Renaissance in England
Unit 3
c1700-c1900: Medicine in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Britain
Unit 4
c1900-present: Medicine in modern Britain
Unit 5
Historic environment: The British sector of the Western Front, 1914-18: injuries, treatment and the trenches
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/17

The Western Front: experiments in surgery and medicine

Practise 18 exam-style questions on The Western Front: experiments in surgery and medicine for Edexcel GCSE History (Medicine in Britain c1250-present). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 18 questions
  • 2–8 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
18 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

2 marks

Describe one feature of the blood bank created for the Battle of Cambrai (1917).

Model answer

Before the Battle of Cambrai, the American army doctor Oswald Robertson collected and stored blood so that it was ready for wounded soldiers. The blood was taken from 'universal donors' (type O), mixed with a citrate and glucose solution to stop it clotting, and kept in bottles in an ice box.

Explanation

The best answers give one clear feature of the blood bank, such as who set it up, how the blood was stored or which donors were used, and support it with a precise detail. Weaker answers describe blood transfusion in general, or the discovery of blood groups in 1901, rather than the blood bank itself. Keep the answer to the store of blood before Cambrai: the battle began on 20 November 1917.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    A valid feature of the blood bank identified, e.g. blood was collected and stored before the battle began / it was set up by Oswald Robertson, an American army doctor working with the British Third Army / the donors were 'universal donors' (type O, then called group IV) / the blood was mixed with a citrate and glucose solution so that it did not clot / it was kept cold in bottles in an ice box / stored blood could be kept for about four weeks / the stored blood was used up within a few days of the fighting.

    Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. The blood was collected before the battle began (1). This meant that blood was ready for transfusions as soon as badly wounded men arrived, without having to find a donor at the time (1). e.g. It was organised by Captain Oswald Robertson, a doctor in the US Army (1). He brought the method of storing blood to the casualty clearing stations of the British Third Army in November 1917 (1). e.g. Only donors of one blood group were used (1). Blood from 'universal donors' (the group now called type O) could be given to any patient without testing which group he belonged to (1). e.g. The blood was mixed with a solution of sodium citrate and glucose (1). The citrate stopped the blood clotting and the glucose kept the red cells alive, so it could be stored for up to about four weeks (1). e.g. It was kept cold (1). The bottles were stored in an ice box, which could be made from two packing cases with sawdust between them (1). e.g. The store was soon used up (1). In his 1918 report Robertson wrote that a store of twenty pints laid in just before an attack gave enough for fourteen transfusions and ran out on the third day, and that few lightly wounded men were available as donors to refill it (1). (His report does not name the battle; the official medical history says his method was tested at a Third Army casualty clearing station during the Battle of Cambrai.) Accept approximate figures that students may have learned for the size of the store (for example about 20 pints, or 22 units), but do not require one: Robertson's own report gives twenty pints for the store and 22 transfusions to 20 men in all. Accept type O or 'universal donor'. Credit donors being lightly wounded soldiers who volunteered. Do not credit the claim that blood groups were discovered at Cambrai (Landsteiner identified them in 1901), or confusion with direct transfusion from a donor lying next to the patient. Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.

  2. 1 mark

    Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for collecting in advance: blood was ready when the wounded arrived, without a donor having to be present; for Robertson: an American doctor (US Army Medical Officers' Reserve Corps) working with the Third Army from November 1917; for donors: type O (universal donors) so no matching tests were needed, taken from lightly wounded men; for the solution: sodium citrate stopped clotting and glucose kept the cells alive; for storage: glass bottles in an ice box, kept for up to about 26 days; for being used up: Robertson reported that a store of twenty pints gave fourteen transfusions and ran out on the third day of the attack, with few lightly wounded donors to refill it.

    The supporting information must develop the feature given for the first mark. Do not credit a repeat of the feature, or a general comment such as 'it helped the soldiers' or 'it was a big step forward'.

Question 2

2 marks

Describe one feature of the use of amputation to treat wounded soldiers on the Western Front.

Model answer

Amputation was often the only way to save a soldier whose limb had been infected with gas gangrene. The infection spread so quickly through dead muscle that, especially in 1914 and 1915 before excision was widely used, surgeons had to cut off the limb to stop it reaching the rest of the body.

Explanation

A good answer gives one clear feature, such as why amputation was needed, how it was done or how its use changed, and backs it up with a precise detail. Strong answers often link amputation to gas gangrene, or show that it became less common as excision and the Thomas splint saved more limbs. Avoid general statements that amputation was 'gruesome' or 'painful', which are not features.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    A valid feature of the use of amputation identified, e.g. limbs were amputated when they were too badly smashed to save / amputation was used when gas gangrene had set in, to save the man's life / there were many amputations early in the war / a quick 'guillotine' amputation was often used and the stump left open / a second operation was usually needed later / amputations became less common as wound excision and the Thomas splint spread / large numbers of men needed artificial limbs.

    Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Amputation was used to save the lives of men with gas gangrene (1). Once the infection had killed the muscles of a limb it spread very quickly, so cutting off the limb was often the only way to stop it (1). e.g. There were many amputations early in the war (1). In 1914-15 gas gangrene was not well understood and many wounded men arrived late, so surgeons had to amputate limbs that might later have been saved (1). e.g. A quick 'guillotine' amputation was often used (1). All the tissues and the bone were cut through at the same level and the stump was left open, not stitched, which was fast and reduced the risk of infection (1). e.g. A second operation was usually needed (1). The stump was tidied up later at a base hospital or in Britain so that an artificial limb could be fitted, for example at Queen Mary's Hospital, Roehampton, opened in 1915 (1). e.g. Amputations became less common (1). Early excision of wounds and the Thomas splint meant more limbs could be saved: in August 1918 the amputation rate among 10,000 wounded in the base hospitals was only about half a per cent (1). e.g. Many soldiers lost limbs (1). About 41,000 British servicemen lost one or more limbs in the war (1). Do not credit claims that amputations were carried out without anaesthetics as a normal practice, or that they were done in the front-line trenches. Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.

  2. 1 mark

    Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for gas gangrene: infection spread very fast through dead muscle, so amputation was the only way to save life; for early in the war: gas gangrene poorly understood and men arrived late in 1914-15; for the guillotine method: tissues and bone cut at one level and the stump left open to stop infection; for a second operation: the stump was reshaped later so an artificial limb could be fitted (Roehampton, 1915); for fewer amputations: excision and the Thomas splint saved limbs, about 0.5 per cent amputation rate in August 1918; for numbers: about 41,000 British servicemen lost limbs.

    The supporting information must develop the feature given for the first mark. Do not credit a repeat of the feature, or a general comment such as 'it was very painful' or 'it was the last resort' without saying why.

Question 3

4 marks

Source A: From the journal kept by Harvey Cushing, an American brain surgeon who was working at No. 46 Casualty Clearing Station near Proven in Belgium, published in 1936 as From a Surgeon's Journal, 1915-1918. These entries were written on 2 and 3 August 1917, at the start of the Third Battle of Ypres.

Thursday, August 2
... Operating from 8.30 a.m. one day till 2.00 a.m. the next; standing in a pair of rubber boots, and periodically full of tea as a stimulant, is not healthy. ... Something over 2000 wounded have passed, so far, through this one C.C.S. There are fifteen similar stations behind the battle front.
10.30 p.m. ... Operating again all day, and finished up an hour ago with an extraction of a large piece of shell from a man's badly infected ventricle [a space inside the brain] with the magnet - then dinner, and now to bed. ...
Friday, August 3
... In the early afternoon a large batch of wounded were unexpectedly brought in - mostly heads - men who have been lying out for four days in craters in the rain, without food. ... Then a long operation on a sergeant with things in his brain and ventricle like the man of last night - the magnet again useful ... Many muddy bystanders from the adjacent hospitals looking on and fairly sitting on the instrument stands.

How could you follow up Source A to find out more about the work of brain surgeons at casualty clearing stations during the Third Battle of Ypres? In your answer, you must give the question you would ask and the type of source you could use.

Set out your answer under these four headings:
Detail in Source A that I would follow up:
Question I would ask:
What type of source I could use:
How this might help answer my question:

Model answer

Detail in Source A that I would follow up: 'men who have been lying out for four days in craters in the rain'.
Question I would ask: How did delays in bringing in wounded men affect the survival of soldiers with head wounds?
What type of source I could use: The casualty clearing station's admission and discharge register for head wounds in August 1917.
How this might help answer my question: It would record when each man was admitted, his treatment and whether he was sent to the base or died, so I could compare delay with survival.

Explanation

Choose a detail that leads to a clear question about the work of brain surgeons, then name a specific source from the time that would contain the answer, such as a surgeon's article in a medical journal or a register of head cases. Explain what information the source would give, not simply that it would be 'reliable'. Do not take the detail from the provenance or ask a question that only Cushing could answer.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    A detail in Source A that could form the basis of a follow-up enquiry into the work of brain surgeons at casualty clearing stations, e.g. 'an extraction of a large piece of shell ... with the magnet' / 'men who have been lying out for four days in craters in the rain' / 'Operating from 8.30 a.m. one day till 2.00 a.m. the next' / 'Many muddy bystanders from the adjacent hospitals looking on'.

    Award 1 mark for selecting a detail in the source that could form the basis of a follow-up enquiry and 1 mark for an appropriate follow-up question. Award 1 mark for identification of an appropriate source to use in a follow-up enquiry and 1 mark for an answer that explains how the information it contains could help answer the chosen follow-up question. e.g. Detail: 'an extraction of a large piece of shell ... with the magnet' (1). Question: How often did the magnet succeed in removing metal from the brain? (1). Type of source: an article by a brain surgeon in the British Medical Journal in 1918 reporting the results of a series of operations on head wounds at the casualty clearing stations (1). How it might help: it would give the number of cases in which the magnet was used, how many fragments it removed and how many patients survived (1). e.g. Detail: 'men who have been lying out for four days in craters in the rain' (1). Question: How did delays in bringing in wounded men affect the survival of soldiers with head wounds? (1). Type of source: the casualty clearing station's admission and discharge register for head wounds in August 1917 (1). How it might help: it would record when each man was wounded and admitted, his treatment and whether he was sent to the base or died, so delay could be compared with outcome (1). e.g. Detail: 'Many muddy bystanders from the adjacent hospitals looking on' (1). Question: How did surgeons at other casualty clearing stations learn the new methods of brain surgery? (1). Type of source: the reports of the meetings of medical officers held at casualty clearing stations in the Fifth Army in 1917 (1). How it might help: they would show which methods were demonstrated or discussed and who attended, showing how new techniques spread (1). (No mark for a question that is not linked to following up Source A, e.g. 'because it would be an interesting question to ask'.) Accept other appropriate alternatives.

  2. 1 mark

    An appropriate follow-up question linked to the detail chosen and to the work of brain surgeons, e.g. How often did the magnet succeed in removing metal from the brain? / How did delays in bringing in the wounded affect the survival of men with head wounds? / How long did surgical teams have to work during the battle? / How did other surgeons learn the new methods?

    The question must follow up the chosen detail and stay within the enquiry. Do not credit a question addressed to Cushing (e.g. 'Why did Cushing keep a journal?') or a question outside the enquiry (e.g. 'Why did it rain so much in August 1917?').

  3. 1 mark

    An appropriate type of source that could help answer the question, e.g. articles by brain surgeons in the British Medical Journal or the British Journal of Surgery (1917-18) / a casualty clearing station's register of head wounds / the war diary of No. 46 Casualty Clearing Station / reports of medical officers' meetings / letters or diaries of nursing sisters at the head-wound centre.

    Credit a specific type of source that existed at the time and could contain the information needed. Do not credit vague answers such as 'RAMC records' or 'a book' unless the explanation makes clear what the source contains. Do not credit modern history books, websites, documentaries or interviewing someone. If the question is not valid, a source chosen to answer it cannot be credited.

  4. 1 mark

    An explanation of how the information in the chosen source could help answer the question, e.g. a surgeon's article would give figures for magnet extractions and survival / a register of head wounds would show delay, treatment and outcome for each man / reports of meetings would show which methods were demonstrated to other surgeons.

    The explanation must say what information the chosen source would contain and how it would answer the question. Do not credit 'it would tell me the answer' or an explanation that does not match the source or the question.

Question 4

8 marks

Study Sources A and B.

Source A: From Surgery at a Casualty Clearing Station by Cuthbert Wallace and John Fraser, published in 1918. Wallace was a consulting surgeon with the British army in France and Fraser had worked as a surgeon at a casualty clearing station. Here they describe a new way of storing blood for transfusions.

It has been suggested that when transfusion of whole blood is for any reason impossible, there are advantages in injecting, suspended in some medium, red blood corpuscles, which have been citrated and preserved. They possibly retain some power as oxygen carriers and they certainly assist in preserving blood volume and pressure in so far as they do not tend to escape out of the blood-vessels as fluids do. ...
Peyton Rous and Turner described a method by which washed blood corpuscles may be preserved for three or four weeks.
They employed a solution containing two parts of isotonic (3.8 per cent) sodium citrate and five parts of isotonic (5.4 per cent) glucose.
Captain Robertson, M.O.R.C., U.S.A. [of the United States Army Medical Officers' Reserve Corps], has carried out a large amount of exceedingly valuable work on the subject, and he has evolved a method by which transfusion of blood on this basis can be applied in war work.
In the following account of the method we quote very largely from Captain Robertson's report to the Medical Research Committee.

Source B: From the journal kept by Harvey Cushing, an American surgeon who was working with the British army in France, published in 1936 as From a Surgeon's Journal, 1915-1918. These entries were written in Boulogne on 16 and 19 December 1917.

Sunday, Dec. 16th. Boulogne
... Robertson is back from the Front, where he has had an interesting period with his uncle, D.M.S. [Director of Medical Services] of the 3rd Army, and done some excellent work on blood transfusion. He knows the Cambrai performance at first hand. ...
Wed. the 19th Dec.
Robertson gave a talk this afternoon on his transfusion work at No. 3 C.C.S. in Grévillers near Bapaume; also at No. 46 in Ytres during the Cambrai affair. Very interesting. Made sufficient impression on Colonel Gray to cause him to volunteer as a donor, since they had few walking cases from whom they could get blood to store.

How useful are Sources A and B for an enquiry into Oswald Robertson's work on storing blood for transfusions during the Battle of Cambrai (1917)? Explain your answer, using Sources A and B and your knowledge of the historical context.

Model answer

Source A is useful because it explains the method that made the blood bank possible. Wallace and Fraser say that blood cells 'citrated and preserved' in Rous and Turner's citrate and glucose solution could be kept 'for three or four weeks', and that Captain Robertson had 'evolved a method' of using such blood 'in war work'. This fits what I know: Robertson, an American army doctor, brought this method to the casualty clearing stations of the British Third Army in November 1917, storing blood from universal donors (type O) in bottles in an ice box before the attack at Cambrai. As experienced surgeons writing in 1918 and using Robertson's own report, the authors show how quickly British surgeons took up the method. However, the book is a technical guide, so it says nothing about Cambrai itself or how much blood was stored, and it relies on Robertson's report rather than its authors' own experience.

Source B is useful because it links Robertson's stored blood directly to the Battle of Cambrai. Cushing records that Robertson did transfusion work at No. 46 casualty clearing station at Ytres 'during the Cambrai affair', and that they had 'few walking cases from whom they could get blood to store'. This shows that the blood bank depended on lightly wounded donors, who were scarce when the most serious cases were arriving, which fits what I know: Robertson later reported that a store of about 20 pints, laid in just before an attack, ran out on the third day of the fighting. Cushing heard Robertson's talk only weeks after the battle, so this is close to the event, but it is a brief private journal entry, edited and published in 1936, and he is repeating what Robertson told him. He also admired Robertson, a fellow American, so he may stress his success.

Overall, Source A is more useful for how the blood was stored, and Source B for evidence that stored blood was used during the battle, but neither gives the number of transfusions or how many men survived.

Explanation

Strong answers judge each source against the specific enquiry: Source A explains the storage method but not the battle, while Source B links the blood bank to Cambrai but is brief and second-hand. They use precise context, such as Robertson's work with the Third Army from November 1917, universal type O donors and storage in an ice box. Weaker answers write about blood transfusion in general or about the discovery of blood groups instead of the blood bank.

Mark scheme
  1. 8 marks

    Levels of response (8 marks). AO3: 8 marks.
    Level 3 (6-8 marks): Judgements on source utility for the specified enquiry are given, applying valid criteria with developed reasoning which takes into account how the provenance affects the usefulness of the source content. The sources are analysed to support reasoning about their utility. Contextual knowledge is used in the process of interpreting the sources and applying criteria for judgements on their utility.
    Level 2 (3-5 marks): Judgements on source utility for the specified enquiry are given, using valid criteria. Judgements are supported by developed comment related to the content of the sources and/or their provenance. Comprehension and some analysis of the sources is shown by the selection and use of material to support comments on their utility. Contextual knowledge is used directly to support comments on the usefulness of the content of the sources and/or their provenance.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple judgement on utility is given, and supported by undeveloped comment on the content of the sources and/or their provenance. Simple comprehension of the source material is shown by the extraction or paraphrase of some content. Limited contextual knowledge is deployed with links to the sources.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.
    Note: Provenance = nature, origin, purpose. No credit may be given for contextual knowledge unless it is linked to evaluation of the sources. No credit may be given for generic comments on provenance which are not used to evaluate source content.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Source A (Wallace and Fraser, 1918). Content: red blood cells could be 'citrated and preserved' and given when fresh whole blood was not available; Rous and Turner's citrate and glucose solution kept blood for three or four weeks; Captain Robertson of the US Army had done 'exceedingly valuable work' and 'evolved a method' of using stored blood 'in war work'; his report to the Medical Research Committee was the basis of their account. Provenance: two experienced casualty clearing station surgeons writing in 1918, soon after Robertson's work and with access to his report, so it is up to date and shows how quickly the method was taken up by British surgeons; but it is a technical guide, says nothing about Cambrai or how much blood was stored, and depends on Robertson's own report. Context: Robertson, an American army doctor, brought the method to the British Third Army in November 1917; the solution came from the experiments of Rous and Turner (1916); blood from universal donors (type O, then called group IV) needed no matching; bottles were kept in an ice box; in his 1918 report Robertson wrote that a store of twenty pints laid in 'just before a recent attack' (he does not name the battle) gave fourteen transfusions and ran out on the third day, and that in all he gave 22 transfusions to 20 men, 11 of whom reached the base in good condition (accept '22 units', which some textbooks give for the store); the official medical history says the method was tested during the Battle of Cambrai but 'was not generally adopted' because other methods were simpler; blood groups had been identified by Landsteiner in 1901. Source B (Cushing's journal). Content: Robertson had worked at the front with the Third Army, whose senior medical officer was his uncle, and 'knows the Cambrai performance at first hand'; he did transfusion work at No. 3 casualty clearing station near Bapaume and at No. 46 at Ytres 'during the Cambrai affair'; they had few walking wounded to give blood 'to store', so even Colonel Gray volunteered as a donor. Provenance: written within weeks of the battle by an American surgeon who heard Robertson's talk himself, so it is first-hand evidence that stored blood was used during Cambrai and that donors were hard to find; but it is a private journal, brief and second-hand about the battle, edited and published in 1936, and Cushing was a friend and fellow American who admired Robertson. Context: the Battle of Cambrai began on 20 November 1917 with a mass tank attack; the German counter-attack of 30 November brought many more wounded; transfusions were given in resuscitation wards at casualty clearing stations; donors were normally lightly wounded soldiers. Judgement: A is more useful for how blood was stored and why it mattered; B for evidence that it was used at casualty clearing stations during Cambrai and for the difficulty of finding donors; neither gives the number of transfusions or results. Do not credit comparison for its own sake.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.