Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of shell shock among soldiers on the Western Front.
Model answer
Shell shock often had physical symptoms even when the soldier had no wound at all. Some men shook uncontrollably, developed a stammer or lost the power to speak, see or move their legs after long periods under heavy shellfire.
Explanation
A full-mark answer gives one specific feature of shell shock, such as its cause or a particular symptom, and then supports it with a precise example. Weaker answers stay vague ('it affected their minds') or describe the effects of gas or wounds instead. Two linked sentences are enough.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of shell shock identified, e.g. it was caused by the strain of constant shelling and the horrors of trench warfare / it had physical symptoms such as shaking, stammering, paralysis or loss of speech, sight or hearing / it had mental symptoms such as nightmares, panic, memory loss or being unable to sleep / doctors at first thought it was caused by the blast of shells damaging the nerves / large numbers of officers and men were affected / it was not well understood and some people saw it as cowardice.
Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Shell shock was caused by the strain of trench warfare (1). Men suffered long periods of shelling, saw friends killed and were sometimes buried alive by explosions, and in the end their minds could not cope (1). e.g. It had physical symptoms (1). Some men shook uncontrollably, developed a stammer, or lost the use of their legs, their speech, their sight or their hearing even though they had no wound (1). e.g. It had mental symptoms (1). Sufferers had nightmares, could not sleep, panicked at the sound of guns or lost their memory of what had happened (1). e.g. At first its cause was misunderstood (1). The name came from the idea that the blast of exploding shells damaged the brain or nerves, but doctors found that many sufferers had never been near an explosion (1). e.g. It affected very large numbers of men (1). Large numbers of officers and men were sent away from the front with it, and special hospitals were set up in Britain to treat them (1). e.g. It was not always treated sympathetically (1). Some officers saw it as weakness or cowardice, and from June 1917 the army tried to stop the term 'shell shock' being used, labelling new cases 'NYDN' (not yet diagnosed, nervous) (1). Accept 'neurasthenia', 'nerves' or 'war neurosis' as names used at the time. Do not credit descriptions of the physical effects of gas or of wounds. Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the cause: constant shelling, seeing friends killed or being buried by an explosion; for physical symptoms: shaking, stammering, paralysis, or loss of speech, sight or hearing without any wound; for mental symptoms: nightmares, sleeplessness, panic at gunfire or memory loss; for the misunderstood cause: the name suggested damage from shell blast, but many sufferers had not been near an explosion; for the scale: large numbers sent home and special hospitals set up; for attitudes: some saw it as cowardice and from 1917 the army labelled cases 'NYDN' instead of shell shock.
The supporting information must develop the feature given for the first mark. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature, or a general comment such as 'it was a terrible condition' or 'it affected the mind'. Do not credit the claim that all sufferers were shot as cowards: a small number of soldiers were executed for offences such as desertion, but shell shock cases were normally treated medically.