Question 1
4 marksExplain one way in which ideas about miasma as a cause of disease in the years c1700-c1860 were similar to ideas about miasma in the medieval period (c1250-c1500).
Model answer
One similarity is that in both periods many people believed that disease was caused by bad air, or miasma, rising from rotting matter, so the authorities tried to remove filth. In the medieval period, the smell of rotting rubbish, sewage and dead bodies was thought to poison the air. During the Black Death, Edward III ordered the streets of London to be cleaned in 1349, and an Act of 1388 banned the throwing of filth into rivers and ditches. In the years c1700-c1860 the same idea was still widely held. Edwin Chadwick's Report of 1842 blamed disease on the filth and poor drainage of industrial towns, and Chadwick believed that the smell of decaying filth itself caused illness. When the Thames stank during the Great Stink of 1858, Parliament passed a law that led to Bazalgette's new sewers. In both periods, removing the source of the smell was seen as the way to stop disease.
Explanation
A Level 2 answer states the similarity, such as the belief that bad air from rotting matter caused disease and the action taken to remove filth, and supports it with specific evidence from both periods, such as the Act of 1388 and Chadwick's Report of 1842. Describing medieval ideas in detail but saying only 'this was the same in the nineteenth century' stays in Level 1, because both periods need support. Remember that the miasma theory was still the main explanation of disease until after 1860.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO2: 2 marks. AO1: 2 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): Features of the period are analysed to explain a similarity. [AO2] Specific information about the topic is added to support the comparison, showing good knowledge and understanding of the periods. [AO1]
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Simple or generalised comment is offered about a similarity. [AO2] Generalised information about the topic is included, showing limited knowledge and understanding of the periods. [AO1]
0 marks: No rewardable material.
Performance in AO1 and AO2 is interdependent. An answer displaying no qualities of AO2 cannot be awarded more than the top of Level 1, no matter how strong performance is in AO1; markers should note that the expectation for AO1 is that candidates demonstrate both knowledge and understanding.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Valid similarities, each needing specific information from both periods for Level 2: (1) In both periods bad air from rotting matter was blamed for disease: medieval people blamed the smell of rotting rubbish, sewage, dead bodies and stagnant water, and the Black Death (1348-49) was widely blamed on corrupted air; in c1700-c1860 Edwin Chadwick's Report (1842) blamed the filth and poor drainage of industrial towns, Chadwick believed that the smell of decaying filth itself caused disease, William Farr linked cholera deaths in 1849 to low-lying districts near the Thames, and the Great Stink (1858) alarmed Parliament. (2) In both periods the belief led the authorities to remove filth: Edward III ordered the streets of London to be cleaned (1349) and an Act of 1388 banned throwing filth into rivers and ditches; in c1700-c1860 the Public Health Act (1848) set up a General Board of Health and, after the Great Stink, Bazalgette's sewers were begun (1859). (3) In both periods people tried to purify the air or let it flow: posies and sweet-smelling herbs, and fires, in the medieval period; ventilation and fresh air in homes and hospitals (e.g. Florence Nightingale's Notes on Nursing, 1859) and fumigation in c1700-c1860. (4) In both periods miasma was held alongside other explanations (medieval: God's punishment, the humours, astrology; c1700-c1860: spontaneous generation and some religious explanations). Level 1: a generalised similarity (e.g. 'people blamed bad air') or detail about only one period. Do not credit: claims that the miasma theory had been abandoned before 1860; claims that medieval people knew about germs; differences (e.g. the use of statistics in the later period).