Question 1
4 marksExplain one way in which John Snow's explanation of how cholera spread (1849-54) was different from explanations of how the Black Death spread in England in 1348-49.
Model answer
One difference is that Snow explained cholera by a natural cause that was swallowed in contaminated water, whereas in 1348-49 people explained the Black Death by supernatural causes or by bad air. In 1348-49 the Church taught that the plague was a punishment from God for people's sins, and physicians blamed the movement of the planets or miasma, corrupted air from rotting matter that upset the balance of the humours when it was breathed in. Snow rejected the idea of bad air. In 1849 he argued that, because cholera attacked the gut, its cause must be swallowed, and that it spread when the waste of victims got into drinking water. The Broad Street outbreak of 1854 supported this: the brewery workers next to the pump, who breathed the same air as their neighbours but drank beer or water from the brewery's own well, escaped.
Explanation
Top answers state the difference clearly, such as a natural cause carried in water compared with God's punishment or bad air, and support it with specific detail about both 1348-49 and Snow's work. Weaker answers describe the causes of the Black Death in detail and then say only that Snow 'was more scientific'. Snow did not know about germs: germ theory came in 1861, and Koch identified the cholera bacterium in 1883.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO2: 2 marks. AO1: 2 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): Features of the period are analysed to explain a difference. [AO2] Specific information about the topic is added to support the comparison, showing good knowledge and understanding of the periods. [AO1]
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Simple or generalised comment is offered about a difference. [AO2] Generalised information about the topic is included, showing limited knowledge and understanding of the periods. [AO1]
0 marks: No rewardable material.
Performance in AO1 and AO2 is interdependent. An answer displaying no qualities of AO2 cannot be awarded more than the top of Level 1, no matter how strong performance is in AO1; markers should note that the expectation for AO1 is that candidates demonstrate both knowledge and understanding.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Valid differences, each needing specific information about both 1348-49 and Snow for Level 2: (1) Supernatural compared with natural explanations: in 1348-49 many people, taught by the Church, believed the Black Death was a punishment sent by God for people's sins, and physicians blamed the movement of the planets (the Paris physicians' report of 1348 blamed a conjunction of Saturn, Jupiter and Mars in 1345); Snow's explanation was entirely natural: cholera was caused by a 'morbid matter' from the bodies of victims that multiplied in the gut of the person who swallowed it (On the Mode of Communication of Cholera, 1849; enlarged 1855). (2) Air compared with water: the most common natural explanation in 1348-49 was miasma, corrupted air from rotting matter, filth or swamps that was breathed in and upset the balance of the humours; Snow rejected the miasma theory, arguing that because cholera attacked the gut first, its cause must be swallowed, so it spread mainly through drinking water contaminated by the evacuations of victims, e.g. the well under the Broad Street pump (1854) and Thames water supplied by the Southwark and Vauxhall Company. (3) General compared with specific: medieval explanations such as God's anger, the planets, miasma or the humours were used for many different diseases; Snow argued that cholera had its own specific cause, which passed from one cholera victim to another by a particular route. (4) Authority compared with evidence: medieval explanations came from the Church, astrology and the ancient texts of Galen; Snow tested his idea against evidence, e.g. the deaths clustered round the Broad Street pump, while the brewery workers and the workhouse inmates in Poland Street, who breathed the same air as their neighbours but had their own water, mostly escaped. Level 1: a generalised difference (e.g. 'Snow was more scientific' or 'people in 1348 were more religious') or detail about only one period. Do not credit: claims that Snow identified the cholera bacterium or used germ theory (germ theory came in 1861; Koch identified the cholera bacterium in 1883-84); claims that people in 1348-49 knew that rats and fleas spread the plague; similarities (e.g. that both linked disease with filth, or that both saw that it could pass from person to person).