Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Edexcel GCSE History (Medicine in Britain c1250-present) Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
c1250-c1500: Medicine in medieval England
Unit 2
c1500-c1700: The Medical Renaissance in England
Unit 3
c1700-c1900: Medicine in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Britain
Unit 4
c1900-present: Medicine in modern Britain
Unit 5
Historic environment: The British sector of the Western Front, 1914-18: injuries, treatment and the trenches
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/17

The historical context of medicine in the early twentieth century

Practise 18 exam-style questions on The historical context of medicine in the early twentieth century for Edexcel GCSE History (Medicine in Britain c1250-present). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 18 questions
  • 2–8 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
18 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

2 marks

Describe one feature of the development of x-rays before they were used on the Western Front.

Model answer

X-rays were put to use in British hospitals very soon after Wilhelm Röntgen discovered them in Germany in 1895. In 1896 Glasgow Royal Infirmary set up an x-ray department, and x-rays were soon being used to find broken bones and objects such as needles and bullets inside the body.

Explanation

Choose one development from before the war, such as Röntgen's discovery, early hospital use, the army's use of x-rays in earlier wars or the discovery of the dangers, and support it with a precise date or example. Make sure the feature belongs to the years before 1914: mobile x-ray units on the Western Front came later. Two precise sentences are enough for both marks.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    A valid feature of the development of x-rays before the First World War identified, e.g. x-rays were discovered by Wilhelm Röntgen in 1895 / they were used very quickly in British hospitals / they were used to find broken bones and objects such as bullets and needles in the body / the British army used x-rays in its wars before 1914 / methods were developed to find the exact position and depth of an object (localisation) / the dangers of x-rays to the people using them were discovered / the equipment improved.

    Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. X-rays were discovered by Wilhelm Röntgen (1). He discovered them in Germany in November 1895, and news of the discovery spread round the world within weeks (1). e.g. They were quickly used in British hospitals (1). In January 1896 John Hall-Edwards in Birmingham x-rayed a hand to find a needle, and in 1896 Glasgow Royal Infirmary set up an x-ray department (1). e.g. The army used x-rays in war (1). Army surgeons used x-ray apparatus to find bullets in the Tirah campaign in India (1897-98), in the Sudan (1898) and in the general hospitals of the Boer War (1899-1902) (1). e.g. Ways of locating objects exactly were developed (1). In 1898 James Mackenzie Davidson presented his cross-thread localiser for finding the exact depth of a bullet or needle, and stereoscopic (3D) x-ray pictures were used (1). e.g. The dangers of x-rays were discovered (1). Many early x-ray workers suffered burns and skin damage, and Hall-Edwards had his left arm amputated in 1908 (1). e.g. The equipment improved (1). More reliable x-ray tubes were made, such as the Coolidge tube of 1913 (1). Accept 1895 or 1896 for the discovery and its first use. Do not credit mobile x-ray units on the Western Front as a pre-war development (credit them only as supporting information showing how earlier developments were later used). Do not credit Marie Curie as the discoverer of x-rays. Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.

  2. 1 mark

    Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the discovery: Röntgen, Germany, November 1895; for early use: Hall-Edwards's x-ray of a needle in a hand (Birmingham, January 1896), the x-ray department at Glasgow Royal Infirmary (1896); for military use: Tirah campaign (1897-98), Sudan (1898), Boer War general hospitals (1899-1902); for localisation: Mackenzie Davidson's cross-thread localiser (1898) and stereoscopic pictures; for dangers: burns and dermatitis, Hall-Edwards's arm amputated in 1908; for equipment: more reliable tubes such as the Coolidge tube (1913).

    The supporting information must develop the feature given for the first mark. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature, or a general comment such as 'x-rays were very useful'. Accept approximate dates.

Question 2

2 marks

Describe one feature of the developments in the storage of blood before the Battle of Cambrai (1917).

Model answer

Doctors began to add sodium citrate to blood to stop it clotting, so it could be collected in a container and given later instead of passing straight from a donor beside the patient. In 1916 Rous and Turner found that adding glucose kept the red blood cells intact for about four weeks.

Explanation

The best answers identify one development from before Cambrai, such as the use of sodium citrate or the citrate-glucose solution, and support it with a precise detail such as a date, a name or what it made possible. Remember that the key change was that the donor no longer had to be beside the patient. Do not describe the store of blood collected for the Battle of Cambrai itself, or drift into the discovery of blood groups, which came earlier.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    A valid feature of the developments in the storage of blood before Cambrai identified, e.g. sodium citrate was added to blood to stop it clotting / blood could be collected in a container and given later, so the donor no longer had to be beside the patient / citrated blood could be kept for some hours and given to a different patient / adding glucose (sugar) to citrated blood kept the red cells intact for weeks / the methods were worked out in laboratories as well as at the front.

    Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Sodium citrate was used to stop blood clotting (1). Albert Hustin in Belgium and Luis Agote in Argentina used it in 1914, and Richard Lewisohn in New York worked out a safe amount in 1915 (1). e.g. The donor no longer had to be present (1). Citrated blood could be collected from the donor in a glass vessel and then injected into the patient, which made transfusion simple enough for a casualty clearing station (1). e.g. Blood could be kept for a short time (1). In April 1916, at a casualty clearing station, Major Edward Archibald kept the citrated blood collected for one wounded soldier overnight and gave it to another the next day (1). e.g. Glucose helped to preserve the blood (1). In 1916 Peyton Rous and J. R. Turner in New York found that human red cells kept in a citrate and glucose (dextrose) solution stayed intact for about four weeks, and that rabbit cells kept for two weeks worked normally when transfused (1). e.g. The methods were developed in laboratories (1). Rous and Turner tested their solutions on animals at the Rockefeller Institute before stored blood was used for wounded soldiers (1). Accept two to four weeks for the Rous-Turner solution. Credit the store of blood collected before the Battle of Cambrai only as supporting information showing what the earlier developments made possible, not as a development before Cambrai. Do not credit Landsteiner's discovery of blood groups (1901) as a development in storage. Do not credit blood banks of the Second World War or the NHS. Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.

  2. 1 mark

    Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for sodium citrate: Hustin and Agote (1914), Lewisohn's safe dose (1915); for no donor present: blood collected in a glass vessel and injected later, simple enough for a casualty clearing station; for short-term keeping: Archibald's citrated blood kept overnight at a casualty clearing station and given to another soldier (April 1916); for glucose: Rous and Turner (1916), human red cells intact for about four weeks; for laboratory work: solutions tested on animals at the Rockefeller Institute.

    The supporting information must develop the feature given for the first mark. Do not credit a repeat of the feature, or a general comment such as 'this saved lives' without any detail.

Question 3

4 marks

Source A: From an article by Major Edward Archibald of the Canadian Army Medical Corps, published in the medical journal The Lancet in 1916. Archibald was a Canadian surgeon. Here he describes two wounded soldiers he gave blood to at a casualty clearing station on the Western Front in April 1916.

Case 6. - Admitted April 5, 1916, at 7.30 p.m. ... Consequently, it was decided to give him citrated blood, which was done about 9 p.m. After not more than two ounces had been injected, he half raised his head, made a sort of inarticulate noise, and seemed to be in momentary distress of some kind ... The injection was immediately stopped; and within five minutes he awoke, became as before, answered questions slowly and as if very tired, but quite rationally ... [Presumably], it was one of the rare accidents due to isoagglutinins [substances in the blood that make red blood cells from someone of a different blood group clump together], known to occur with blood transfusion. ... Case 7. - Admitted at 8.45 a.m. April 6, 1916, suffering from very extensive wounds of the left knee, the right foot and the right thigh. He had lost a great deal of blood and was also in shock ... At the close of the operation, the pulse had disappeared at the wrist, respirations were rapid, and he was very pale. The citrated blood obtained the night before for Case 6 had been preserved; and this was now injected into this patient's vein, about sixteen ounces in all. It brought back quite a pink colour to the face and restored the pulse which was counted to 130.

How could you follow up Source A to find out more about how far blood transfusion helped to save badly wounded soldiers on the Western Front? In your answer, you must give the question you would ask and the type of source you could use.

Set out your answer under these four headings:
Detail in Source A that I would follow up:
Question I would ask:
What type of source I could use:
How this might help answer my question:

Model answer

Detail in Source A that I would follow up: 'It brought back quite a pink colour to the face and restored the pulse'.
Question I would ask: Why did some badly wounded soldiers die even after a transfusion had restored their pulse?
What type of source I could use: Articles by army surgeons in the British Medical Journal in 1916-18 reporting a series of transfusions at casualty clearing stations.
How this might help answer my question: The articles described each patient's condition and whether he survived, so they would show whether the men who died were killed by shock or infection rather than by loss of blood.

Explanation

The key details in this source are that a transfusion quickly restored the pulse and colour of a soldier who had lost a lot of blood, but that transfusion also carried risks. A good follow-up question asks how far transfusion actually saved lives, for example why some men still died or how often patients reacted badly, rather than about the individual soldiers. The source should be specific and from the period, such as reports in the British Medical Journal or a casualty clearing station's admission and discharge book.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    A detail in Source A that could form the basis of a follow-up enquiry into how far blood transfusion helped to save badly wounded soldiers, e.g. 'It brought back quite a pink colour to the face and restored the pulse' / 'He had lost a great deal of blood and was also in shock' / 'one of the rare accidents due to isoagglutinins' / 'The injection was immediately stopped'.

    Award 1 mark for selecting a detail in the source that could form the basis of a follow-up enquiry and 1 mark for an appropriate follow-up question. Award 1 mark for identification of an appropriate source to use in a follow-up enquiry and 1 mark for an answer that explains how the information it contains could help answer the chosen follow-up question. e.g. Detail: 'It brought back quite a pink colour to the face and restored the pulse' (1). Question: Why did some badly wounded soldiers die even after a transfusion had restored their pulse? (1). Type of source: articles by army surgeons in the British Medical Journal or The Lancet in 1916-18 reporting a series of transfusions at casualty clearing stations (1). How it might help: the articles described each patient's wounds and condition and whether he survived, so they would show whether the men who died were killed by shock or by infection such as gas gangrene rather than by loss of blood (1). e.g. Detail: 'He had lost a great deal of blood and was also in shock' (1). Question: Was blood transfusion more successful for soldiers suffering mainly from loss of blood than for those in shock? (1). Type of source: the medical case sheets of soldiers given transfusions, which were collected and indexed during the war (1). How it might help: the case sheets recorded each soldier's condition, treatment and outcome, so they would show which kinds of patient transfusion helped most (1). e.g. Detail: 'one of the rare accidents due to isoagglutinins' (1). Question: How often did soldiers react badly to transfusions, and how many died as a result? (1). Type of source: the reports of the army's consulting surgeons in France on transfusion, such as Sir George Makins's account published in the British Medical Journal in 1917 (1). How it might help: the consulting surgeons collected information from hospitals across the army area, so the reports would show how common bad reactions and deaths were (1). (No mark for a question that is not linked to following up Source A, e.g. 'because it would be an interesting question to ask'.) Accept other appropriate alternatives.

  2. 1 mark

    An appropriate follow-up question linked to the detail chosen and to how far transfusion helped to save badly wounded soldiers, e.g. Why did some soldiers die even after a transfusion had restored their pulse? / Was transfusion more successful for loss of blood than for shock? / How often did soldiers react badly to transfusions? / How many soldiers given transfusions at casualty clearing stations survived?

    The question must follow up the chosen detail and stay within the enquiry (how far blood transfusion helped to save badly wounded soldiers). Do not credit a question about the individual soldiers that could not be followed up (e.g. 'What were the soldiers' names?'), a question addressed to Archibald, or a question about transfusion after 1918 (e.g. the Second World War or the NHS).

  3. 1 mark

    An appropriate type of source that could help answer the question, e.g. articles by army surgeons reporting series of transfusions in the British Medical Journal or The Lancet, 1916-18 / the medical case sheets of soldiers given transfusions / the admission and discharge books of a casualty clearing station / the reports of the army's consulting surgeons in France / the Official History of the War: Medical Services volumes on surgery (published in the 1920s, based on wartime records).

    Credit a specific type of source that could contain the information needed for the question asked; the Official History may be credited as an official record compiled from wartime documents. Do not credit vague answers such as 'a book', 'records', 'the internet' or 'a diary' with no indication of whose it is or what it contains, unless the explanation in the last section makes clear what specific information it contains. Do not credit modern history books, websites, documentaries or interviewing someone. If the question is not valid, a source chosen to answer it cannot be credited.

  4. 1 mark

    An explanation of how the information in the chosen source could help answer the question, e.g. journal articles would give each patient's condition and whether he survived / case sheets would record each soldier's treatment and outcome / admission and discharge books would show whether patients died or were sent on to a base hospital / consulting surgeons' reports would show how common bad reactions and deaths were across the army.

    The explanation must say what information the chosen source would contain and how that would answer the question. Do not credit 'it would tell me the answer', 'it would be reliable' or an explanation that does not match the source or the question.

Question 4

8 marks

Study Sources A and B.

Source A: From the preface to Localization by X Rays and Stereoscopy by Sir James Mackenzie Davidson, published in 1916. Davidson was a leading British x-ray specialist. The book explains his method of finding the exact position of objects such as bullets inside the body.

It is nearly twenty years since the author first described, in the medical press, the system of exact localization [finding the exact position] by means of X rays which is mainly the theme of this volume. The present appalling war, with its enormous number of casualties, made it seem likely that a more detailed description of the method in book form would be of some service to those engaged in X-ray work among the wounded. ... The system he advocates has stood the test of time, but it has also shown itself adaptable to the more rapid procedure which is demanded, and the simplifications which have been introduced into the original method will be found fully described in the body of this book. ... As every ophthalmic surgeon [eye surgeon] knows, foreign bodies in the eyeball and orbit [eye socket] are ever with us. At present, owing to hand-grenade warfare, such cases are occurring in very large numbers, but in civil life, especially in engineering workshops and various industrial concerns, these cases are constantly met with; and very often it happens that the eye can be saved if - but only if - the exact position of the foreign body is known, so that it may be extracted without difficulty.

Source B: An extract from an x-ray register written for this course, based on the records kept by the x-ray departments of British general hospitals in France in 1916.

X-ray Department, General Hospital, Rouen. Tuesday 4 July 1916. Selected entries.
9.10 a.m. Pte A. Hollis, 2nd Bn. Shrapnel wound, left thigh. Screen, then stereo plates. Shrapnel ball 6 cm below entry wound. Localised (cross-thread method). To theatre.
9.40 a.m. L/Cpl R. Tait, 8th Bn. Bullet wound, chest. Plate. Bullet lying behind right lung. Report sent to surgeon.
10.25 a.m. Pte J. Greaves, 11th Bn. Shell wound, right forearm. Plate. Radius fractured; three small fragments of shell. Not localised - for evacuation to England.
11.50 a.m. Tube overheated. Work stopped 40 minutes.
2.15 p.m. 2nd Lt C. Marsh, 6th Bn. Shell wound, head. Stereo plates. Fragment in skull, 2 cm deep. Urgent - to theatre.
3.30 p.m. Pte W. Dunn, 2nd Bn. Shell wound, buttock. Screen only (plates running short). Fragment not found.
Total examined today: 58. Waiting at 6 p.m.: 21. Plates in stock: 40. Request sent for plates and two new tubes.

How useful are Sources A and B for an enquiry into the methods x-ray departments used to locate bullets and shell fragments in soldiers wounded on the Western Front? Explain your answer, using Sources A and B and your knowledge of the historical context.

Model answer

Source A is useful because it shows that x-ray methods for finding objects in the body were well developed before the war and were in great demand during it. Davidson says his system of 'exact localization' had existed for 'nearly twenty years', which fits what I know: x-rays were discovered in 1895 and the army used them to find bullets in the Boer War. He wrote the book because the war's 'enormous number of casualties' made it useful 'to those engaged in X-ray work among the wounded', and he explains that hand grenades were causing 'very large numbers' of eye injuries, where 'the eye can be saved if - but only if' the fragment's exact position was known. As the inventor of the method and a leading specialist, he is an expert witness. However, his purpose was to explain and promote his own system, which he says 'has stood the test of time', so he may overstate how well it worked in busy army hospitals, and he does not show how widely it was used.

Source B is useful because it shows x-rays being used routinely in a base hospital. It records shrapnel balls, bullets and shell fragments being found by screen and stereo plates and 'localised' before men went to theatre. It also shows the problems: the 'tube overheated', plates were 'running short' and one fragment was 'not found'. This fits what I know about glass gas tubes, which overheated, and heavy glass plates. As an administrative record it was not written to impress anyone. However, it covers only one hospital on 4 July 1916, just after the first day of the Somme, when about 57,000 British soldiers became casualties, so the pressure may not have been typical, and it does not show whether the operations succeeded.

Overall, Source A is more useful for the methods and their importance, and Source B for how they worked in practice.

Explanation

High-level answers explain how the provenance shapes each source's value: an expert promoting his own method can explain it but may overstate its success, while an administrative record is factual but narrow. Precise context, such as the date of the Somme or the problems of gas x-ray tubes and glass plates, should be used to test each source. A source written for this course should be treated as the type of record its provenance describes; do not dismiss it because it was written for the course.

Mark scheme
  1. 8 marks

    Levels of response (8 marks). AO3: 8 marks.
    Level 3 (6-8 marks): Judgements on source utility for the specified enquiry are given, applying valid criteria with developed reasoning which takes into account how the provenance affects the usefulness of the source content. The sources are analysed to support reasoning about their utility. Contextual knowledge is used in the process of interpreting the sources and applying criteria for judgements on their utility.
    Level 2 (3-5 marks): Judgements on source utility for the specified enquiry are given, using valid criteria. Judgements are supported by developed comment related to the content of the sources and/or their provenance. Comprehension and some analysis of the sources is shown by the selection and use of material to support comments on their utility. Contextual knowledge is used directly to support comments on the usefulness of the content of the sources and/or their provenance.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple judgement on utility is given, and supported by undeveloped comment on the content of the sources and/or their provenance. Simple comprehension of the source material is shown by the extraction or paraphrase of some content. Limited contextual knowledge is deployed with links to the sources.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.
    Note: Provenance = nature, origin, purpose. No credit may be given for contextual knowledge unless it is linked to evaluation of the sources. No credit may be given for generic comments on provenance which are not used to evaluate source content.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Source A (Davidson). Content: a system for finding the exact position of objects by x-ray had existed for nearly twenty years (since the late 1890s); the war's enormous casualties made a detailed guide useful to those doing x-ray work among the wounded; the method had been simplified to meet the demand for speed; hand grenades caused very large numbers of fragments in the eye, and an eye could be saved only if the exact position of the fragment was known. Provenance: written by the inventor of the method, a leading x-ray specialist, so expert evidence of what x-ray localisation could do; written in 1916 to help x-ray workers among the wounded, so it shows the method was in demand; but his purpose was to explain and promote his own system ('has stood the test of time'), so he may overstate its value and does not show how widely it was used or how well it worked in busy hospitals. Context: x-rays were discovered by Röntgen in 1895 and used by the army before 1914 (Tirah, Sudan, Boer War); Davidson's cross-thread localiser dated from 1898, and stereoscopic plates were also used; base hospitals in France had x-ray departments, mobile x-ray units were in use from 1915, and by 1917 many casualty clearing stations had their own x-ray equipment; shrapnel and shell fragments were often hard to find without x-rays. Source B (x-ray register, written for this course). Content: on one day a base hospital x-rayed 58 wounded men; screens and stereo plates were used to find shrapnel balls, bullets and shell fragments, and some were localised before going to the operating theatre; urgent head cases had priority; problems included an overheated tube, a shortage of plates and a fragment that could not be found on the screen; 21 men were still waiting. Provenance: the type of record an x-ray department kept for administrative purposes, so factual and not written to persuade; but it is one hospital on one day, gives selected entries, does not say whether the operations succeeded, and 4 July 1916 was just after the first day of the Somme, so it may not be typical. Context: 1 July 1916 brought about 57,000 British casualties, and Rouen was a major base hospital area; gas x-ray tubes overheated and had to be rested; glass plates were heavy, breakable and sometimes in short supply. Judgement: A is useful for the method and why it mattered; B is useful for how x-ray work was actually carried out and its problems. Treat Source B as the type of record its provenance describes.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.