Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Edexcel GCSE History (Medicine in Britain c1250-present) Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
c1250-c1500: Medicine in medieval England
Unit 2
c1500-c1700: The Medical Renaissance in England
Unit 3
c1700-c1900: Medicine in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Britain
Unit 4
c1900-present: Medicine in modern Britain
Unit 5
Historic environment: The British sector of the Western Front, 1914-18: injuries, treatment and the trenches
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/17

Medical treatment on the Western Front

Practise 19 exam-style questions on Medical treatment on the Western Front for Edexcel GCSE History (Medicine in Britain c1250-present). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 19 questions
  • 2–8 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
19 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

2 marks

Describe one feature of the work of the Royal Army Medical Corps (RAMC) on the Western Front.

Model answer

The RAMC was responsible for moving the wounded back from the front line and treating them on the way. Each division had three RAMC field ambulances, whose bearers carried the wounded in relays from the Regimental Aid Posts and whose tent subdivisions ran the dressing stations.

Explanation

Give one clear feature of what the RAMC did, such as its role at a stage of the chain of evacuation, its growth or the dangers its men faced, and back it up with a precise detail about that same feature. Weaker answers only say that the RAMC 'helped the wounded'. Remember that army nurses were not members of the RAMC, and that RAMC men did not fight.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    A valid feature of the work of the RAMC identified, e.g. it was the army's medical service, responsible for the wounded at every stage of the chain of evacuation / each battalion had an RAMC medical officer who ran its Regimental Aid Post / its field ambulances carried the wounded back and ran the dressing stations / it ran the casualty clearing stations and the general hospitals in France / it grew enormously during the war / its members did not fight but worked close to the fighting, so many were killed / it also tried to prevent disease among the troops.

    Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Each battalion had its own RAMC medical officer (1). He ran the Regimental Aid Post close to the front line, giving first aid such as dressing wounds and stopping bleeding before the wounded were carried back (1). e.g. Its field ambulances moved the wounded back from the aid posts (1). Each division had three field ambulances, whose bearers carried the wounded in relays and whose tent subdivisions ran the advanced and main dressing stations (1). e.g. It ran the casualty clearing stations and the general hospitals (1). Surgeons at the casualty clearing stations operated on the most serious cases, which were then sent by ambulance train to the general hospitals at bases such as Etaples, Boulogne and Rouen (1). e.g. It grew enormously during the war (1). By the end of the war it had about 13,000 officers and 154,000 other ranks, and many of its doctors were civilian doctors given temporary commissions (1). e.g. Its members did not fight but worked close to the fighting (1). Many lost their lives: 743 RAMC officers and 6,130 soldiers were killed in the war, counting all theatres (1). e.g. It also tried to prevent disease (1). Soldiers were offered inoculation against typhoid before going overseas, and the RAMC's mobile bacteriological laboratories searched for carriers of the disease to stop outbreaks among the troops (1). Credit details of stretcher bearers, dressing stations or casualty clearing stations when they are given as part of the RAMC's work. Accept approximate figures for the size of the RAMC (e.g. 'over 150,000 men' or 'about 167,000'). Do not credit army nurses as members of the RAMC (they belonged to Queen Alexandra's Imperial Military Nursing Service and its reserves, and the VADs and FANY were voluntary organisations), although answers may say that nurses worked in RAMC hospitals and casualty clearing stations; do not credit the claim that RAMC men fought as infantry. Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.

  2. 1 mark

    Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for medical officers: one with each battalion, running the Regimental Aid Post and giving first aid; for field ambulances: three per division, with bearers carrying the wounded in relays and tent subdivisions running the advanced and main dressing stations; for casualty clearing stations and hospitals: operations at the casualty clearing stations, then ambulance trains to the general hospitals at the bases; for growth: about 13,000 officers and 154,000 other ranks by the end of the war, many of the doctors civilians with temporary commissions; for danger: 743 officers and 6,130 soldiers killed (all theatres of the war); for preventing disease: inoculation against typhoid, laboratories searching for carriers.

    The supporting information must develop the feature given for the first mark. Do not credit a repeat of the feature, or a general comment such as 'they helped the wounded' or 'they were very brave'.

Question 2

4 marks

Source A: From 'The War Doctors', written by Lord Northcliffe in September 1916 and published later that year in his book At the War, which was sold to raise money for the British Red Cross and the Order of St John. Northcliffe owned The Times and the Daily Mail. Here he describes the Regimental Aid Posts on the Somme in 1916.

First in the order of danger is the Regimental Aid Post, where the regimental doctor, with his stretcher-bearers, awaits, alongside the men who are to clamber "over the top," the bloody fruits of battle. ... The doctor has to-day probably only the shelter of one of our own trenches or any little part that may remain of a captured German trench. There is no other covering for him and his brave stretcher-bearers, who are at once his nurses and his orderlies. ... The stretcher-bearers stagger in with their load. There is a lightning diagnosis, an antiseptic application, bandaging, a hastily-written label tied to the man's breast, and the wounded one is borne off and away in the open to the next stage, the Advanced Dressing Station, which is as often as not also pushed right up into the fire zone. The regimental stretcher-bearers therefore begin again another dangerous pilgrimage rearwards.

How could you follow up Source A to find out more about the work done at Regimental Aid Posts? In your answer, you must give the question you would ask and the type of source you could use.

Set out your answer under these four headings:
Detail in Source A that I would follow up:
Question I would ask:
What type of source I could use:
How this might help answer my question:

Model answer

Detail in Source A that I would follow up: 'a hastily-written label tied to the man's breast'.
Question I would ask: What information was recorded about each wounded man when he was first treated?
What type of source I could use: Surviving field medical cards (Army Form W3118) kept in archives and museum collections.
How this might help answer my question: The card was filled in when a man was first treated and travelled with him, so it would show what was written about his wound and treatment, such as morphine or anti-tetanus serum.

Explanation

Each heading earns a mark, so choose one precise detail and keep the question, the source and the explanation linked to it and to the enquiry about the work done at aid posts. The source must be a specific type that existed at the time and would really contain the answer, such as a medical officer's diary or field medical cards; vague answers such as 'a book' or 'the internet' do not score. Give only one detail, one question and one source: offering several usually breaks the link between the sections.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    A detail in Source A that could form the basis of a follow-up enquiry into the work done at Regimental Aid Posts, e.g. 'a hastily-written label tied to the man's breast' / 'There is a lightning diagnosis, an antiseptic application, bandaging' / 'only the shelter of one of our own trenches' / 'his brave stretcher-bearers, who are at once his nurses and his orderlies'.

    Award 1 mark for selecting a detail in the source that could form the basis of a follow-up enquiry and 1 mark for an appropriate follow-up question. Award 1 mark for identification of an appropriate source to use in a follow-up enquiry and 1 mark for an answer that explains how the information it contains could help answer the chosen follow-up question. e.g. Detail: 'a hastily-written label tied to the man's breast' (1). Question: What information was recorded about each wounded man when he was first treated, and how was it used later in the chain of evacuation? (1). Type of source: surviving field medical cards (Army Form W3118) kept in archives and museum collections (1). How it might help: the card was filled in when the man was first treated and travelled with him, so it would show what was written down, such as the wound and whether morphine or anti-tetanus serum had been given (1). e.g. Detail: 'There is a lightning diagnosis, an antiseptic application, bandaging' (1). Question: How much treatment could a Regimental Medical Officer give at an aid post? (1). Type of source: the diary or letters of a Regimental Medical Officer serving on the Somme in 1916, e.g. in the Imperial War Museum's collections (1). How it might help: a medical officer recording his daily work would describe the treatments he gave, such as dressings, splints and morphine, and what he could not do there, such as operations (1). e.g. Detail: 'only the shelter of one of our own trenches' (1). Question: How dangerous was it for medical officers and stretcher bearers to work at Regimental Aid Posts? (1). Type of source: the RAMC casualty lists published in national newspapers such as The Times in 1916 (1). How it might help: the lists name the RAMC officers and men killed and wounded each day, so they would show how many were lost while working near the front (1). (No mark for a question that is not linked to following up Source A, e.g. 'because it would be an interesting question to ask'.) Accept other appropriate alternatives.

  2. 1 mark

    An appropriate follow-up question linked to the detail chosen and to the work done at Regimental Aid Posts, e.g. What information was recorded about each wounded man at the aid post? / How much treatment could a Regimental Medical Officer give at an aid post? / How dangerous was it to work at Regimental Aid Posts?

    The question must follow up the chosen detail and stay within the enquiry (the work done at Regimental Aid Posts). Do not credit a question addressed to the author (e.g. 'Why did Northcliffe visit the front?'), a question about something outside the enquiry (e.g. 'Who owned the Daily Mail?'), or a question so narrow that it only asks about one person or moment in the source.

  3. 1 mark

    An appropriate type of source that could help answer the question, e.g. surviving field medical cards (Army Form W3118) / the diary or letters of a Regimental Medical Officer / a battalion's or field ambulance's war diary / RAMC casualty lists in The Times / official photographs of aid posts / articles by RAMC doctors in the British Medical Journal.

    Credit a specific type of source that existed at the time and could contain the information needed for the question asked. Do not credit vague answers such as 'a book', 'the internet', 'records' or 'a diary' with no indication of whose or what it contains, unless the explanation in the last section makes clear what specific information it contains. Do not credit modern history books, websites, documentaries or interviewing someone. If the question is not valid, a source chosen to answer it cannot be credited.

  4. 1 mark

    An explanation of how the information in the chosen source could help answer the question, e.g. field medical cards would show what was recorded about each man's wound and treatment / a medical officer's diary would describe the treatments he could and could not give / casualty lists would show how many RAMC men were killed or wounded near the front.

    The explanation must say what information the chosen source would contain and how that would answer the question. Do not credit 'it would tell me the answer', 'it would be reliable' or an explanation that does not match the source or the question.

Question 3

4 marks

Source A: From The Great War as I Saw It by Frederick George Scott, published in 1922. Scott was a chaplain with the 1st Canadian Division. Here he describes what happened after he was wounded near Cambrai on 29 September 1918.

I found myself being carried off in a German sheet by four prisoners. ... The chaplain walked beside me till we came to the aid post where there were some stretchers. I was placed on one and carried into the dressing station at Haynecourt. They had been having a hard time that day, for the village was heavily shelled. ... When the doctors had finished binding up my wounds, I was carried off immediately to an ambulance in the road, and placed in it with four others, one of whom was dying. It was a long journey of four hours and a half to No. 1 C.C.S. at Agnez-les-Duisans, and we had to stop at Queant on the way. ... Partly from shell holes, and partly from the wear of heavy traffic, the road was very bumpy. The man above me was in terrible agony, and every fresh jolt made him groan. ... They took me to the X-ray room and then to the operating-tent that night, and sent me off on the following afternoon to the Base ...

How could you follow up Source A to find out more about how quickly wounded soldiers reached a casualty clearing station for treatment? In your answer, you must give the question you would ask and the type of source you could use.

Set out your answer under these four headings:
Detail in Source A that I would follow up:
Question I would ask:
What type of source I could use:
How this might help answer my question:

Model answer

Detail in Source A that I would follow up: 'It was a long journey of four hours and a half to No. 1 C.C.S.'
Question I would ask: How long did it usually take to move the wounded from a dressing station to a casualty clearing station in 1918?
What type of source I could use: The war diary of the motor ambulance convoy working on that part of the front in autumn 1918.
How this might help answer my question: It would record each day's journeys, how long they took and any delays on the roads, so I could see whether four and a half hours was typical.

Explanation

The strongest answers turn one detail from Scott's own journey into a wider question about how quickly wounded men in general reached a casualty clearing station and treatment, and then choose a source that would cover many cases, such as a convoy's war diary or surgeons' reports of the time between wounding and operation. Questions about Scott himself, such as how he recovered, do not help the enquiry. Make sure the explanation says exactly what information the source would give.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    A detail in Source A that could form the basis of a follow-up enquiry into how quickly wounded soldiers reached a casualty clearing station for treatment, e.g. 'It was a long journey of four hours and a half to No. 1 C.C.S.' / 'we had to stop at Queant on the way' / 'the road was very bumpy' / 'I was carried off immediately to an ambulance' / 'the village was heavily shelled' / 'They took me to the X-ray room and then to the operating-tent that night'.

    Award 1 mark for selecting a detail in the source that could form the basis of a follow-up enquiry and 1 mark for an appropriate follow-up question. Award 1 mark for identification of an appropriate source to use in a follow-up enquiry and 1 mark for an answer that explains how the information it contains could help answer the chosen follow-up question. e.g. Detail: 'It was a long journey of four hours and a half to No. 1 C.C.S. at Agnez-les-Duisans' (1). Question: How long did it usually take to move wounded men from the dressing stations to a casualty clearing station during the advance of autumn 1918? (1). Type of source: the war diary of the motor ambulance convoy that carried the wounded from that part of the front in September and October 1918 (1). How it might help: the diary would record the journeys made each day, how long they took and any delays from shelled or crowded roads, so it would show whether four and a half hours was typical (1). e.g. Detail: 'They took me to the X-ray room and then to the operating-tent that night' (1). Question: How many hours after being wounded were most soldiers operated on at a casualty clearing station? (1). Type of source: articles by army surgeons in the British Medical Journal or The Lancet in 1917-18 on the treatment of wounds at casualty clearing stations (1). How it might help: surgeons often reported how many hours after being wounded their patients arrived and were operated on, because early operation prevented infection, so the articles would show how quickly men usually reached surgery (1). e.g. Detail: 'the road was very bumpy' (1). Question: What slowed down the ambulances taking wounded men back to the casualty clearing stations? (1). Type of source: the diary or letters of a motor ambulance driver serving in 1918 (1). How it might help: a driver would describe the roads, the traffic and any shelling on each journey and how long it took, so they would show the causes of delay (1). (No mark for a question that is not linked to following up Source A, e.g. 'because it would be an interesting question to ask'.) Accept other appropriate alternatives.

  2. 1 mark

    An appropriate follow-up question linked to the detail chosen and to how quickly the wounded reached a casualty clearing station for treatment, e.g. How long did it usually take to move the wounded to a casualty clearing station? / What slowed down the ambulances? / How many hours after being wounded were men operated on? / Did the advance of autumn 1918 make the journeys longer?

    The question must follow up the chosen detail and stay within the enquiry (how quickly the wounded reached a casualty clearing station and treatment). Do not credit a question addressed to the author (e.g. 'Why was Scott near the front line?'), a question about Scott's own recovery or life, or a question about the fighting at Cambrai that is not about how quickly the wounded were moved and treated.

  3. 1 mark

    An appropriate type of source that could help answer the question, e.g. the war diary of a motor ambulance convoy or field ambulance for 1918 / the admission and discharge register of a casualty clearing station / articles by army surgeons in the British Medical Journal or The Lancet on wounds treated at casualty clearing stations / the diary or letters of a motor ambulance driver / official photographs of ambulances and roads in 1918.

    Credit a specific type of source that existed at the time and could contain the information needed for the question asked. Do not credit vague answers such as 'a book', 'the internet', 'medical records' or 'a diary' with no indication of whose or what it contains, unless the explanation makes clear what specific information it contains. Do not credit modern histories, documentaries or interviews. If the question is not valid, a source chosen to answer it cannot be credited.

  4. 1 mark

    An explanation of how the information in the chosen source could help answer the question, e.g. a motor ambulance convoy's war diary would record how long journeys took and why there were delays / a casualty clearing station's admission register would show when men were admitted and where they were sent next / surgeons' articles would show how many hours after wounding men were operated on / a driver's diary would describe the roads and the delays.

    The explanation must say what information the chosen source would contain and how that would answer the question. Do not credit 'it would tell me the answer' or an explanation that does not match the source or the question.

Question 4

8 marks

Study Sources A and B.

Source A: From an official despatch written by General Sir Douglas Haig, Commander-in-Chief of the British armies in France, dated 23 December 1916 and published in the London Gazette on 29 December 1916. Here he is writing about the work of the medical services during the Battle of the Somme.

The losses entailed by the constant fighting threw a specially heavy strain on the Medical Services. This has been met with the greatest zeal and efficiency. The gallantry and devotion with which officers and men of the regimental medical service and Field Ambulances have discharged their duties is shown by the large number of the R.A.M.C. and Medical Corps of the Dominions who have fallen in the Field. The work of the Medical Services behind the front has been no less arduous. The untiring professional zeal and marked ability of the surgical specialists and consulting surgeons, combined with the skill and devotion of the medical and nursing staffs, both at the Casualty Clearing Stations in the Field and the Stationary and General Hospitals at the Base, have been beyond praise. In this respect also the Director General has on many occasions expressed to me the immense help the British Red Cross Society have been to him in assisting the R.A.M.C. in their work.

Source B: From A Surgeon in Khaki by Arthur Anderson Martin, published in 1915. Martin was a New Zealand surgeon who joined the RAMC in 1914 and served with a field ambulance and in hospitals in France and Belgium. Here he is writing about the surgical equipment of the field ambulances and clearing hospitals in 1914.

The Field Ambulance carries a complete hospital emergency equipment. Theoretically, if necessary a serious abdominal operation, a trephining operation [an operation on the skull], or an amputation could be carried out at an ambulance station by skilled surgeons surrounded by the latest and best of surgical instruments and in antiseptic surroundings. I said theoretically, but as a matter of fact such a state of affairs is not achieved, and the surgery performed at Field Ambulance stations is crude and temporary. A Field Ambulance station is a first-aid station, and surgery is avoided as much as possible. The equipment of our Field Ambulance to-day leaves very much to be desired, and I earnestly hope that during this war the whole organisation will be thoroughly reviewed, reorganised, and remodelled, and that there will be evolved a medical unit more in consonance with the modern conceptions of good clean surgery. ... It was not the military authorities who were to blame. The military chiefs did all they could to help the medical department and always have done so. The fault lay at the door of the Royal Army Medical Corps chiefs, and after the war these things will again be reviewed in order to prevent a future repetition.

How useful are Sources A and B for an enquiry into the quality of the medical care provided by the RAMC on the Western Front? Explain your answer, using Sources A and B and your knowledge of the historical context.

Model answer

Source A is useful because it shows how the medical services were judged by the army's commander after the Battle of the Somme. Haig says the losses 'threw a specially heavy strain' on the medical services but that this was met 'with the greatest zeal and efficiency', and he praises the surgeons and nurses at the casualty clearing stations and base hospitals. The fact that many RAMC men had 'fallen in the Field' shows that regimental medical officers and field ambulances worked close to the fighting. However, this is an official despatch published in the London Gazette for the public, and its purpose was to praise the army after a battle with about 420,000 British and Empire casualties, so it gives no figures and mentions no problems, even though on 1 July 1916 the casualty clearing stations were overwhelmed and many wounded lay waiting in the open. Haig was also not a medical expert. It is useful for the official view and for the strain on the service, but not for judging the quality of care in detail.

Source B is useful because it was written by an expert. Martin, a surgeon who worked in a field ambulance in 1914, says that surgery there was 'crude and temporary' and that the equipment 'leaves very much to be desired', blaming the 'Royal Army Medical Corps chiefs'. This fits what I know about 1914, when the army's medical services had been planned for a short war of movement and wounds became badly infected in the farmland of France and Flanders. However, Martin wrote in 1915 to push for reform, so he concentrates on faults, and he only describes 1914. By 1916 serious surgery had moved to the better-equipped casualty clearing stations, partly answering his criticisms.

Overall, Source B is more useful for the quality of care early in the war, while Source A shows how the RAMC was presented officially by 1916; used together, they suggest that the quality of care improved.

Explanation

To reach Level 3, explain how the purpose of each source affects what it can tell us: Haig's despatch was written to praise the army after the Somme, while Martin wrote in 1915 to expose problems and push for reform. Use precise context, such as the overcrowded casualty clearing stations of July 1916 or the move of major surgery to the casualty clearing stations from 1915, to test what each source says. Avoid simply saying that one source is biased and the other is not: both are useful for different parts of the enquiry.

Mark scheme
  1. 8 marks

    Levels of response (8 marks). AO3: 8 marks.
    Level 3 (6-8 marks): Judgements on source utility for the specified enquiry are given, applying valid criteria with developed reasoning which takes into account how the provenance affects the usefulness of the source content. The sources are analysed to support reasoning about their utility. Contextual knowledge is used in the process of interpreting the sources and applying criteria for judgements on their utility.
    Level 2 (3-5 marks): Judgements on source utility for the specified enquiry are given, using valid criteria. Judgements are supported by developed comment related to the content of the sources and/or their provenance. Comprehension and some analysis of the sources is shown by the selection and use of material to support comments on their utility. Contextual knowledge is used directly to support comments on the usefulness of the content of the sources and/or their provenance.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple judgement on utility is given, and supported by undeveloped comment on the content of the sources and/or their provenance. Simple comprehension of the source material is shown by the extraction or paraphrase of some content. Limited contextual knowledge is deployed with links to the sources.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.
    Note: Provenance = nature, origin, purpose. No credit may be given for contextual knowledge unless it is linked to evaluation of the sources. No credit may be given for generic comments on provenance which are not used to evaluate source content.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Source A (Haig). Content: the heavy losses of the Somme put great strain on the medical services, which Haig says was met with zeal and efficiency; many RAMC and Dominion medical personnel were killed in the field, showing that regimental medical officers and field ambulances worked close to the fighting; surgical specialists, consulting surgeons and nurses at casualty clearing stations and base hospitals are praised; the Red Cross helped. Provenance: an official despatch by the Commander-in-Chief, published in the London Gazette for the public; Haig commanded the whole army and received reports from the Director General of Medical Services, so he knew the organisation; but his purpose was to report success and praise the troops after a battle with enormous losses, so it is general and one-sided, with no figures and no problems, and Haig was not a medical expert. Context: the Battle of the Somme lasted from 1 July to 18 November 1916, with about 420,000 British and Empire casualties (about 57,000 on 1 July); on the first day casualty clearing stations were overwhelmed and many wounded lay waiting; but by 1916 there were motor ambulance convoys, many more ambulance trains, consulting surgeons and surgical teams at casualty clearing stations; in the whole war over 6,800 RAMC officers and men were killed. Source B (Martin). Content: field ambulances had emergency equipment but surgery there was 'crude and temporary' and avoided where possible; the equipment 'leaves very much to be desired'; the whole organisation needed reform; he blames the RAMC chiefs, not the army's commanders. Provenance: a qualified surgeon who worked in a field ambulance and clearing hospitals in 1914, so an expert eyewitness; a civilian surgeon in a wartime post, perhaps critical of the regular RAMC's leaders; written in 1915 to push for reform, so he highlights faults; it covers only 1914. Context: in 1914 the medical services were planned for a short war of movement; wounds in the manured farmland of France and Flanders became badly infected (gas gangrene); from 1915 major surgery moved to the casualty clearing stations, which gained nurses, better equipment and specialist surgeons; later developments (the Thomas splint, mobile x-ray units, blood transfusion) suggest reforms of the kind he wanted. Limits and judgement: Source A shows the official view and the strain in 1916 but little about the actual quality of care; Source B is expert and detailed about early weaknesses but limited to 1914; together they suggest the quality of care improved between 1914 and 1916. Do not credit 'Haig is biased' unless the answer explains how this affects the content.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.