Question 1
4 marksSource A: A poster published in October 1929 by the Reich Committee for the German People's Petition, a group of nationalist organisations, including the DNVP and the Nazi Party, that campaigned against the Young Plan. The caption has been translated for this course.
It shows a grinning, bare-chested man with a whip raised above his head, standing on top of a stone post. Long wooden bars are fixed to the post. Three figures - a stooping older man, a strong younger man and a thin, barefoot boy - are bent over as they push the bars round and round the post; the boy is tied to his bar with a rope. Large red lettering at the top and bottom of the poster reads: 'You will have to slave until the third generation!' Small print at the bottom gives the dates for signing the petition: 16 to 29 October 1929.
Give two things you can infer from Source A about opposition to the Young Plan in 1929.
Set out your answer under these headings, once for each inference:
What I can infer:
Details in the source that tell me this:
Model answer
What I can infer: Opponents argued that the Young Plan would leave Germans paying reparations for decades, so their children and grandchildren would suffer too.
Details in the source that tell me this: The caption says Germans 'will have to slave until the third generation', and an old man, a younger man and a boy are all working.
What I can infer: The campaign stirred up anger by presenting reparations as slavery imposed by a cruel master, rather than by explaining the plan's terms.
Details in the source that tell me this: A grinning man with a raised whip stands over the three bent figures, and the boy is tied to his bar with a rope.
Explanation
Top answers infer what the poster reveals about the opponents' arguments and methods and support each inference with a specific detail of the image or caption. A common mistake is to describe the picture ('there is a man with a whip') without saying what it suggests. Another is to write own knowledge about the referendum or the terms of the Young Plan, which is not an inference from the source.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid inference about opposition to the Young Plan in 1929, e.g. opponents claimed the plan would keep Germany paying reparations for generations / opponents presented reparations as slavery forced on Germans by a cruel master / the campaign tried to stir up anger and fear rather than discuss the plan's details / opponents wanted to appeal to Germans of every age and to families / the opposition was organising a mass petition to force a vote on the plan.
Award 1 mark for each valid inference up to a maximum of two inferences. The second mark for each example should be awarded for supporting detail selected from the source. e.g. Opponents claimed that the plan would keep Germany paying reparations for generations (1). The caption says Germans 'will have to slave until the third generation'; an old man, a man and a boy are all forced to work (1). Opponents presented reparations as slavery forced on Germans by a cruel (perhaps foreign) master (1). A grinning man with a raised whip stands over the three bent figures; the boy is tied to his bar with a rope (1). The campaign relied on stirring up emotions such as anger and fear rather than on arguments about the plan's terms (1). The poster uses a violent image and a dramatic caption and gives no facts or figures about the plan (1). Opponents wanted to win the support of Germans of all ages, especially families worried about their children's future (1). The three figures are an old man, a younger man and a boy (1). The opposition was organising a mass campaign to force a public vote on the plan (1). The poster gives 'the dates for signing the petition', 16 to 29 October 1929 (1). The endless circling suggests opponents claimed the payments would never end or achieve anything for Germany (1). The figures push the bars 'round and round the post' (1). An inference must go beyond what the source says: 'the poster shows a man with a whip' or 'it says Germans will slave' is description, not inference, and earns no mark. Inferences must be about opposition to the Young Plan; own knowledge (e.g. that the referendum failed in December 1929, or that payments were to last until 1988) is not an inference from the source, though it may help a student to understand it. Accept other appropriate alternatives.
-
1 mark
Supporting detail selected from Source A that supports the first inference, e.g. the caption 'You will have to slave until the third generation!' / the man with the raised whip / the old man, the younger man and the boy / the boy tied with a rope / the bars pushed round and round the post / the dates for signing the petition.
Award only if the first inference has been credited and the detail genuinely supports it (a detail of the image, the caption or the provenance). A detail that does not support the inference given, or information from own knowledge, earns no mark.
-
1 mark
A second valid inference about opposition to the Young Plan, different from the first (see the examples under the first inference).
The second inference must be a different point, not the first one reworded (e.g. 'the plan would last a long time' and 'Germans would pay for many years' are the same inference). Apply the same rules: no credit for description or own knowledge.
-
1 mark
Supporting detail selected from Source A that supports the second inference.
Award only if the second inference has been credited and the detail from Source A supports it.