Question 1
4 marksSource B: From a report on the mood of workers in central Germany, printed in the September 1938 issue of the 'Germany Reports' of the Social Democratic Party (SPD) (translated for this course). The SPD had been banned in 1933. Its leaders in exile published these reports, without the names of their authors, based on information sent secretly by supporters inside Germany.
Among industrial workers there are many who no longer care about the successes of the Hitler system and have nothing but scorn and mockery for the whole show. Others say: 'Well, Adolf himself doesn't know about a lot of things and doesn't want a lot of things.' But with them you never know whether they mean it seriously or only want to cover themselves. Of course, very many have also become completely unpolitical. A large proportion of the skilled workers who were unemployed for a long time, in particular, are not enthusiastic Nazis. They often complain, too, that they now earn much less than in about 1929, but the end of the story is always: 'We don't care about anything; at least we have work.' - The further down you go into the poorer classes, the greater the opposition. But even today - although people know that there is a shortage of workers - everyone is deeply afraid of losing their job. The years of unemployment have not been forgotten. ...
The mood in the factories is depressed. ... Now people go into the factory with a heavy heart, if only because they must always be afraid of saying one word too many and getting into trouble. A weight presses on the whole of life.
Source C: A photograph taken in 1938 at a Christmas party for the families of workers at the Mercedes-Benz car company. The words on the notice board have been translated for this course.
In the photograph, women and children sit at long tables with cups, plates of cake and wrapped presents. A man dressed as Father Christmas, with a long white beard, stands on the left. On the wall behind them is a large notice board headed 'Here speaks the German Labour Front', with a section headed 'Strength through Joy!' that includes a poster with a picture of a car and the letters 'KdF'. Several men in dark uniforms and caps stand at the sides of the room, and there is a Christmas tree on the right.
Interpretation 1: From Bread and Work: The German Worker under Hitler by Martin Oakhurst (fictional), published in 1992.
For most German workers, the Nazi years meant something they had not known since 1929: a secure job. After the misery of the Depression, men who had queued for months at the labour exchange were back at work, and many were grateful. The German Labour Front did not let workers bargain over wages, but it gave them other things: cheap holidays, outings and theatre trips through Strength through Joy, cleaner canteens and washrooms through Beauty of Labour, and works celebrations at which managers and workers sat together. By 1938 thousands of workers were saving for a People's Car. Workers still grumbled about prices and long hours, but there were almost no strikes. Many workers had been won over to the 'national community', at least for the time being.
Interpretation 2: From The Silent Factory: Workers and the Nazi Dictatorship by Pauline Tarrant (fictional), published in 2015.
The German working class was never won over by Nazism. Workers lost their trade unions and the right to strike in 1933, wages were held down while hours grew longer, and the Labour Front's promises of cars and cruises meant little to most families. Many workers had voted for the SPD or the KPD, and they did not forget it. Yet they kept quiet. Every factory had its informers, and anyone who complained too loudly could lose his job or be handed over to the Gestapo. Memories of unemployment made men cling to their jobs. Workers therefore withdrew into private life: they did their work, avoided politics and saved their real opinions for trusted friends. Their silence was a sign of fear and exhaustion, not of support.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about the attitudes of German workers towards Hitler's regime. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
One reason is that the historians have given weight to different sources. Interpretation 1 stresses what workers gained, such as 'outings and theatre trips through Strength through Joy' and 'works celebrations', and says many workers 'had been won over'. This is supported by Source C, which shows workers' families enjoying a Christmas party in front of a German Labour Front notice board advertising Strength through Joy and the KdF car. Interpretation 2 argues that workers 'kept quiet' out of fear and that 'Memories of unemployment made men cling to their jobs'. This is supported by Source B, the SPD report, which says many workers are 'not enthusiastic Nazis', that 'everyone is deeply afraid of losing their job' and that they fear 'saying one word too many'. So the author of Interpretation 1 may have relied on evidence like Source C, while the author of Interpretation 2 relied on secret reports like Source B.
Explanation
Top answers give one clear reason and support it by matching specific details in the interpretations to details in the sources, for example the Labour Front Christmas party in Source C with the 'works celebrations' in Interpretation 1. Weaker answers simply state that one author 'used Source B', or repeat the difference between the views without explaining why it exists. Comments about the dates of the books do not explain the difference.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the authors have given weight to different sources. Source C, showing workers' families at a works Christmas party run under a German Labour Front notice board advertising 'Strength through Joy' and the KdF car, gives some support to Interpretation 1's 'works celebrations', Strength through Joy and saving 'for a People's Car', and its view that many workers 'had been won over'. Source B, a secret SPD report, gives some support to Interpretation 2: workers are 'not enthusiastic Nazis', earn 'much less than in about 1929', are 'deeply afraid of losing their job' and fear 'saying one word too many', which matches 'Memories of unemployment made men cling to their jobs', the informers and 'fear and exhaustion'. Source B also contains material that fits Interpretation 1 ('at least we have work'), so an author could select from it in either direction. The interpretations may differ because of a different emphasis or focus: Interpretation 1 focuses on what workers gained (jobs, leisure, better workplaces) and the absence of strikes; Interpretation 2 focuses on what workers lost (unions, the right to strike, wages) and on their private opinions behind their public silence. They may differ in how they interpret the same evidence: both mention grumbling or silence and the end of unemployment, but Interpretation 1 reads quiet as acceptance while Interpretation 2 reads it as fear. Level 2 needs one reason explained and substantiated from the interpretations (and, where used, the sources). Do not credit reasons based only on the dates of publication or the titles of the books, or bare claims that a historian is biased. Do not credit an answer that only describes the difference between the views (that is a different question).