Question 1
4 marksInterpretation 1: From Surrender Without a Fight: German Parties in 1933 by Rupert Inglesant (fictional), published in 1994.
Most of Germany's political parties were not destroyed in 1933; they gave up. After the Enabling Act, the Reichstag no longer mattered, and the parties had lost their purpose. Their members drifted away, and many joined the Nazi Party in the rush of spring 1933. The nationalist DNVP, Hitler's partner in government, dissolved itself at the end of June, and the liberal parties soon followed. The Centre Party, hoping that the negotiations between the Vatican and Hitler's government would protect the Catholic Church, announced its own dissolution on 5 July. By the time the law of 14 July declared the Nazis the only legal party, there was almost nothing left to ban.
Interpretation 2: From Crushing the Opposition, 1933 by Esther Dunkeld (fictional), published in 2012.
The other parties did not simply fade away; they were broken by force. The Communist Party was hunted down after the Reichstag Fire, its offices were seized and thousands of its members were sent to the new concentration camps. The Social Democrats' property was seized in May, and in June the party was banned outright. Leaders of other parties were arrested or threatened, and SA violence continued across the country. When the remaining parties dissolved themselves in late June and early July, they did so with the fate of the Communists and Social Democrats in front of them. Their 'voluntary' decisions were made under the threat of the same treatment.
Study Interpretations 1 and 2. They give different views about why the other political parties disappeared so quickly in 1933. What is the main difference between these views? Explain your answer, using details from both interpretations.
Model answer
The main difference is about why the parties disappeared. Interpretation 1 argues that most parties 'gave up' rather than being destroyed. It says that after the Enabling Act they had 'lost their purpose', that their members 'drifted away' or joined the Nazis, and that parties such as the DNVP and the Centre dissolved themselves, so that by July 'there was almost nothing left to ban'. Interpretation 2, by contrast, argues that the parties 'were broken by force'. It stresses that the Communists were 'hunted down' and sent to concentration camps, that the Social Democrats were 'banned outright' and that other parties' leaders were 'arrested or threatened'. It sees their 'voluntary' dissolution as made under threat. So Interpretation 1 emphasises the parties' own weakness and choices, while Interpretation 2 emphasises Nazi terror.
Explanation
Top answers state the overall difference of view, here the parties' own weakness and choices versus destruction by force, and support it with a detail from each interpretation. Answers that list details from each interpretation in turn without saying how the views differ, or that only point out that the interpretations mention different parties, stay in Level 1.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): The interpretations are analysed and a key difference of view is identified and supported from them.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Limited analysis of the interpretations is shown by the extraction or paraphrase of some content, but differences of surface detail only are given, or a difference of view is asserted without direct support.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The main difference is about why the parties disappeared. Interpretation 1 argues that most parties were not destroyed but 'gave up': after the Enabling Act they had 'lost their purpose', their members 'drifted away' or joined the Nazis, and the DNVP, the liberals and the Centre dissolved themselves (the Centre hoping to protect the Catholic Church), so that by 14 July 'there was almost nothing left to ban'. Interpretation 2 argues that they 'were broken by force': the Communists were 'hunted down' and sent to concentration camps, the Social Democrats were 'banned outright', leaders of other parties were 'arrested or threatened', and the remaining parties' 'voluntary' decisions were made 'under the threat of the same treatment'. Level 2 needs this difference of view (the parties' own weakness and choices v. Nazi force and terror) supported from both interpretations. Answers that only give surface differences (e.g. 'Interpretation 1 mentions the Centre Party and Interpretation 2 mentions the Communists', 'one mentions 5 July') or that summarise each interpretation in turn without stating the difference stay in Level 1. Do not credit an answer that says Interpretation 1 denies that any force was used: it says 'most' parties gave up, and its focus is on their choices. Do not credit explanations of why the historians differ (that is a different question).