Question 1
4 marksSource B: From the Editors' Law, issued by Hitler's government on 4 October 1933. The law applied to everyone who helped to shape the contents of German newspapers and political magazines. This English translation was published by the US government in 1946.
Section 5
Persons who can be editors are only those who:
1. possess the German citizenship,
...
3. are of Aryan descent, and are not married to a person of non-Aryan descent.
...
7. have the qualities which the task of exerting intellectual influence upon the public requires.
...
Section 14
Editors are especially bound to keep out of the newspapers anything which:
1. in any manner is misleading to the public, mixes selfish aims with community aims
2. tends to weaken the strength of the German Reich, outwardly or inwardly, the common will of the German people, the German defense ability, culture or economy, or offends the religious sentiments of others,
...
Section 35
The Reich Minister for Public Enlightenment and Propaganda may decree the removal of an editor from the professional list independent of the proceedings of the Professional Court, if he deems it necessary for pressing reasons of public welfare.
Source C: From a report in the National-Zeitung, a Nazi Party newspaper published in Essen, 10 August 1938 (translated for this course). It describes the annual meeting of people working in German radio, which was held in Berlin during the city's radio exhibition.
This year's annual meeting of German radio ... received its special motto from Dr Goebbels in his words 'Germany must become the strongest radio country in the world'.
First, Reich Director of Broadcasting Glasmeier spoke on the main principles of German radio programmes. What matters is that the basic attitude of radio is National Socialist. ...
On the problem, so much discussed among all groups of listeners, of whether to prefer light entertainment music or great artistic performances, Reich Director Glasmeier declared that radio had kept to a healthy middle course here and would continue to do so in future. ...
[Hans Kriegler, the President of the Reich Radio Chamber, said that] today, on average across the Reich, about 54 per cent of households were connected to the radio network. Of the remainder, a relatively small part would stay away from radio out of lack of interest. But the majority of the population had so far not been able, for financial reasons, to pay 65 Reichsmarks for the People's Receiver and on top of that the radio licence fee of 2 Reichsmarks a month.
Interpretation 1: From Gleichschaltung: The Coordination of German Life by Trevor Quantock (fictional), published in 1981.
Within two years the Nazis had brought the German media under complete control. The Editors' Law of October 1933 made every journalist responsible to the state rather than to his employer, and Jewish and left-wing journalists were driven out of their profession. Each day the Propaganda Ministry's press conference told editors what to report and what to leave out, so that newspapers across the country printed the same stories in almost the same words. Radio was even easier to control, because it was already largely owned by the state. Goebbels purged its staff, placed it under his ministry and made sure that the new People's Receivers carried the regime's message into millions of homes. No independent voice remained.
Interpretation 2: From Reading Between the Lines by Sylvia Rendcombe (fictional), published in 2016.
The regime's control of the media was never as complete as it claimed. Germans quickly tired of newspapers that all said the same thing, and many cancelled their subscriptions; in 1934 even Goebbels urged editors to make their papers less monotonous. A few papers, such as the Frankfurter Zeitung, were allowed to keep a more independent tone to reassure readers at home and abroad. Radio was a powerful weapon, but in 1938 only around half of German households owned a set, and the regime had to fill most of the airtime with music and light entertainment to keep listeners at all. People who wanted other news could still tune in to foreign stations, and many did.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about how far the Nazis controlled the press and radio in the years 1933-39. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
One reason why the interpretations differ is that the historians have given weight to different sources. Interpretation 1 argues that the Editors' Law 'made every journalist responsible to the state' and that Jewish and left-wing journalists were driven out, so that 'no independent voice remained'. This is supported by Source B, the Editors' Law itself, which allowed only people 'of Aryan descent' to be editors, ordered them to keep out anything that might 'weaken the strength of the German Reich', and let the Propaganda Minister remove any editor. Interpretation 2 instead stresses the limits of control, saying that 'only around half' of households owned a radio and that the regime had to offer 'music and light entertainment'. This matches Source C, which reports that only 'about 54 per cent of households' had a radio, that most others could not afford one, and that listeners argued about 'light entertainment music'.
Explanation
Top answers give one clear reason and support it by matching details from both interpretations and both sources, as in the link between Source C's '54 per cent' and Interpretation 2's 'only around half'. Weaker answers repeat the difference in views, which is a different question, or simply assert that one author 'used Source B'. Comments about the dates of publication are not valid reasons unless they are supported from the interpretations.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the authors have given weight to different sources. Source B, a law that allowed only those 'of Aryan descent' to be editors, bound editors to 'keep out of the newspapers anything which ... tends to weaken the strength of the German Reich' and let the Propaganda Minister order 'the removal of an editor', gives support to Interpretation 1's view that the Editors' Law 'made every journalist responsible to the state' and drove out 'Jewish and left-wing journalists', so that 'no independent voice remained'. Source C, which says that only 'about 54 per cent of households' had a radio, that most of the rest could not afford 'the People's Receiver' and the licence fee, and that listeners argued about 'light entertainment music' versus serious performances, gives some support to Interpretation 2's view that 'only around half' of households owned a set and that the regime had to provide 'music and light entertainment to keep listeners'. (Source C also shows the regime's aim that radio's 'basic attitude' be 'National Socialist', which a historian could use for Interpretation 1.) The interpretations may differ because they focus on different things: Interpretation 1 on the laws, institutions and aims of the regime (the controls placed on the media); Interpretation 2 on how readers and listeners actually responded (cancelled subscriptions, foreign stations). They may differ because of emphasis: Interpretation 1 stresses the speed and completeness of coordination; Interpretation 2 stresses its limits and the regime's need to adapt. Level 2 needs a reason for the difference explained and substantiated with details from the interpretations (and, if the sources are used, matching details from the sources). Do not credit answers that only repeat the difference itself (that is a different question), or that explain it by the dates of publication or the titles without evidence, or that simply say 'the author of Interpretation 1 used Source B' without matching details.