'Bhagavan is the most important of the three features of the divine.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Hindu teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many Hindus, especially Vaishnavas, would agree that Bhagavan is the most important feature. Bhagavan is the personal, loving God, and for Vaishnavas, including ISKCON, he is Vishnu or Krishna. In the Bhagavad Gita Krishna says, 'I am the embodiment of the Brahman' (14.27), which Vaishnavas understand to mean that non-personal Brahman is like the light shining from him. He also calls himself the highest person, beyond both the perishable world and the imperishable souls (15.17-18). So Bhagavan is not one feature among three but includes the others: the same Lord pervades the universe and sits in every heart. Most importantly, only a personal God can be loved and can love in return. Krishna tells Arjuna, 'you are dear to me' (18.65), and the bhakti that flows from this relationship is the heart of daily worship for millions of Hindus.
However, other Hindus would strongly disagree. Followers of Advaita Vedanta, the school of Shankara, believe that the non-personal Brahman is the highest truth. They value worship of a personal God, but see it as the way Brahman appears to us within the everyday world of maya; the final goal is to realise that the atman is Brahman, which is beyond all qualities - 'neti neti', not this, not this. For them Brahman, not Bhagavan, is most important. Others might argue that Paramatma, God within the heart, matters most in practice, because it is God as witness and guide who shapes a Hindu's conscience, comforts them in suffering and is found in meditation.
It can also be argued that the question itself is mistaken. The Bhagavata Purana (1.2.11) teaches that the one non-dual reality is called Brahman, Paramatma and Bhagavan; these are three ways of experiencing one God rather than three rivals to be ranked. Many Shaivas would say that Shiva is everywhere, within the heart and the loving Lord all at once.
In conclusion, I think Bhagavan is the most important feature for Vaishnava and devotional Hindus, and the Bhagavad Gita gives them strong support. But it is not the most important for all Hindus, since Advaitins put Brahman first. Because the Bhagavata Purana itself describes one reality seen in three ways, the most convincing view is that the importance of each feature depends on the path a Hindu follows - knowledge, meditation or devotion - rather than one feature being more important for everyone.
Explanation
Top-level answers set out the Vaishnava case for Bhagavan using sources such as Bhagavad Gita 14.27 and 18.65 and weigh it against Advaita's view of Brahman, possibly adding the importance of Paramatma in daily life. The conclusion should judge whether ranking the features makes sense, for example in the light of Bhagavata Purana 1.2.11.