'Diwali is more important to Hindus in Britain as a cultural celebration than as a religious festival.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Hindu teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some people would agree that, in Britain, Diwali is mainly a cultural celebration. The largest Diwali events, such as the lights on Belgrave Road in Leicester or Diwali on the Square in Trafalgar Square, are public festivals with lights, performances and food stalls, enjoyed by many people who are not Hindus. Sikhs and Jains also celebrate at this time for their own religious reasons, so Diwali has become a shared South Asian festival, and schools, councils and businesses often mark it as a celebration of diversity. For many young British Hindus, Diwali may mean family gatherings, new clothes, sweets and fireworks more than worship, and for a minority community it is an important way to show pride in its heritage.
However, many Hindus would argue that Diwali is above all a religious festival. On Diwali night families gather at the home shrine for Lakshmi puja, and thousands visit mandirs for darshan and arati; at the BAPS mandir in Neasden hundreds of vegetarian dishes are offered to the deities at the Annakut on Hindu New Year. The festival's stories, such as Rama and Sita's return in the Ramayana, teach dharma and the victory of good over evil, which the Bhagavad Gita (4.7-8) says God comes into the world to protect. The lamps express the teaching that God destroys the darkness of ignorance with the lamp of knowledge (Gita 10.11). Even the 'cultural' customs have religious roots: rangoli and lamps welcome Lakshmi, and sweets are first offered as prasad.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Diwali in Britain clearly has an important cultural side, and the public events help Hindus share their festival with others. But the cultural customs grow out of religious beliefs, and for many Hindus, who see their faith as a whole way of life (sanatana dharma), culture and religion cannot be separated. Diwali matters to them most because of the worship and teaching at its heart.
Explanation
High-level answers weigh the public, cultural side of Diwali in Britain (with examples such as Leicester or Trafalgar Square) against its worship and teachings, and question whether culture and religion can be separated in Hinduism. Applying teachings such as Bhagavad Gita 10.11 to the lamps lifts an answer. Purely descriptive answers about how Diwali is celebrated stay in the lower levels.