'The atman is identical to Brahman.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Hindu teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many Hindus, especially followers of Advaita Vedanta, would agree that the atman is identical to Brahman. The great teacher Shankara taught that Brahman is the only ultimate reality, so the true self of every being must be Brahman. The Upanishads seem to support this: in the Chandogya Upanishad (6.8.7) the sage Uddalaka tells his son 'tat tvam asi' ('That art thou'), meaning that his inner self is the ultimate reality, and the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad (1.4.10) declares 'aham brahmasmi' ('I am Brahman'). Advaitins explain that we feel separate only because of maya and ignorance (avidya), just as the space inside a pot seems separate from the space outside until the pot is broken. Moksha is the realisation of this truth, which the Mundaka Upanishad (3.2.8) describes as rivers flowing into the sea and losing their names.
However, other Hindus disagree. Madhva, the founder of Dvaita Vedanta, taught that the atman and God (Vishnu) are eternally distinct: the soul depends on God completely, but it can never become God. Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita teaches that souls are real parts of Brahman, like the body of God, so they are one with Brahman in one sense but still different. In the Bhagavad Gita (15.7), Krishna calls the living being an eternal portion of himself, and a part is not the same as the whole. The Mundaka Upanishad (3.1.1-2) pictures two birds in one tree, one eating the fruit and grieving, the other, the Lord, simply watching, which suggests that the individual self and God are different. A strong argument is that the atman can be trapped by ignorance and karma, whereas Brahman is all-knowing and never bound. Devotional Hindus also point out that love for God needs a relationship between two.
In conclusion, I think the statement is true only from one Hindu point of view. Advaita offers a powerful reading of the Upanishads, but the Vaishnava argument that the soul is an eternal part of God seems more convincing to me, because it explains why the atman can suffer in samsara while Brahman cannot. Since most Hindus agree that the atman shares Brahman's spiritual nature, I would say the atman is like Brahman in quality but not identical to it.
Explanation
This statement needs knowledge of different Hindu schools: the strongest answers set Advaita teaching (tat tvam asi) against Dvaita and Vishishtadvaita views and apply scripture to each. Reach a justified conclusion, for example by weighing which view better explains why the atman is bound in samsara. Avoid presenting the Advaita view as what all Hindus believe.